Effect of Mo Content on Microstructure and Properties of Stellite21 Plasma Cladding Layers
Literature Overview and Why It Matters
This paper by Luo Fang et al. from Zhejiang University of Technology addresses a problem that is all too familiar to anyone who has worked on triple-eccentric butterfly valves: how to improve the wear and corrosion resistance of Stellite21 hard-facing on the sealing surfaces. The authors systematically varied Mo content from 5.5% to 15% by adding Mo powder to Stellite21 powder and applied the mixture using plasma transferred arc (PTA) cladding on WCB cast steel. The finding that 10% Mo content provides the best combination of hardness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance is a practical result that can be directly applied to valve manufacturing. This is the kind of paper that a valve manufacturer would want on their desk before they commit to a production run.
Core Technical Points
Effect of Mo on Microstructure
The authors found that increasing Mo content suppressed the continuous growth of columnar crystals and promoted the formation of shorter dendrites and equiaxed crystals. This is a significant microstructural change because finer grains generally improve both strength and toughness. The Mo2C phase concentrated at grain boundaries, while Co7Mo6 and Co3Mo phases increased and Cr23C6 carbides decreased. This phase balance is critical for the mechanical and corrosion properties of the cladding. The increase in Mo-rich intermetallic phases at the expense of Cr-rich carbides suggests that Mo is competing with Cr for carbon, which affects the type and distribution of carbides.
Hardness Improvement with Mo Addition
The hardness increased with Mo content, reaching a maximum of 398 HV at 15% Mo, which is about 19.5% higher than the 5.5% Mo baseline. This is a significant improvement, but it comes at a cost. The authors found that the best combination of wear and corrosion resistance was at 10% Mo, not 15% Mo. This is a classic example of the trade-off between hardness and toughness. Higher hardness often means lower toughness, and in a sealing surface application, toughness is critical for resisting impact and thermal shock.
Wear Resistance and Friction Behaviour
The authors found that at 10% Mo, the friction coefficient and wear volume were lowest, with reductions of 17.2% and 79.1% respectively compared to the 5.5% Mo baseline. This is a remarkable improvement in wear resistance. The wear mechanism changed from severe abrasive wear to a combination of abrasive and adhesive wear, with the formation of a protective oxide layer on the worn surface. The oxide layer is likely a Mo-rich oxide that provides lubrication and reduces friction. This is a key finding because it suggests that the wear resistance is not simply a function of hardness, but also of the tribochemical behaviour of the surface.
Corrosion Resistance and Electrochemical Behaviour
At 10% Mo, the cladding exhibited the highest corrosion potential (-0.999 V) and the lowest corrosion current density (1.552 x 10^-5 A/cm²). The weight loss coefficient K was also lowest at 1.54%. This indicates that 10% Mo provides the best corrosion resistance among the compositions tested. The improvement in corrosion resistance is likely due to the formation of a Mo-rich passive film that is more stable and protective than the film formed on the lower-Mo compositions. The presence of Mo in the passive film is known to improve resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in chloride-containing environments.
Engineering Practice Integration
Why This Matters for Triple-Eccentric Butterfly Valves
Triple-eccentric butterfly valves are used in critical service applications where tight shut-off is required, such as in power plants, oil and gas processing, and chemical plants. The sealing surfaces are subjected to high contact stresses, abrasive wear from particulate matter in the fluid, and corrosion from the process medium. The hard-facing on the sealing surfaces must withstand all three simultaneously. Stellite21 is a cobalt-based alloy that is well-suited for this application because of its combination of wear resistance, corrosion resistance, and high-temperature strength. However, the standard Stellite21 composition may not be optimal for all service conditions. The authors' finding that adding Mo to achieve 10% total Mo content significantly improves wear and corrosion resistance is a valuable contribution to valve manufacturing.
Practical Considerations for PTA Cladding of Valve Sealing Surfaces
When applying Stellite21 cladding to valve sealing surfaces using PTA, the following process parameters are critical:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Criticality |
|---|---|---|
| Plasma gas flow rate | 2-4 L/min | High - affects arc stability |
| Shielding gas flow rate | 10-20 L/min | Medium - affects oxidation |
| Powder feed rate | 20-40 g/min | High - affects deposition rate and dilution |
| Welding current | 100-200 A | High - affects heat input and dilution |
| Travel speed | 100-200 mm/min | Medium - affects bead width and thickness |
| Oscillation width | 10-30 mm | Medium - affects coverage and uniformity |
| Pre-heat temperature | 200-300°C | High - affects cracking and HAZ properties |
The authors used a planetary angle grinder to mix the Stellite21 powder and Mo powder, which is a practical method for ensuring uniform distribution. However, I would recommend verifying the powder mixing uniformity before each production run, as segregation can occur during handling and feeding.
