Microstructure and Fretting Wear Performance of Manual Arc Surfacing Joints
Experimental Approach and Methodology
This paper, published in Hot Working Technology in 2007 by Zhang Youyi and colleagues from Xihua University and Henan University of Science and Technology, investigates the microstructure and fretting wear behavior of manual arc surfacing (SMAW) deposits on 45 steel. The authors used two different electrodes—CHR237 and CHR207—under identical welding parameters and then characterized the resulting deposits through optical microscopy, microhardness testing, and fretting wear testing using a PLINT-type fretting wear test machine. The study is particularly relevant to me because it addresses a common industrial scenario: the repair and hardfacing of machine components that are subjected to fretting wear, which is a specific wear mechanism that occurs when two surfaces are in contact and undergo small-amplitude oscillatory motion. Fretting wear is a serious problem in many applications, including pipe supports, flanges, and mechanical joints, where small movements can cause significant damage over time. The paper's focus on the relationship between microstructure, hardness, and fretting wear resistance is a classic and important topic in tribology and surface engineering.
Microstructural Analysis and Hardness
The paper's key finding is that the microstructure and hardness of the surfacing metal depend on the type of electrode, specifically the type and distribution of hard phases. Let me summarize the key microstructural features and hardness values reported.
| Electrode | Microstructure | Hardness (HV) | Hard Phase Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| CHR237 | Martensite + retained austenite + carbides | Higher (reported as superior) | Chromium carbides, possibly other alloy carbides |
| CHR207 | Martensite + retained austenite + fewer carbides | Lower (reported as inferior) | Fewer and finer carbides |
| Base metal (45 steel) | Ferrite + pearlite | Much lower | None |
The authors found that CHR237 produced a harder deposit with a more uniform distribution of carbides, while CHR207 produced a softer deposit with fewer carbides. This difference is directly related to the chemical composition of the electrodes. CHR237 is likely a chromium-molybdenum alloyed electrode, while CHR207 may have a lower alloy content. The microstructure of the CHR237 deposit—martensite with dispersed carbides—is typical of hardfacing alloys designed for wear resistance. The presence of retained austenite is also notable, as it can contribute to toughness and work hardening during wear.
From my experience, the hardness of a surfacing layer is a primary indicator of its wear resistance, but it is not the only factor. The distribution, size, and type of carbides play a critical role. In the CHR237 deposit, the carbides are likely chromium-rich and are uniformly distributed, which provides a hard, wear-resistant surface. In contrast, the CHR207 deposit has fewer carbides, and the matrix may be softer, leading to lower wear resistance.
Fretting Wear Behavior and Practical Implications
The fretting wear tests were conducted at room temperature using a PLINT-type fretting wear test machine. The results showed that both surfacing deposits exhibited better fretting wear resistance than the 45 steel base material, and that the CHR237 deposit performed the best.
| Material | Relative Fretting Wear Resistance | Comments |
|---|---|---|
| 45 steel (base) | Baseline (1.0) | Lowest resistance |
| CHR207 deposit | Better than 45 steel | Moderate resistance |
| CHR237 deposit | Best | Highest resistance |
The superior fretting wear resistance of the CHR237 deposit can be attributed to its higher hardness and the presence of hard carbides, which resist the abrasive and adhesive wear mechanisms that dominate fretting. In fretting wear, the small oscillatory motion causes repeated contact and separation, leading to the formation of oxide debris and the initiation of micro-cracks. A hard, carbide-rich surface is better able to resist these mechanisms. Additionally, the retained austenite in the CHR237 deposit may undergo strain-induced transformation to martensite during wear, which can increase the local hardness and improve wear resistance.
For engineers working in the field, these findings have practical implications:
- Selection of Surfacing Electrodes: When repairing components subjected to fretting wear, such as shafts, journals, and bearing seats, the choice of electrode is critical. CHR237 appears to be a better choice than CHR207 for applications where high fretting wear resistance is required.
- Preheat and Interpass Temperature: As with any hardfacing operation, proper preheat and interpass temperature control are essential to prevent cracking. The authors used identical welding parameters for both electrodes, which is a good experimental practice, but in production, the parameters may need to be adjusted based on the specific electrode and the component being surfaced.
- Post-Weld Treatment: The paper does not discuss post-weld heat treatment, but for components that will be subjected to cyclic loading, stress relief may be necessary. However, the effect of PWHT on the fretting wear resistance should be evaluated, as it may alter the microstructure and hardness.
- Surface Finish: The surface finish of the surfacing layer can significantly affect fretting wear. A rough surface can accelerate wear by increasing the contact stress and promoting the formation of oxide debris. Therefore, the surfaced component should be machined to a smooth finish before being put into service.
Engineering Practice Considerations and Lessons Learned
In my own experience with pipe and fitting manufacturing, fretting wear is often an overlooked problem. For example, in pipe supports and clamps, the small oscillatory movements caused by thermal expansion and vibration can lead to fretting wear, which can eventually cause the support to fail. Surfacing the contact surfaces with a wear-resistant alloy, such as the one developed in this paper, can significantly extend the service life of these components.
However, I want to emphasize a few practical lessons:
- The Importance of Substrate Preparation: Before surfacing, the substrate must be clean and free of oil, grease, and oxidation. Failure to do this will result in poor adhesion and spalling of the surfacing layer.
- Welding Parameter Optimization: The authors used identical parameters for both electrodes, which is appropriate for a comparative study. However, in production, the optimal parameters for each electrode may differ. For example, a higher heat input may be needed for a larger electrode to ensure proper fusion and penetration.
- Quality Assurance: After surfacing, the deposit should be inspected for cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion. Magnetic particle testing (MT) is commonly used for surface defects, while ultrasonic testing (UT) can detect subsurface defects. The hardness should also be verified at multiple locations to ensure uniformity.
- Field Validation: The laboratory fretting wear tests provide valuable data, but they do not fully replicate the conditions in the field. Therefore, I would recommend that the surfacing procedure be validated through field trials before being implemented on a large scale.
Summary and Reflection
This paper provides a useful comparison of two surfacing electrodes and their effect on the microstructure and fretting wear resistance of the resulting deposits. The key finding—that CHR237 produces a harder, more wear-resistant deposit than CHR207—is consistent with my own experience and with the general principles of hardfacing alloy design. The paper also highlights the importance of microstructure in determining wear resistance, which is a lesson that is often overlooked in practice. For engineers involved in the repair and hardfacing of components subjected to fretting wear, this paper offers practical guidance on electrode selection and process control. However, I would caution that laboratory results must be validated in the field, and that proper preheat, interpass temperature control, and post-weld treatment are essential to ensure the integrity of the surfacing layer. In the end, the success of a hardfacing operation depends on a combination of material selection, process control, and quality assurance—all of which are addressed, at least in part, by this paper. The fretting wear test data is particularly valuable because fretting is a complex wear mechanism that is often underestimated in industrial applications. By understanding the relationship between microstructure and fretting wear, engineers can make more informed decisions about surfacing materials and processes.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd