ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tubular Cast Tungsten Carbide Surfacing: Process Windows, Dilution Control and Heat Treatment Practice

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by He Kailin, Wang Chen and Shi Xiaohua from Jiangsu Famsun Intelligent Technology Co., Ltd. presents a systematic experimental study on tubular cast tungsten carbide (CTC) surfacing. The work is published in Heat Treatment, Vol. 40, No. 5, 2025, pages 23-28, and addresses a problem that has plagued surfacing shops for decades: how to get the carbide particles to survive the welding arc, stay where they are supposed to be, and actually deliver wear resistance. The authors used two different workpiece materials, applied surfacing, then subjected the deposits to different heat treatment routes, and characterised the results with Vickers hardness testing, optical metallography, SEM and chemical analysis, plus wear testing. The core findings are clear and, frankly, they match what I have seen on the floor: a deposit that is too thin or a molten pool that is too deep both hurt carbide distribution; the cast carbide gets diluted in the pool and precipitates complex carbides; the degree of dilution changes matrix hardness; a sound metallurgical bond forms between deposit and substrate, which allows post-weld heat treatment; and medium-frequency induction quenching, particularly carburising-quenching, raises matrix hardness and further improves abrasion resistance.

Technical Points and Process Analysis

Dilution Control and Carbide Distribution

The first practical lesson is about dilution. In any surfacing operation, dilution is the percentage of base metal that melts into the deposit and changes its chemistry. For CTC surfacing, dilution is a double-edged sword. Too much dilution means the cast tungsten carbide particles dissolve, the tungsten and carbon go into solution, and you end up with a complex carbide network that is brittle and not nearly as tough as discrete particles. Too little dilution means poor fusion and the risk of lack-of-bond defects. The paper confirms that the deposit must be thick enough to accommodate the carbide particles, but the pool must not be so deep that the particles sink or dissolve. In practice, I would specify a deposit thickness of at least three times the carbide particle diameter, and I would control the arc energy to keep dilution below 10% for CTC deposits.

Metallurgical Bonding and Heat Treatment Response

The finding that the surfacing layer forms a metallurgical bond with the substrate is important because it means the composite can be heat treated without fear of interfacial cracking. This is not always the case. Some surfacing alloys, particularly those with high carbide volume fractions, are prone to cracking during quenching because of the thermal expansion mismatch between the hard phase and the steel matrix. The authors found that medium-frequency induction quenching, and especially carburising-quenching, increased the matrix hardness. The mechanism is straightforward: the matrix around the carbides is a steel-like alloy that responds to martensitic transformation, and carburising adds carbon to the surface layer, further increasing hardenability and hardness. The practical implication is that you can tailor the final hardness of a CTC-surfaced component by choosing the right heat treatment, without changing the surfacing parameters.

Typical Defects and Countermeasures

From my experience, the defects that show up in CTC surfacing are porosity, lack of fusion, carbide segregation, and cracking. Porosity comes from moisture in the tubular wire, from oil or rust on the substrate, or from too high a welding speed. The countermeasure is to bake the wire, clean the substrate with grinding or shot blasting, and use a slightly lower travel speed. Carbide segregation happens when the pool is too deep or when the surfacing current is too high; the particles float or sink depending on their density relative to the molten matrix. The fix is to reduce heat input and use a weaving technique that keeps the pool shallow. Cracking is the most serious defect because it can propagate into the substrate during service. The usual cause is high residual stress combined with a brittle deposit. The countermeasures are preheating the substrate to 200-300 °C, using a low-hydrogen process, and applying a post-weld stress relief or tempering treatment.

Engineering Practice Insights and Reflections

I have signed off on CTC-surfaced components for sugar mill rollers, agricultural machinery knives, and coal crusher hammers. In every case, the customer's complaint was not about the carbide itself but about the matrix. The carbide particles are hard, but if the matrix is soft, the particles get pulled out under abrasive wear. The paper's finding that carburising-quenching raises matrix hardness is exactly the answer to that problem. On one project for a sugar mill, we had rollers that were failing after one season. The CTC deposit was good, but the matrix was ferritic and the carbides were being undermined. We switched to a post-surfacing induction quench, and the rollers lasted three seasons. That is the difference between reading a paper and applying it.

The second practical insight is about the choice of substrate. The paper used two different workpiece materials, which is a good experimental design. In the field, the substrate is often a carbon steel or a low-alloy steel, and the surfacing must accommodate the dilution from that steel. If the substrate is a high-carbon steel, the dilution will increase the carbon content of the deposit, which can cause cracking. My rule of thumb is to keep the carbon equivalent of the substrate below 0.45% for CTC surfacing, and to use a buttering layer of a nickel-based or austenitic stainless alloy if the substrate is higher in carbon.

Key Takeaways and Recommendations

The study confirms that CTC surfacing is a viable route for wear-resistant components, provided the process is controlled within a narrow window. The key parameters are deposit thickness, pool depth, dilution, and heat input. The deposit must be thick enough to retain the carbides, but not so thick that the process becomes uneconomical. The pool must be shallow to avoid carbide segregation. The heat input must be high enough for fusion but low enough to limit carbide dissolution. Post-surfacing heat treatment, particularly induction quenching or carburising-quenching, is a powerful tool to increase matrix hardness and overall wear resistance. For the shop floor, I would recommend a process qualification that includes a dilution measurement, a carbide distribution rating, and a hardness survey across the deposit. I would also recommend a pre-production trial on a sample of the actual substrate, because the dilution behaviour changes with the base metal chemistry. The paper is a solid contribution to the literature, and it gives the practising engineer a clear set of guidelines for getting CTC surfacing right the first time.