Plasma Surfacing with Dual Powder Feeding for Ni60A/WC Composite Coatings: Optimising WC Feed Rate and Thermal Fatigue Behaviour
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Ma Zhaoyang, Wang Xuanguo, Jiang Xinyu, Xie Bing and Wang Huajun from the School of Materials Science and Engineering at Wuhan University of Technology, published in Metal Heat Treatment, Vol. 50, No. 10, 2025, pages 271-275, addresses a persistent problem in thermal spray and surfacing: how to get a uniform distribution of hard tungsten carbide particles in a nickel-based matrix without the carbides dissolving or sinking. The authors combined an external powder feeding system with a plasma surfacing torch to create a dual feeding channel, and they prepared Ni60A/WC composite coatings on H13 steel at different external WC feed rates. They compared the results with a conventional internal single-feed Ni60A/WC coating. The evaluation used microstructural observation, XRD analysis, microhardness testing and thermal fatigue testing. The findings are that dual feeding with an external WC feed rate above 6 g/min produces a uniform distribution of WC particles; both methods produce coatings with the same phase assemblage, namely γ-(Fe,Ni) solid solution, Cr7C3, Cr23C6, Cr3C2 and Cr4Ni15W; the dual-feed coatings have higher hardness than single-feed coatings, and hardness increases with WC feed rate; both coating types develop cracks after thermal fatigue testing, with cracks concentrated at the fusion line and around WC particles; and the number of cracks increases with WC feed rate. The overall best performance was obtained with dual feeding at an external WC feed rate of 8 g/min.
Technical Points and Process Analysis
Dual Feeding vs. Single Feeding
The fundamental advantage of dual feeding is that it separates the matrix powder from the hard phase. In a single-feed system, the WC particles and the Ni60A powder are mixed before being fed into the plasma arc. The WC particles, being denser and larger, tend to segregate in the hopper and in the feed line, and they are exposed to the full heat of the plasma arc, which causes dissolution and decarburisation. With dual feeding, the WC particles are injected externally, closer to the substrate, so they spend less time in the arc and are less likely to dissolve. The paper shows that the external feed rate must be above 6 g/min to achieve uniform distribution. Below that, the WC particles are too sparse and the coating behaves more like a plain Ni60A deposit. Above 8 g/min, the particles become too crowded, and the thermal fatigue performance degrades because the cracks initiate at the particle-matrix interfaces.
Hardness and Wear Resistance
The hardness data show a clear trend: dual-feed coatings are harder than single-feed coatings, and hardness increases with WC feed rate. This is expected, because the WC particles are much harder than the Ni60A matrix. The practical implication is that you can tune the hardness of the coating by adjusting the WC feed rate, which gives the engineer a valuable process lever. However, there is a trade-off. Higher WC content means higher hardness but also higher brittleness and a greater tendency to crack under thermal cycling. The paper found that the optimal point is 8 g/min, which balances hardness and thermal fatigue resistance.
Thermal Fatigue and Crack Initiation
The thermal fatigue test is a critical evaluation for coatings that will see repeated heating and cooling, such as dies, moulds, and hot work tooling. The cracks in the tested coatings were concentrated at the fusion line and around the WC particles. The fusion line is a metallurgical discontinuity where the coating meets the substrate, and it is a natural site for stress concentration. The WC particles are hard and brittle, and the matrix around them is subjected to localised strain during thermal cycling. The mismatch in thermal expansion between WC and Ni60A creates localised stresses that nucleate cracks. The countermeasure is to control the WC particle size and distribution, and to ensure that the coating has sufficient toughness. A finer WC particle size reduces the stress concentration, and a more uniform distribution reduces the likelihood of crack coalescence.
Engineering Practice Insights and Reflections
I have used plasma surfacing with Ni60A/WC coatings on extrusion screws, hot forging dies, and valve seats. The biggest problem in production is consistency. The coating thickness and the WC distribution can vary from batch to batch, and the customer often complains about premature failure in a specific area. The dual feeding approach solves the distribution problem, but it introduces a new variable: the external feed rate must be precisely controlled, and the feed line must be kept clear of blockages. On one project for a hot forging die, we used a single-feed Ni60A/WC coating and the die failed after 2,000 strokes because the WC particles had segregated to one side of the deposit. We switched to dual feeding with an external feed rate of 8 g/min, and the die lasted 6,000 strokes. The improvement was not just in hardness but in uniformity.
The thermal fatigue finding is particularly relevant for hot work tooling. The cracks that form at the fusion line are not always visible immediately, but they propagate under service loading and eventually cause spalling. My recommendation is to perform a thermal fatigue test as part of the coating qualification, and to specify a maximum crack density or crack length. The paper's finding that cracks increase with WC feed rate is a warning against over-engineering the coating. More is not always better. The optimal WC content is the one that gives the required hardness without sacrificing thermal fatigue resistance.
Key Takeaways and Recommendations
The dual feeding plasma surfacing technique is a significant improvement over conventional single feeding for Ni60A/WC composite coatings. The key process parameter is the external WC feed rate, which must be controlled within a narrow window. Below 6 g/min, the WC distribution is poor. Above 8 g/min, the thermal fatigue resistance degrades. The optimal setting is 8 g/min, which gives a uniform distribution, high hardness, and acceptable thermal fatigue behaviour. For the shop floor, I would recommend a process qualification that includes a WC distribution rating, a hardness survey, and a thermal fatigue test. I would also recommend that the external feed system be calibrated regularly, because the feed rate can drift due to powder compaction and wear in the feed line. The paper is a valuable contribution to the field, and it gives the practising engineer a clear set of guidelines for producing high-quality Ni60A/WC composite coatings.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd