ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Titanium Ceramic Particle Reinforced Iron-Based Cladding Alloy: Microstructure and Wear Resistance

Introduction and Context

The paper by Zhu Shuzhi, Jia Hua and colleagues from Dalian Ocean University addresses a topic that is close to my heart: hardfacing. In the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, we use hardfacing for a wide range of applications, from drill pipe tool joints to mud pump liners, from valve seats to chute liners. The authors have investigated the effect of adding 4% titanium to a Fe-Cr-C-B-N iron-based alloy, using open-arc surfacing on Q235 steel. The goal is to produce in-situ titanium carbide, titanium boride and titanium nitride particles that reinforce the matrix and improve wear resistance. This is a classic metallurgical problem: how do you get hard, stable particles to form in a matrix that is tough enough to withstand impact? The authors have done a good job of characterising the microstructure and linking it to the wear performance. The results are promising, and the paper provides a useful reference for anyone working on wear-resistant cladding.

Microstructural Analysis and Phase Identification

The authors used optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, Rockwell hardness testing and a wear testing machine. The results show that the Fe-Cr-C-B-N-Ti alloy consists of lath martensite, a small amount of retained austenite, and a range of hard phases: TiC, TiB2, TiN, M23(C,B)6, M3(C,B) and M2B. The titanium-containing phases are irregular, fine particles that are uniformly dispersed. The primary austenite grains are refined, and lath martensite forms within them. The eutectic structure is a discontinuous network, and the hard phases in the eutectic are more evenly distributed than in the alloy without titanium. This is a significant finding because the distribution of hard phases is critical for wear resistance. If the hard phases are clustered, they will spall out during wear. If they are uniformly distributed, they will provide a consistent wear surface.

The following table summarises the phases identified in the two alloys.

Phase Fe-Cr-C-B-N (No Ti) Fe-Cr-C-B-N-Ti (4% Ti) Role in Wear Resistance
Martensite (lath) Primary matrix Primary matrix, refined grains Provides hardness and toughness
Retained austenite Present Present, reduced Contributes to toughness, may transform to martensite under wear
TiC Absent Present, fine dispersed particles High hardness, excellent abrasive wear resistance
TiB2 Absent Present, fine dispersed particles Very high hardness, good thermal stability
TiN Absent Present, fine dispersed particles High hardness, good chemical stability
M23(C,B)6 Present Present, more uniform distribution Moderate hardness, contributes to wear resistance
M3(C,B) Present Present, more uniform distribution Moderate hardness, contributes to wear resistance
M2B Present Present, more uniform distribution High hardness, good wear resistance

The hardness of the titanium-containing alloy was 66 HRC, which is 5.3% higher than the alloy without titanium. The wear loss was 0.0429 g, which is 20.8% lower. This is a significant improvement. In my experience, a 20% reduction in wear loss is the difference between a chute liner that lasts two years and one that lasts two and a half years. In a mining operation, that is a real cost saving.

Wear Mechanism and Engineering Implications

The wear test was conducted using a sliding friction wear machine, which is a standard method for evaluating abrasive wear resistance. The results show that the wear mechanism is primarily abrasive wear, with micro-cutting by hard asperities. In the titanium-containing alloy, the fine TiC, TiB2 and TiN particles act as obstacles to the abrasive particles, reducing the depth of the cutting grooves. The refined microstructure also helps, because the lath martensite provides a tough matrix that holds the hard particles in place. The discontinuous eutectic network is beneficial because it prevents the hard phases from being pulled out in large chunks. Instead, they are worn away gradually, maintaining a relatively smooth wear surface.

For the steel pipe industry, this has direct applications in hardfacing of drill pipe tool joints, where the wear is caused by the rotation of the pipe against the casing. The standard hardfacing material is a tungsten carbide composite, which is expensive and difficult to apply. The titanium-containing iron-based alloy is cheaper and can be applied using open-arc surfacing, which is a well-established process. The key advantage is that the titanium reacts with the carbon, boron and nitrogen in the alloy to form the hard phases in-situ. This means there is no need for a separate carbide addition, which simplifies the process and reduces cost.