Dilution Control and Its Effect on Cladding Properties
Dilution is a critical concern in PTA cladding because it affects the composition of the cladding layer. The authors used WCB cast steel as the substrate, which has a different composition from Stellite21. Iron dilution from the substrate into the cladding can degrade the corrosion resistance and wear resistance of the cladding. The authors did not report dilution levels, but they likely controlled it by adjusting the powder feed rate and welding current. For a production operation, I would recommend measuring the dilution on the first article and then monitoring it periodically. The following table summarises the typical dilution ranges for PTA cladding:
| Process Parameter | Effect on Dilution |
|---|---|
| Powder feed rate | Higher feed rate reduces dilution |
| Welding current | Higher current increases dilution |
| Travel speed | Higher speed reduces dilution |
| Oscillation width | Wider oscillation reduces dilution |
| Pre-heat temperature | Higher pre-heat increases dilution |
Practical Qualification Tests for Valve Sealing Surfaces
When qualifying a Stellite21 cladding procedure for valve sealing surfaces, I would recommend the following test matrix:
| Test | Purpose | Acceptance Criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Visual examination | Detect surface defects | No cracks, porosity, or lack of fusion |
| Dye penetrant testing | Detect surface-breaking defects | No indications |
| Hardness survey across cladding | Verify hardness uniformity | Hardness within ±10% of specified range |
| Wear test (pin-on-disc) | Verify wear resistance | Wear rate less than specified value |
| Corrosion test (electrochemical) | Verify corrosion resistance | Corrosion current density less than specified value |
| Microstructural examination | Verify phase distribution | No continuous network of brittle phases at grain boundaries |
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a fundamental question: what is the optimum Mo content for a specific service condition? The authors found that 10% Mo provides the best combination of wear and corrosion resistance, but this may not be the optimum for all applications. For a valve handling abrasive slurry, a higher Mo content might be beneficial for wear resistance, even if it sacrifices some corrosion resistance. For a valve handling corrosive chemicals, a lower Mo content might be sufficient for wear resistance while providing better corrosion resistance. The optimum Mo content must be determined based on the specific service conditions.
Another question concerns the long-term stability of the Mo-rich phases. The authors tested in the as-clad condition, but in service, the cladding will experience thermal cycling and mechanical loading. The Mo-rich intermetallic phases may coarsen over time, which could degrade the mechanical properties. I would like to see long-term exposure tests under simulated service conditions before I fully trust the 10% Mo recommendation.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This paper provides a clear, actionable answer to a common production problem. The key takeaways are:
- Mo content significantly affects the microstructure, hardness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance of Stellite21 cladding.
- 10% Mo content provides the best combination of wear and corrosion resistance, with a 79.1% reduction in wear volume and a significant improvement in corrosion resistance.
- The improvement in wear resistance is due to both microstructural refinement and the formation of a protective oxide layer on the worn surface.
- The improvement in corrosion resistance is due to the formation of a Mo-rich passive film that is more stable and protective.
The paper's practical value lies in its direct applicability to valve manufacturing. A valve manufacturer can take the 10% Mo recommendation and apply it immediately, with minor adjustments based on the specific valve size, service conditions, and production constraints.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of hard-facing for valve sealing surfaces. The systematic evaluation of Mo content is exactly the kind of composition optimisation that is needed to improve the performance of cobalt-based alloys in demanding service conditions. The finding that 10% Mo provides the best combination of properties is a practical result that can be immediately applied in production.
However, I would caution against over-generalising the results. The optimum Mo content depends on the specific service conditions, the base metal, the cladding process parameters, and the post-cladding heat treatment. For a different application, the optimum Mo content may be different. I would recommend that any valve manufacturer conduct its own qualification testing based on the paper's methodology, rather than blindly adopting the 10% Mo recommendation.
In summary, this is a well-executed composition optimisation study that provides actionable guidance for production. The 10% Mo recommendation is a solid starting point, but it must be validated for each specific application. The paper's methodology is a good model for composition optimisation, and I would recommend it to any engineer involved in hard-facing for valve sealing surfaces.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd