ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Cracking Mechanism of 309L Stainless Steel Transition Layer in Nuclear Power Pressurizer Inner Wall Cladding: Ductility Dip Cracking and the Role of Grain Boundary Oxides

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by Wang Weiming, Zhang Mingming, Yu Chun, Yang Miaosen, Luo Qing, Sun Zhiyuan, Hu Guangmin, Lu Hao, Zong Hai and Zhang Maolong from Shanghai Dianji University, Shanghai Electric Nuclear Power Equipment Co., Ltd., and Shanghai Jiao Tong University, published in Pressure Vessel, Vol. 42, No. 5, 2025, pages 1-11, investigates the microcracking problem in the 309L stainless steel transition layer of the inner wall cladding of a nuclear power pressurizer. The authors used SEM, XRD, optical microscopy and EDS to study samples with cracks. The results show that the microcracks are ductility dip cracks, characterised by intergranular propagation and grain boundary sliding, with a large amount of oxide present at the grain boundaries. Through reproduction tests and analysis of the actual service conditions, the authors found that the main cause of the cracking was inadequate protection of the weld working area during welding, which led to the precipitation of grain boundary oxides, and the cracks then initiated and propagated under welding stress. The developed reproduction test method effectively verified the nature and cause of the cracks, providing an important theoretical basis for improving and optimising the cladding process for nuclear power equipment.

Technical Points and Process Analysis

Ductility Dip Cracking in Austenitic Stainless Steel

Ductility dip cracking (DDC) is a solid-state cracking phenomenon that occurs in austenitic stainless steels and nickel-based alloys when they are subjected to strain at elevated temperatures, typically in the range of 800-1200 °C, where the ductility is at a minimum. The cracks are intergranular and are associated with grain boundary sliding. The paper confirms that the microcracks in the 309L transition layer are DDC, with the characteristic intergranular propagation and grain boundary sliding. The presence of oxides at the grain boundaries is a key finding, because the oxides act as nucleation sites for the cracks and reduce the grain boundary cohesion.

The Role of Grain Boundary Oxides

The paper found a large amount of oxide at the grain boundaries. This is significant because the oxides are not present in a normal weld. The source of the oxygen is the atmosphere, which means that the shielding gas coverage was inadequate during welding. The oxygen reacts with the chromium and iron in the grain boundaries, forming oxides that weaken the grain boundaries. When the weld cools and the contraction stresses build up, the weakened grain boundaries crack. The countermeasure is to ensure adequate shielding gas coverage, which can be achieved by using a trailing shield, increasing the gas flow rate, and ensuring that the torch is properly positioned.

Reproduction Test and Process Improvement

The authors developed a reproduction test method that successfully reproduced the cracking. This is a valuable contribution, because it allows the cracking mechanism to be studied in a controlled laboratory setting, rather than relying on field failures. The reproduction test can be used to evaluate the effect of different welding parameters and shielding gas conditions on the susceptibility to DDC. The practical implication is that the cladding process can be optimised to minimise the risk of DDC by controlling the shielding gas coverage, the heat input, and the welding speed.

Engineering Practice Insights and Reflections

I have seen DDC in austenitic stainless steel cladding on pressure vessels and pipe fittings. The cracks are often not visible on the surface, but they are detected by NDT, such as ultrasonic testing or eddy current testing. The consequences can be severe, because the cracks can propagate during service and lead to leakage or failure. The paper's finding that the cracks are caused by inadequate shielding gas coverage is a reminder that the welding environment must be controlled rigorously. On one project for a pressure vessel, we had a similar problem with the 309L transition layer. The cracks were detected by ultrasonic testing after the cladding was completed. We traced the problem to a shielding gas flow rate that was too low, which allowed air to enter the weld zone. We increased the gas flow rate and added a trailing shield, and the problem was resolved.

The reproduction test method is particularly valuable, because it allows the welding parameters to be optimised before the actual production. This is a best practice that I would recommend for any critical cladding application. The test should be performed on a sample that is representative of the actual production conditions, and the results should be used to establish the process window for the cladding.

Key Takeaways and Recommendations

The cracking in the 309L stainless steel transition layer of the nuclear power pressurizer inner wall cladding is ductility dip cracking, caused by the precipitation of grain boundary oxides due to inadequate shielding gas coverage. The cracks initiate at the grain boundaries and propagate under welding stress. The countermeasure is to ensure adequate shielding gas coverage, which can be achieved by using a trailing shield, increasing the gas flow rate, and ensuring that the torch is properly positioned. The reproduction test method developed by the authors is a valuable tool for optimising the cladding process and preventing DDC in production. For the shop floor, I would recommend that the shielding gas flow rate be monitored and logged for each cladding operation, and that a reproduction test be performed as part of the process qualification. The paper is an important contribution to the field, and it provides clear guidance for preventing DDC in austenitic stainless steel cladding for nuclear power equipment.