Process Considerations and Practical Lessons

The authors used open-arc surfacing, which is a simple and cost-effective process. However, it has some limitations that must be considered. The open arc produces a high heat input, which can cause dilution of the substrate. In this case, the substrate was Q235 steel, which has a low carbon content, so the dilution effect is manageable. In practice, I would recommend a dilution of less than 15% for this type of hardfacing. If the dilution is too high, the hard phases will not form properly and the wear resistance will be reduced. The authors did not report the dilution, but the hardness of 66 HRC suggests that it was within acceptable limits.

Another important consideration is the preheat and interpass temperature. For a high-chromium iron-based alloy, a preheat of 200–300 °C is recommended to prevent cracking. The authors did not mention preheat, which is a gap in the paper. In my experience, if you do not preheat a high-chromium hardfacing alloy, you will get cracking in the first layer. This is a practical issue that must be addressed in any production application.

The wear resistance of the titanium-containing alloy is impressive, but I would like to see data on impact wear as well. In many applications, such as chute liners and crusher hammers, the wear is a combination of abrasion and impact. The titanium-containing alloy has a hardness of 66 HRC, which is high, but the toughness may be a concern. The retained austenite provides some toughness, but if the impact energy is high, the hard particles may crack and spall. This is a topic for further research.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that are relevant to the practising engineer. First, what is the optimum titanium content? The authors used 4%, but the effect of higher or lower contents is not investigated. In my experience, the optimum is usually in the range of 3–5%. Above 5%, the titanium tends to form large, brittle particles that reduce toughness. Second, what is the effect of the substrate on the hardfacing? The authors used Q235 steel, which is a common structural steel. In practice, hardfacing is often applied to high-strength steels, such as 16Mn or 35CrMo. The higher carbon content of these steels can cause dilution problems, and the preheat requirements are different. Third, what is the effect of the welding process on the titanium recovery? In open-arc surfacing, the titanium can be oxidised, reducing the amount of TiC, TiB2 and TiN that forms. The authors did not measure the titanium recovery, but this is an important parameter for process control.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of hardfacing. The authors have demonstrated that the addition of 4% titanium to a Fe-Cr-C-B-N alloy results in a significant improvement in wear resistance, with a 20.8% reduction in wear loss and a 5.3% increase in hardness. The microstructural analysis is thorough, and the phase identification is convincing. The practical implication is that this alloy can be used for hardfacing applications where abrasive wear is the dominant failure mode, such as chute liners, hopper walls and conveyor components. The cost advantage over tungsten carbide composites is significant, and the process is simpler. However, the paper does not address the issue of impact wear, and the preheat requirement is not specified. These are practical issues that must be resolved before the alloy can be used in production. I would recommend that the authors conduct impact wear tests and provide guidance on preheat and interpass temperature. In the meantime, the paper is a useful reference for anyone considering a titanium-reinforced hardfacing alloy.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is well-structured and the results are clearly presented. The use of XRD for phase identification is appropriate, and the SEM images provide good evidence of the microstructure. The main limitation is the lack of impact wear data and the absence of preheat information. Future work should focus on optimising the titanium content, evaluating the effect of different substrates, and testing the alloy under impact-abrasion conditions. The potential applications in the steel pipe industry are significant, particularly for drill pipe tool joints and mud pump components. In my experience, the key to successful hardfacing is not just the alloy composition, but the process control. The open-arc surfacing process must be carefully controlled to maintain the correct dilution, preheat and interpass temperature. With the right process parameters, this alloy could be a cost-effective alternative to tungsten carbide composites. I would recommend that any company considering this alloy conduct a trial on a representative component, with full process control and wear testing, before committing to production.