Intergranular Corrosion Resistance of Austenitic Stainless Steel Strip Electroslag Cladding
Literature Overview and Significance
This study from Hohai University and Changzhou Baoling Heavy Industry Machinery Co., Ltd. addresses a critical issue in the cladding of pressure vessels and chemical equipment: the intergranular corrosion resistance of austenitic stainless steel cladding layers. The authors compared two cladding methods, strip electroslag cladding and strip submerged arc cladding, and investigated the effect of welding speed on the microstructure and corrosion resistance of the deposit. The findings are directly relevant to the fabrication of reactors, columns, and storage tanks in the chemical and petrochemical industries, where the cladding layer must provide both corrosion resistance and mechanical integrity. The paper is particularly valuable because it uses the electrochemical potentiokinetic reactivation (EPR) method, which is a sensitive and quantitative technique for assessing susceptibility to intergranular corrosion.
Microstructure and Delta Ferrite Content
The authors used two cladding methods to deposit Cr-Ni stainless steel onto a carbon steel substrate. The strip electroslag cladding process uses a molten slag bath to melt the strip electrode and the substrate surface, while the strip submerged arc cladding process uses a granular flux that is melted by the arc to provide shielding. Both processes produce a deposit with an austenitic matrix and a certain amount of delta ferrite. The delta ferrite content is a critical parameter because it affects both the mechanical properties and the corrosion resistance of the cladding.
The microstructural analysis revealed that the delta ferrite content in the strip electroslag cladding increases with increasing welding speed. At a welding speed of 8 m/h, the delta ferrite content was 6.8%, while at higher speeds, it increased to 20.4%. In contrast, the strip submerged arc cladding produced a delta ferrite content of 23.6%, which is significantly higher than that of the electroslag cladding at the same welding speed. The higher delta ferrite content in the submerged arc cladding is attributed to the higher heat input and the different cooling rate, which favour the formation of delta ferrite during solidification.
The delta ferrite content is important for two reasons. First, it affects the mechanical properties of the cladding. Delta ferrite is a body-centred cubic phase that is harder and less ductile than the face-centred cubic austenite. A high delta ferrite content can reduce the toughness of the cladding and increase its susceptibility to hydrogen-induced cracking. Second, it affects the corrosion resistance. Delta ferrite is anodic relative to austenite in many corrosive environments, and a high delta ferrite content can lead to preferential attack at the ferrite-austenite interfaces. However, a certain amount of delta ferrite is also beneficial because it can prevent hot cracking during solidification.
EPR Test Results and Intergranular Corrosion Susceptibility
The authors used the electrochemical potentiokinetic reactivation (EPR) method to assess the susceptibility of the cladding layers to intergranular corrosion. The EPR method involves polarising the specimen in an acid solution and measuring the reactivation current during a reverse scan. The degree of sensitisation is quantified by the reactivation rate, which is the ratio of the reactivation current to the activation current. A high reactivation rate indicates a high susceptibility to intergranular corrosion.
The EPR results showed that the strip electroslag cladding at a welding speed of 8 m/h had the lowest reactivation rate of 3.22%, indicating the best resistance to intergranular corrosion. At higher welding speeds, the reactivation rate increased, indicating a decrease in corrosion resistance. The strip submerged arc cladding had a higher reactivation rate than the electroslag cladding at the same welding speed, indicating a lower resistance to intergranular corrosion.
The results are summarised in the following table:
| Cladding Method | Welding Speed (m/h) | Delta Ferrite Content (%) | Reactivation Rate (%) | Intergranular Corrosion Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Strip ESW | 8 | 6.8 | 3.22 | Excellent |
| Strip ESW | Higher | Up to 20.4 | Higher | Reduced |
| Strip SAW | Not specified | 23.6 | Higher than ESW | Reduced |
The correlation between the delta ferrite content and the reactivation rate is clear: a higher delta ferrite content corresponds to a higher reactivation rate and thus a lower resistance to intergranular corrosion. This is consistent with the well-known mechanism that chromium depletion occurs at the ferrite-austenite interfaces when the cladding is subjected to sensitisation temperatures. The delta ferrite phase has a higher chromium content than the austenite, and during sensitisation, chromium carbides precipitate at the interfaces, depleting the adjacent austenite of chromium. This chromium-depleted zone is susceptible to intergranular corrosion.
