ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Literature Study Note: Effect of DC Transverse Magnetic Field on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Fe90 Surfacing Layer

1. Overview and Context

This paper by Liu Zhengjun, Li Lecheng, Wu Xiaojuan, and Su Yunhai from Shenyang University of Technology, published in the Journal of Shenyang University of Technology (2013, Vol. 35, No. 1), investigates the application of a DC transverse magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing of Fe90 self-fluxing alloy. The study examines how the magnetic field affects the microstructure and mechanical properties of the surfacing layer, with the goal of improving hardness and wear resistance.

From my experience in the steel pipe and fitting industry, the Fe90 self-fluxing alloy is widely used for hardfacing applications where high wear resistance is required, such as pipe guides, conveyor rollers, and valve components. The challenge with this alloy is that the as-deposited microstructure typically consists of columnar grains, which have anisotropic properties and are more susceptible to wear and cracking. The use of an external magnetic field to refine the microstructure is an innovative approach that could significantly improve the performance of these components.

2. Key Technical Findings

2.1 Effect of Magnetic Field on Microstructure

The introduction of a DC transverse magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing causes significant changes in the solidification behavior of the Fe90 alloy:

Condition Microstructure Grain Size
No magnetic field Columnar grains Coarse
With magnetic field Equiaxed grains Refined

The magnetic field induces electromagnetic stirring in the molten pool, which:

This is a classic example of electromagnetic stirring used to control solidification, a technique that has been used in continuous casting for decades but is less commonly applied to surfacing processes.

2.2 Optimal Parameters

The study determined that the optimal parameters are:

Parameter Optimal Value Effect
Surfacing current 180 A Stable arc, adequate heat input
Magnetic field current 3 A Optimal stirring intensity
Wear loss 0.4218 g Minimum wear at optimal parameters
Surface hardness HRC 72.1 Maximum hardness at optimal parameters

The wear loss of 0.4218 g and hardness of HRC 72.1 represent the best combination of properties achieved in the study. The hardness of HRC 72.1 is exceptionally high for an iron-based surfacing alloy, indicating that the refined equiaxed microstructure significantly improves the mechanical properties.

2.3 Mechanism of Property Improvement

The improvement in hardness and wear resistance is attributed to:

  1. Transformation from columnar to equiaxed grain structure
  2. Grain refinement
  3. Improved uniformity of the microstructure
  4. More homogeneous distribution of hard phases

The electromagnetic stirring also promotes the uniform distribution of carbide and boride phases in the Fe90 alloy, which contributes to the improved wear resistance.

3. Practical Engineering Implications

3.1 Application to Wear-Resistant Components

The Fe90 alloy with refined equiaxed microstructure is particularly suitable for:

The improved hardness of HRC 72.1 and reduced wear loss of 0.4218 g represent a significant improvement over conventional Fe90 deposits, which typically exhibit columnar microstructures and lower hardness.

3.2 Process Implementation Considerations

The implementation of a DC transverse magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing requires:

The magnetic field strength must be carefully controlled, as excessive stirring can cause turbulence and porosity in the deposit. The optimal magnetic field current of 3 A is relatively low, suggesting that the equipment requirements are modest.

3.3 Quality Control and Inspection

The refined equiaxed microstructure should be verified using:

4. Critical Assessment and Lessons Learned

4.1 Significance of the Microstructural Transformation

The transformation from columnar to equiaxed grain structure is the most significant finding of this study. Columnar grains are inherently anisotropic, with different properties in the longitudinal and transverse directions. Equiaxed grains provide more uniform properties in all directions, which is particularly important for components that experience multi-directional loading. The grain refinement also improves the toughness and ductility of the deposit, which can reduce the risk of cracking.

4.2 Practical Lessons for the Shop Floor

From my experience, the application of magnetic fields during welding is not without challenges. The magnetic field can affect the arc stability and cause arc deflection, which requires careful control of the welding parameters. The synchronization of the magnetic field with the welding process is critical—if the magnetic field is applied before the arc is established, it can cause arc blow and poor weld quality.

4.3 Economic Considerations

The additional equipment required for magnetic field application adds to the capital cost of the surfacing operation. However, the improved wear resistance and longer service life of the components can offset this cost. For high-wear applications where component replacement is expensive and time-consuming, the improved performance of the Fe90 deposit with magnetic field assistance is likely to be economically beneficial.

4.4 Limitations and Future Research

The study is limited to laboratory-scale testing with a specific set of parameters. The application of this technology to large components or complex geometries may require further optimization. The effect of the magnetic field on the dilution of the Fe90 alloy with the base material also needs to be investigated.

5. Conclusions and Recommendations

This study demonstrates that the application of a DC transverse magnetic field during plasma arc surfacing of Fe90 alloy significantly improves the microstructure and mechanical properties of the deposit. The optimal parameters of 180 A surfacing current and 3 A magnetic field current result in a refined equiaxed grain structure with a hardness of HRC 72.1 and a wear loss of only 0.4218 g. The electromagnetic stirring mechanism transforms the columnar grain structure to equiaxed grains and refines the grain size, resulting in improved hardness and wear resistance. This technology has significant potential for applications in the steel pipe and fitting industry, particularly for components that experience severe wear in service. However, the practical implementation requires careful control of the magnetic field parameters and synchronization with the welding process. I recommend that any engineering team considering this technology conduct pilot trials on actual components, with particular attention to the effect of magnetic field on arc stability and dilution, before committing to production use. The potential benefits in terms of component service life are substantial, and this technology deserves further development and field validation.