ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Welding Process and Microalloying on Microstructure and Bonding Strength of Aluminum Bronze Overlays

What the Paper Really Says

This study by Ning Shaochen and colleagues at the China Academy of Machinery Ningbo Intelligent Machine Tool Research Institute and the Jiangxi Copper Technology Research Institute addresses a topic that is near and dear to my heart: welding aluminum bronze onto steel. The paper compares two welding processes, cold metal transfer (CMT) and pulsed welding, and two aluminum bronze alloys, S215 and S216, looking at the microstructure and bonding strength of the resulting overlays.

The results are fascinating and, frankly, a bit counterintuitive. For S215, the CMT process, which has a lower heat input, produces a finer alpha phase with a more dispersed second phase, and the bonding strength is about 38 MPa higher than with pulsed welding. For S216, the result is reversed. The pulsed process produces a higher bonding strength, about 32 MPa better than CMT.

The authors explain this through the alloy chemistry. S216 contains more manganese and nickel, which lower the melting point of the alloy. With the same welding parameters, more heat is absorbed by the steel substrate. In pulsed mode, this promotes diffusion of iron from the steel substrate into the copper-based filler metal. The iron diffusion causes heterogeneous nucleation and pins the grain boundaries, resulting in fine columnar and equiaxed alpha grains. The dislocation pinning is more pronounced, and the bonding strength increases.

This is a classic example of how alloy chemistry and welding process interact, and it is a reminder that you cannot assume one process is always better than another. The best process depends on the specific alloy.

What This Means on the Shop Floor

Aluminum bronze overlays on steel are used in a wide range of applications, from ship propellers to bearing shells to chemical plant components. The challenge is always the same: copper and steel have very different melting points, thermal conductivities, and coefficients of thermal expansion. Getting a sound metallurgical bond without cracking, porosity, or excessive dilution is difficult.

The CMT process has become very popular in recent years because it offers a low heat input, which reduces distortion and dilution. However, this paper shows that CMT is not always the best choice. For S216, the pulsed process actually gives a better bond, because the higher heat input promotes the diffusion of iron into the copper, which strengthens the interface.

From a practical standpoint, this means you need to know your alloy chemistry before you choose your process. If you are welding S215, use CMT. If you are welding S216, use pulsed. The difference in bonding strength is significant, about 30 to 40 MPa, which can be the difference between a component that lasts and one that fails.

Practical Lessons for Welding and Cladding

Let me lay out the key parameters and what they mean for the welding engineer.

Parameter S215 with CMT S215 with Pulsed S216 with CMT S216 with Pulsed
Heat input Low Higher Low Higher
Alpha grain size Fine Coarser Fine Fine, columnar + equiaxed
Second phase Dispersed Coarser Dispersed Dispersed, pinned
Bonding strength Higher (+38 MPa vs pulsed) Lower Lower Higher (+32 MPa vs CMT)
Dominant mechanism Low heat input, fine grains Coarser grains Less Fe diffusion Fe diffusion, grain boundary pinning

The first thing I would emphasize is that the interface is the critical zone. The bonding strength tests in this paper all failed on the copper side, which means the interface itself is stronger than the copper alloy. That is a good sign, but it also means you need to focus on getting a clean, sound interface. Any oxide, slag, or lack of fusion at the interface will be a stress concentrator.

The second thing is the role of iron diffusion. In S216, the iron diffusing into the copper acts as a grain refiner and a pinning agent. This is a beneficial effect, but it can also be a problem if you get too much iron dilution. Too much iron will make the copper alloy brittle. You need to control the dilution rate, which means controlling the heat input and the welding technique. I would recommend a stringer bead technique, with a slight weave, to keep the dilution below 10 percent.

The third thing is preheat and interpass temperature. Copper alloys have high thermal conductivity, so they will draw heat away from the weld pool quickly. You need a preheat, usually around 200 to 300 degrees Celsius, to prevent cracking. However, you also need to control the interpass temperature, because too much heat will cause the iron to diffuse excessively and will coarsen the grain structure. I would recommend an interpass temperature of no more than 250 degrees Celsius.

Final Word

This is an excellent study that highlights the importance of matching the welding process to the alloy chemistry. The interaction between manganese and nickel content, heat input, and iron diffusion is complex, and the results show that what works for one alloy may not work for another. My advice is to always run a welding procedure qualification test on the actual alloy you are going to use, with the actual process parameters, and to test the bonding strength. Do not assume that because CMT worked for one alloy, it will work for all. The data in this paper is a clear warning against that kind of assumption.