Development of Wear-Resistant Surfacing Electrode for Hot Rolling Rolls
Introduction and Motivation
This paper, published in Journal of Welding in 1997 by Ying Pengzhan and colleagues from China University of Mining and Technology, addresses a perennial problem in the steel industry: the wear of hot rolling rolls. Having spent decades in the steel pipe and fitting business, I have seen the impact of roll wear on product quality and production efficiency. Hot rolling rolls are subjected to extreme conditions—high temperatures, high contact stresses, and abrasive wear from the hot metal being rolled. When rolls wear, the surface quality of the rolled product deteriorates, and the rolls must be replaced, leading to costly downtime. The paper focuses on the development of a wear-resistant surfacing electrode specifically designed for hot rolling rolls. The research is systematic: the authors adjusted the electrode coating composition to find the optimal alloy system, then characterized the resulting surfacing layer through metallographic analysis, X-ray diffraction (XRD), hardness testing, and abrasive wear testing. The goal was to develop an electrode that provides high hardness, good wear resistance, and the ability to maintain these properties at elevated temperatures—a combination that is notoriously difficult to achieve.
Alloy System Design and Coating Formulation
The key to this research is the alloy system of the surfacing layer. The paper identifies a composition that produces a microstructure of martensite plus retained austenite plus carbides. This is a classic hardfacing microstructure, but the authors tuned it specifically for hot rolling roll applications.
| Alloying Element | Typical Range (wt%) | Function |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon (C) | 0.3–0.6 | Increases hardness and carbide formation |
| Chromium (Cr) | 5–10 | Promotes carbide formation, improves hardenability |
| Molybdenum (Mo) | 1–3 | Increases hardness and tempering resistance |
| Vanadium (V) | 0.5–1.5 | Forms hard carbides, refines grain structure |
| Tungsten (W) | 1–3 | Increases hot hardness, forms carbides |
| Manganese (Mn) | 1–2 | Deoxidizer, improves hardenability |
| Silicon (Si) | 0.5–1.0 | Deoxidizer, improves fluidity |
The authors found that by carefully balancing these elements in the coating, they could achieve a surfacing layer with a hardness of HRC 58–60. The XRD analysis confirmed the presence of martensite, retained austenite, and carbides. The retained austenite is particularly interesting because it provides some toughness and allows for transformation-induced plasticity (TRIP) during wear, which can enhance wear resistance. However, too much retained austenite can reduce hardness and lead to premature wear, so the balance must be carefully controlled.
The coating formulation is critical because it determines the alloy transition coefficient—the efficiency with which alloying elements are transferred from the electrode to the weld metal. In this paper, the authors adjusted the coating composition to optimize this transfer, ensuring that the surfacing layer has the desired chemical composition and microstructure. In my experience, this is one of the most challenging aspects of electrode development. The coating must provide arc stability, slag protection, and deoxidation, while also delivering the alloying elements in the right proportions. A poorly formulated coating can lead to excessive spatter, poor bead appearance, and inconsistent mechanical properties.
Microstructure and Property Analysis
The paper provides detailed metallographic and property data, which I find particularly useful for understanding the performance of the surfacing layer.
| Property | Value | Test Method |
|---|---|---|
| Hardness (as-welded) | HRC 58–60 | Rockwell C hardness test |
| Hardness after 580°C × 1000 min aging | HRC 58–59 | Rockwell C hardness test |
| Abrasive wear resistance (relative to 45 steel) | 6.1× | High-stress abrasive wear test |
| Microstructure | Martensite + retained austenite + carbides | Optical microscopy, XRD |
The hardness retention after aging at 580°C for 1000 minutes is a critical finding. Many hardfacing alloys suffer from softening at elevated temperatures due to tempering of the martensite or coarsening of the carbides. The fact that this alloy maintains its hardness suggests that the carbides are stable and the matrix has good tempering resistance. This is likely due to the presence of strong carbide-forming elements like chromium, molybdenum, and vanadium, which form stable carbides that resist coarsening.
The wear resistance of 6.1 times that of 45 steel is impressive. In practical terms, this means that a roll surfaced with this electrode would last significantly longer than an unsurfaced roll, reducing downtime and improving product quality. However, I would caution that laboratory wear tests do not always correlate perfectly with field performance. The actual wear mechanism in a hot rolling mill involves a combination of abrasive wear, adhesive wear, and thermal fatigue, which is difficult to simulate in the lab. Therefore, the industrial trials mentioned in the paper are essential to validate the laboratory results.
Industrial Application and Performance Considerations
The paper mentions that industrial trials confirmed the excellent wear resistance of the surfacing alloy. Based on my own experience with roll surfacing in pipe mills, I can offer some practical insights:
- Preheat and Interpass Temperature: For high-carbon, high-alloy hardfacing electrodes, preheating is essential to prevent cracking. The recommended preheat for this type of alloy is typically 200–300°C, depending on the roll size and composition. In my experience, inadequate preheat is the most common cause of cracking in hardfacing deposits.
- Post-Weld Heat Treatment: The paper does not discuss PWHT, but for large rolls, a stress-relief treatment may be necessary to reduce residual stresses. However, the alloy must be able to withstand the PWHT temperature without significant softening. The aging test at 580°C suggests that this alloy can tolerate such temperatures, but I would recommend verifying this on actual production rolls.
- Deposition Technique: The electrode is designed for manual arc welding, which means the deposition rate is limited. For large rolls, this can be a disadvantage. In practice, I have seen many roll surfacing operations switch to submerged arc welding (SAW) or electroslag surfacing to increase productivity. However, the alloy system developed in this paper could potentially be adapted for these processes, which would be a valuable extension of the work.
- Roll Preparation: Before surfacing, the roll surface must be thoroughly cleaned and machined to remove any cracks, defects, or decarburized layers. Failure to do this will result in poor adhesion and premature spalling of the surfacing layer.
- Quality Control: After surfacing, the roll must be inspected for cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion. Ultrasonic testing is commonly used to detect subsurface defects, while magnetic particle testing is used for surface cracks. The hardness of the surfacing layer should be verified at multiple locations to ensure uniformity.
Summary and Reflection
This paper represents a solid piece of applied research that addresses a real industrial problem. The development of a wear-resistant surfacing electrode for hot rolling rolls is not just an academic exercise—it has direct economic implications for steel producers. The key findings—hardness of HRC 58–60, wear resistance 6.1 times that of 45 steel, and excellent hardness retention at elevated temperatures—demonstrate that the alloy system is well-suited for this application. However, I would emphasize that the success of this electrode in production depends on more than just the chemical composition. Proper preheat, interpass temperature control, and post-weld handling are essential to avoid cracking and ensure the integrity of the surfacing layer. Furthermore, the transition from laboratory to industrial application is not automatic; it requires careful process qualification and validation. For engineers working in this field, this paper provides a good starting point for understanding the alloy design principles behind hardfacing electrodes. It also reminds me that the best solutions are often those that are developed in close collaboration between researchers and practitioners, as the authors of this paper clearly did. The 6.1× wear resistance figure is impressive, but I would always verify it with field trials before committing to a full-scale implementation. In the end, the goal is not just to make a hard surface, but to make a surface that performs reliably under the harsh conditions of a hot rolling mill.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd