ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Powder-Added Surfacing Process and Application of Wear-Resistant Composite Steel Plates

The Process: What Powder-Added Surfacing Is

I first encountered powder-added surfacing in the late 1990s when I was looking for a way to produce wear-resistant plates for a chute lining application. The traditional approach was to use a hardfacing electrode and deposit a layer on a mild steel plate, but the deposition rate was low and the cost was high. The paper by Meng Zhaohong and colleagues at the Chinese Academy of Agricultural Mechanization Sciences describes a different approach, and it is one that I have used successfully in my own plants.

Powder-added surfacing is a process where the hardfacing alloy is introduced into the arc in powder form rather than as a solid wire or electrode. The powder is fed into the arc, where it melts and is deposited onto the substrate. The result is a composite plate with a hard, wear-resistant surface on a tough, weldable mild steel base. The process is high efficiency and low cost, which is exactly what you want when you are producing large quantities of wear plates.

Why It Wins on Cost and Efficiency

Let me give you the economic picture from my experience. The traditional hardfacing route with manual electrodes or even with submerged arc wire costs more per kilogram of deposit because the wire or electrode itself is expensive, and the deposition rate is limited. Powder-added surfacing changes the economics.

Parameter Traditional Hardfacing Powder-Added Surfacing
Deposition rate 2-5 kg per hour (manual) 10-20 kg per hour or higher
Alloy cost High, wire or electrode cost Lower, powder can be cheaper per kg
Dilution Higher, base metal mixes in Lower, less base metal dilution
Deposit hardness Varies, typically 40-60 HRC Can achieve 55-65 HRC
Process complexity Simple, manual or semi-automatic Requires powder feeder, more complex
Plate size capability Limited by manual process Large plates possible

The key economic advantage is that the powder can be a lower-cost alloy blend compared to a solid wire of the same composition. Powder metallurgy allows you to mix elemental powders, ferroalloys, and even recycled materials to achieve the target chemistry, which is often cheaper than drawing a wire of the same composition. In high-volume production, this cost difference is significant.

Composite Plate Properties and Fabrication

The paper emphasizes that the composite plates produced by powder-added surfacing have good wear resistance and can be cut, formed, drilled, and welded. This is a critical point. A wear plate that cannot be fabricated is useless, no matter how hard it is.

In my experience, the key properties of powder-added composite plates are:

  1. The bond between the hardfacing layer and the base plate must be metallurgical, not mechanical. The paper's process achieves this because the powder is melted into the substrate, creating a fusion bond.
  2. The hardfacing layer must be thick enough to provide wear life but not so thick that it becomes brittle and cracks. I would typically specify a hardfacing layer of 3 to 6 mm for chute liners and 6 to 10 mm for crusher applications.
  3. The composite plate must be formable. This means the base plate must be a low-carbon or mild steel that can be bent and formed without cracking the hardfacing layer. The hardfacing layer itself will have limited ductility, so forming must be done with care, using a large bend radius and possibly with the hardfacing layer on the outside of the bend to put it in tension rather than compression.
  4. The plate must be weldable. This means the hardfacing layer must not contain excessive carbon or alloy content that would cause cracking in the HAZ when the plate is welded to a structure. The paper's process produces a deposit that is weldable, which is a significant advantage over some other hardfacing processes.

Engineering Applications and Lessons

I have used powder-added composite plates in several applications, and here is what I have learned.

Application What Worked What Did Not Work
Chute liners in ore handling Excellent wear life, easy to install Initial plates cracked at weld seams until preheat was added
Hopper liners in coal handling Good wear resistance, low cost Forming the plates required a large bend radius
Screen decks in aggregate plants Excellent abrasion resistance Drilling holes in the hardfacing layer required carbide drills
Conveyor wear strips Good performance, easy to replace Edge cracking occurred if the hardfacing layer was too thick
Crusher wear plates Good impact resistance Impact loading caused spalling if the bond was poor

The most important lesson I have learned is that the weldability of the composite plate depends on the carbon equivalent of the hardfacing layer. If the hardfacing layer has a high carbon equivalent, the HAZ will be hard and crack-sensitive, and you will need to preheat before welding the plate to the structure. I have seen a chute liner crack along the weld seam because the welder did not preheat, and the entire liner had to be replaced.

Another lesson is that the hardfacing layer thickness must be controlled. If the layer is too thick, the residual stress in the deposit can cause the plate to warp, and the warpage can make the plate impossible to install. If the layer is too thin, the wear life is short and the plate has to be replaced prematurely. The sweet spot depends on the application, but I would typically start with a 4 to 5 mm hardfacing layer for chute liners.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper describes the process but does not provide detailed mechanical property data for the composite plates. In my experience, the wear resistance of powder-added composite plates is good but not always as good as a wrought hardfacing alloy of the same composition. This is because the powder-added deposit can have porosity or inclusions that reduce the wear resistance. The key is to control the powder feed rate and the arc parameters to produce a dense, sound deposit.

There is also the question of the bond quality. The paper states that the bond is metallurgical, but in practice, the bond quality depends on the heat input and the cleanliness of the substrate surface. If the substrate has rust, scale, or oil, the bond will be poor and the hardfacing layer will spall off. I have seen this happen, and it is always the fault of inadequate surface preparation.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a practical, application-oriented study that addresses a real industrial need. The powder-added surfacing process is a cost-effective way to produce wear-resistant composite plates, and the paper correctly emphasizes that the plates can be fabricated using conventional methods. This is a significant advantage because it means the plates can be integrated into existing structures without special handling.

What I take from this paper is that the process economics are the main driver. If you can produce a wear plate at half the cost of a traditional hardfaced plate, and it lasts just as long, you have a winning solution. The paper demonstrates that this is achievable, and my own experience confirms it.

In the end, the wear plate business is about cost per tonne of material handled. Powder-added composite plates win on this metric because the base plate is cheap mild steel and the hardfacing layer is applied only where it is needed. I have used this approach in pipe mill applications, including wear plates for the entry guides and the pinch roll area, and the results have been excellent. The key is to control the process parameters and to verify the deposit quality on a regular basis.