ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

High-Chromium Bimetallic Wear-Resistant Plate Cladding: Microstructure and Sliding Friction Wear Performance

Introduction and Context

The paper by Liu Tianjun, Li Xintong and Wang Qingliang from Hebei Iron and Steel Group Mining and China University of Mining and Technology addresses a topic that is central to the mining and steel industries: wear-resistant plates. The authors have investigated the microstructure and sliding friction wear performance of a high-chromium bimetallic wear plate cladding, comparing it with a conventional martensitic wear-resistant steel. The cladding layer consists of Cr7C3 carbides, α-Fe and a small amount of Cr23C6 carbides. The wear tests were conducted under different loads (200 N and 600 N) and different environments (dry friction and quartz sand friction). The results show that the cladding layer has a lower wear mass loss and volume wear rate than the martensitic steel, and the wear mechanism is primarily abrasive wear. This is a practical paper that provides useful data for anyone selecting wear-resistant materials for chutes, hoppers and conveyor systems.

Microstructure and Hardness Distribution

The cladding layer is composed of Cr7C3 primary carbides, α-Fe matrix and a small amount of Cr23C6 carbides. The Cr7C3 carbides are hard and provide excellent abrasive wear resistance. The α-Fe matrix provides toughness and holds the carbides in place. The hardness distribution across the fusion zone shows a gradient, increasing from the base steel to the cladding layer. This is a typical feature of bimetallic wear plates, where the hardness of the base steel is low (around 200 HB) and the hardness of the cladding layer is high (around 55–60 HRC). The gradient is beneficial because it reduces the risk of spalling at the interface.

The following table summarises the hardness distribution and wear performance.

Parameter Cladding Layer (High-Cr) Martensitic Wear Steel
Hardness (cladding surface) 55–60 HRC 45–50 HRC
Hardness (base steel) ~200 HB ~300 HB (through thickness)
Friction coefficient (dry) 0.4–0.5 0.4–0.5
Wear mass loss (dry, 200 N) Lower Higher
Wear mass loss (dry, 600 N) Lower Higher
Wear mass loss (quartz sand) Lower Higher
Volume wear rate (dry) Lower Higher
Volume wear rate (quartz sand) Lower Higher
Wear mechanism Abrasive (micro-cutting + fatigue spalling) Abrasive (micro-cutting + fatigue spalling)

The wear tests show that the cladding layer outperforms the martensitic steel in all conditions. The friction coefficient is similar, which is expected because the friction coefficient is more dependent on the surface condition than the material. The wear mass loss and volume wear rate are lower for the cladding layer, which is the key result. In the dry friction condition, the wear mechanism is primarily micro-cutting by hard asperities. In the quartz sand condition, the wear mechanism is a combination of micro-cutting by the quartz particles and fatigue spalling. The cladding layer performs better because the Cr7C3 carbides are harder than the quartz particles, so they resist the cutting action. The martensitic steel, with a hardness of 45–50 HRC, is softer than quartz, so the quartz particles cut into it more easily.

Engineering Practice and Application Considerations

In the steel pipe industry, high-chromium bimetallic wear plates are used for a wide range of applications, including chute liners, hopper walls, conveyor skirts and pipe bends in pneumatic conveying systems. The key advantage of these plates is that they combine the high wear resistance of the cladding layer with the toughness and weldability of the base steel. This makes them easy to install and repair. The cladding layer is typically applied using submerged arc welding or open-arc welding, and the thickness can range from 3 mm to 20 mm.

In my experience, the most common failure mode for these plates is not wear, but spalling. The cladding layer can delaminate from the base steel if the interface is not properly bonded. This can happen if the welding process is not controlled correctly, or if the plate is subjected to impact loading. The authors did not discuss spalling, but it is a critical issue in practice. To prevent spalling, the following measures are recommended:

  1. The base steel must be clean and free from rust, oil and moisture before welding.
  2. The welding parameters must be controlled to ensure adequate penetration and fusion at the interface.
  3. The preheat and interpass temperature must be maintained to prevent cracking.
  4. The plate should not be subjected to impact loading that exceeds the bond strength.

The wear performance of the cladding layer is excellent, but the cost is higher than for a martensitic steel plate. In a typical mining application, the high-chromium plate can last two to three times longer than a martensitic steel plate, which justifies the higher initial cost. In my experience, the total cost of ownership is lower for the high-chromium plate, because the replacement cost and downtime are reduced.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that are relevant to the practising engineer. First, what is the effect of the cladding thickness on the wear performance? The authors used a single thickness, but in practice, the cladding thickness can vary. A thicker cladding layer will last longer, but it will also increase the cost. The optimum thickness depends on the application and the expected wear rate. Second, what is the effect of the carbide size and distribution on the wear resistance? The authors did not characterise the carbide size, but this is an important parameter. Larger carbides are more resistant to cutting, but they are also more prone to spalling. A uniform distribution of medium-sized carbides is usually the best compromise. Third, what is the effect of the quartz sand particle size on the wear rate? The authors used a specific particle size, but in practice, the particle size can vary from fine dust to large rocks. The wear rate increases with particle size, up to a certain point, and then it may decrease if the particles are too large to penetrate the surface.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the selection and application of wear-resistant materials. The authors have demonstrated that the high-chromium bimetallic wear plate outperforms the martensitic steel in both dry and quartz sand friction conditions. The microstructure analysis is clear, and the wear test results are convincing. The practical implication is that high-chromium bimetallic plates are a cost-effective solution for abrasive wear applications, particularly in mining and steel processing. The key to success is proper installation and process control. In my experience, the most common problem is spalling, which can be avoided by following the correct welding procedure and avoiding impact loading. I would recommend that any company considering these plates conduct a trial on a representative application, with full monitoring of the wear rate and the interface condition. This will provide the data needed to justify the higher initial cost.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is well-written and the results are clearly presented. The main limitation is the lack of data on the effect of cladding thickness and carbide size. Future work should focus on optimising the cladding thickness for specific applications and characterising the carbide size distribution. The potential for these plates in the steel pipe industry is significant, particularly for pipe bends in pneumatic conveying systems and chute liners in material handling. In my experience, the key to success is a partnership between the material supplier and the end user, with clear specifications and a joint review of the application. This paper provides a solid foundation for that partnership.