ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Near-Equimolar Mo/V/Nb/Ti Strengthened High-Chromium Cast Iron Overlay: Microstructure and Wear Resistance

Literature Overview and Core Thesis

This paper by Hu Shichang, Huang Zhiquan, Gao Zhanqi, Ni Junjie, and Wang Chongyang from the Zhengzhou Research Institute of Mechanical Engineering, China Academy of Machinery Science and Technology, addresses the challenge of improving the wear resistance of high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloys. The authors apply the concept of high-entropy alloy design to develop a new class of high-chromium cast iron overlay strengthened with near-equimolar additions of molybdenum, vanadium, niobium, and titanium.

The core thesis is that by adding these strong carbide-forming elements in near-equimolar ratios, it is possible to refine the microstructure, improve the morphology of the carbides, and enhance the overall wear resistance of the overlay. The authors compare two different near-equimolar compositions with a commercial TN65 high-chromium cast iron overlay, and they evaluate the microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance of each.

Experimental Design and Alloy Compositions

The authors designed two experimental compositions with different Mo/V/Nb/Ti molar ratios, and they prepared the corresponding welding electrodes by adding the alloying elements to the electrode coating. The table below summarises the compositions and the key results.

Parameter 1# Overlay 2# Overlay TN65 Reference
Mo content (wt%) 0.88 1.25 -
V content (wt%) 0.68 0.48 -
Nb content (wt%) 1.22 1.22 -
Ti content (wt%) 0.68 0.85 -
Mo/V/Nb/Ti molar ratio 0.7:1.0:1.0:1.0 1.0:0.7:1.0:1.3 -
Hardness (HRC) 64.1 62.5 65.1
Wear mass loss (g) 0.0771 0.0931 0.0677

The 1# overlay has a Mo/V/Nb/Ti molar ratio of 0.7:1.0:1.0:1.0, corresponding to mass fractions of 0.88% Mo, 0.68% V, 1.22% Nb, and 0.68% Ti. The 2# overlay has a molar ratio of 1.0:0.7:1.0:1.3, corresponding to mass fractions of 1.25% Mo, 0.48% V, 1.22% Nb, and 0.85% Ti. Both overlays have a chromium content of approximately 15.7%, which is typical for high-chromium cast iron.

The overlays were prepared by manual arc welding on Q235 steel plates, using electrodes with the alloying elements incorporated into the coating. This is a practical approach that can be easily implemented in a production environment.

Microstructural Analysis and Phase Identification

The X-ray diffraction analysis shows that both experimental overlays have similar phase compositions to the TN65 reference overlay. The main phases are M7C3 carbides, gamma-Fe, M3C carbides, (Nb, Ti, Mo, V)C / (Nb, Ti, Mo, V)(B, C) carbonitrides, and Fe2B borides. The presence of the complex carbonitrides is particularly interesting, as these phases are formed by the near-equimolar additions of Mo, V, Nb, and Ti.

The metallographic analysis reveals significant differences in the carbide morphology between the experimental overlays and the TN65 reference. The M7C3 carbides in the 1# overlay are more rounded and smaller than those in the TN65 reference. The average particle size of the M7C3 carbides in the 1# overlay is approximately 12.45 μm, which is the smallest among all the overlays tested. The 2# overlay has a higher M3C eutectic carbide content than the 1# overlay.

The refinement and rounding of the M7C3 carbides is a key finding. In conventional high-chromium cast iron, the M7C3 carbides are typically elongated and angular, which can act as stress concentrators and promote crack initiation. The near-equimolar additions of Mo, V, Nb, and Ti promote the formation of fine, rounded carbides, which reduces the stress concentration and improves the toughness of the overlay.

Mechanical Properties and Wear Resistance

The hardness and wear resistance results are the most important part of the paper. The 1# overlay achieves a hardness of 64.1 HRC, which is close to the TN65 reference (65.1 HRC) and higher than the 2# overlay (62.5 HRC). The wear mass loss of the 1# overlay is 0.0771 g, which is lower than the 2# overlay (0.0931 g) and close to the TN65 reference (0.0677 g).

The wear surface analysis shows that the 1# overlay and the TN65 reference have shallower ploughing grooves than the 2# overlay. This indicates that the 1# overlay has better wear resistance, which is consistent with its higher hardness and finer carbide morphology.

The results show that the 1# overlay with a Mo/V/Nb/Ti molar ratio of 0.7:1.0:1.0:1.0 has the best combination of hardness and wear resistance among the experimental overlays. The performance of the 1# overlay is very close to the TN65 reference, which is a commercial high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy.

Engineering Practice and Implications

This paper has direct relevance to the production of wear-resistant components in the pipe and fitting industry. High-chromium cast iron overlays are widely used for wear protection on pipe fittings, particularly in slurry pipelines, ash handling systems, and other abrasive service applications.

The key finding of this paper is that the near-equimolar addition of Mo, V, Nb, and Ti can refine the microstructure and improve the wear resistance of high-chromium cast iron overlays. This is a practical approach that can be implemented using conventional welding consumables and processes.

In my own experience, the main challenge with high-chromium cast iron overlays is the trade-off between wear resistance and toughness. The overlays with high hardness and good wear resistance are often brittle and prone to cracking. The near-equimolar approach described in this paper offers a potential solution to this problem, as the refined and rounded carbides improve the toughness without sacrificing wear resistance.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several questions that I think are worth considering. First, the authors only tested two compositions, and the range of Mo/V/Nb/Ti ratios is relatively narrow. I would like to see a broader composition study to understand the effect of each element individually and in combination.

Second, the wear test used in this study is a simple abrasive wear test. In practice, the wear conditions are often more complex, involving impact, erosion, and corrosion. I would like to see the overlays tested under more realistic conditions.

Third, the paper does not discuss the cost of the alloying additions. Molybdenum, vanadium, niobium, and titanium are all relatively expensive elements, and the cost of the overlay will be higher than a conventional high-chromium cast iron overlay. The economic benefit of the improved wear resistance needs to be weighed against the additional cost.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper provides a valuable contribution to the field of high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloys. The application of the high-entropy alloy design concept to hardfacing alloys is a novel approach that has the potential to improve the performance of wear-resistant coatings.

The key insight for me is that the near-equimolar addition of strong carbide-forming elements can refine the carbide morphology and improve the wear resistance of high-chromium cast iron overlays. This is a practical approach that can be implemented using conventional welding consumables, and it offers a potential solution to the trade-off between wear resistance and toughness.

Conclusion

This paper demonstrates that near-equimolar additions of Mo, V, Nb, and Ti can significantly improve the microstructure and wear resistance of high-chromium cast iron overlays. The 1# overlay with a Mo/V/Nb/Ti molar ratio of 0.7:1.0:1.0:1.0 achieves a hardness of 64.1 HRC and a wear mass loss of 0.0771 g, which are close to the commercial TN65 reference. The refinement and rounding of the M7C3 carbides is the key mechanism responsible for the improved performance. For engineers working in the pipe and fitting industry, this paper provides a practical approach to developing high-performance wear-resistant overlays. The near-equimolar design concept can be applied to other hardfacing alloy systems to improve their performance. However, the economic viability of the approach needs to be carefully evaluated, as the alloying additions are relatively expensive.