Practical Implications for Cladding Process Selection
For the fabricator, this study provides clear guidance on the selection of the cladding method and the welding parameters. The strip electroslag cladding process at a welding speed of 8 m/h produces a cladding layer with excellent resistance to intergranular corrosion, making it the preferred choice for applications where the cladding will be exposed to corrosive media. The strip submerged arc cladding process, while offering a higher deposition rate, produces a cladding with a higher delta ferrite content and a correspondingly lower resistance to intergranular corrosion.
However, the practical decision is not always straightforward. The strip electroslag cladding process has a lower deposition rate than the strip submerged arc cladding process, which means that it takes longer to clad a given area. In a large pressure vessel, the difference in deposition rate can translate into a significant difference in production time and cost. The fabricator must weigh the benefits of improved corrosion resistance against the increased production cost.
Another practical consideration is the control of the welding speed. The authors found that the delta ferrite content in the strip electroslag cladding increases with welding speed, and that the corrosion resistance decreases correspondingly. This means that the welding speed must be carefully controlled to maintain the desired delta ferrite content. In production, this requires a robust welding procedure qualification that establishes the acceptable range of welding speeds and verifies the resulting delta ferrite content and corrosion resistance.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that arises from this study is whether the EPR method is the most appropriate test for evaluating the intergranular corrosion resistance of cladding layers. The authors also used the 10% oxalic acid electrolytic etching test, and the results were consistent with the EPR results. However, the EPR method is more quantitative and sensitive, and it provides a numerical value that can be used for acceptance criteria. In my experience, the EPR method is increasingly used in the industry for the qualification of cladding procedures, and it is specified in some standards for the evaluation of sensitisation in austenitic stainless steels.
Another reflection relates to the effect of post-weld heat treatment. In many cases, clad pressure vessels are subjected to a post-weld heat treatment to relieve residual stresses. However, this heat treatment can also cause sensitisation of the cladding if the temperature is in the sensitisation range (typically 450-850 degrees Celsius). The authors did not investigate the effect of post-weld heat treatment in this study, but it is an important consideration in practice. If a post-weld heat treatment is required, the cladding must be designed to resist sensitisation, which may require a lower carbon content or the addition of stabilising elements such as titanium or niobium.
Study Insights and Implications
The most important insight from this study is that the strip electroslag cladding process offers a significant advantage over the strip submerged arc cladding process in terms of intergranular corrosion resistance, provided that the welding speed is controlled within a narrow range. The lower delta ferrite content in the electroslag cladding is the key factor that contributes to this advantage. For the fabricator, this means that the electroslag cladding process should be the preferred choice for applications where the cladding will be exposed to corrosive media, even if it means a slightly longer production time.
The study also highlights the importance of controlling the welding speed during strip cladding. The delta ferrite content is highly sensitive to the welding speed, and a small change in speed can result in a significant change in the ferrite content and the corrosion resistance. This requires a high level of process control, including the use of automated welding equipment with precise speed control and real-time monitoring of the welding parameters.
Conclusion and Reference Value
This paper provides a valuable comparison of two strip cladding methods and their effect on the intergranular corrosion resistance of austenitic stainless steel cladding. The authors have demonstrated that the strip electroslag cladding process at a welding speed of 8 m/h produces a cladding with excellent corrosion resistance, while the strip submerged arc cladding process produces a cladding with a higher delta ferrite content and a correspondingly lower corrosion resistance. The use of the EPR method provides a quantitative measure of the sensitisation susceptibility, which is essential for the qualification of cladding procedures. For engineers involved in the fabrication of clad pressure vessels and chemical equipment, this paper is an essential reference that should be consulted when selecting the cladding method and establishing the welding procedure.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd