ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Corrosion Resistance of Stainless Steel Strip Electroslag Surfacing Layers

Why Cladding Corrosion Resistance Matters

I have spent my career in the pipe and pressure vessel business, and I can tell you that corrosion is not a theoretical problem. It is a real, expensive, and sometimes deadly problem. When you are building a pressure vessel for a chemical plant, or a pipe for a sour service application, the internal surface has to resist the process fluid, and the external surface has to resist the atmosphere. The traditional solution is to use a solid stainless steel or to clad a carbon steel base with a corrosion-resistant alloy. The paper by Xie Xiang and colleagues at Hohai University compares two cladding methods, strip electroslag surfacing (ESW) and strip submerged arc surfacing (SAW), and it provides valuable data on the corrosion resistance of the resulting deposits.

ESW versus SAW: Process Differences

Let me start with the process differences, because they drive everything else.

Parameter Strip Electroslag Surfacing (ESW) Strip Submerged Arc Surfacing (SAW)
Heat source Resistance heating of the slag bath Electric arc
Deposition rate Very high, 20-40 kg per hour High, 10-20 kg per hour
Dilution Low, typically 10-15 percent Higher, typically 20-30 percent
Penetration Shallow, uniform Deeper, less uniform
Deposit composition More uniform, less segregation More variation, more segregation
Slag system Conductive slag, fluoride-based Conventional SAW slag
Surface finish Smooth, requires less machining Rougher, requires more machining

The critical difference is the dilution. ESW has lower dilution because the heat is generated in the slag bath, which melts the strip and the base metal surface in a controlled manner. The result is a deposit that is closer to the intended composition, with less dilution from the carbon steel base. SAW has higher dilution because the arc is concentrated and penetrates deeper into the base metal.

This dilution difference has a direct effect on corrosion resistance. A deposit with higher dilution has more iron from the base metal, which reduces the chromium and nickel content in the deposit, which reduces the corrosion resistance. The paper's results confirm this.

Electrochemical Test Results

The authors performed electrochemical corrosion tests in two solutions, 9.8 percent sulfuric acid and 5 percent hydrochloric acid, and they also performed intergranular corrosion tests using the 10 percent oxalic acid method.

In the 9.8 percent sulfuric acid solution, the results showed that when the scan potential was below minus 300 mV, the surfacing layer metal entered a passive state. The best electrochemical corrosion performance was obtained with the ESW deposit at a welding speed of 8 meters per hour. This is a significant finding because it shows that the ESW deposit can passivate in a sulfuric acid environment, which means it forms a protective oxide film that resists further corrosion.

In the 5 percent hydrochloric acid solution, the results were different. The chloride ions are highly penetrating and they destroy the passive film that forms on the surface. The result was that the surfacing layer metal remained in an active state across the scan potential range from minus 800 to plus 200 mV, and pitting corrosion occurred. This is a classic chloride attack scenario, and it shows that neither ESW nor SAW deposits can resist hydrochloric acid at this concentration.

Intergranular Corrosion: Oxalic Acid Test

The intergranular corrosion test using 10 percent oxalic acid is a standard method for evaluating the susceptibility of stainless steel to sensitization. Sensitization occurs when chromium carbides precipitate at the grain boundaries, depleting the chromium in the adjacent regions and making them susceptible to intergranular corrosion.

The paper found that the ESW deposit had significantly better intergranular corrosion resistance than the SAW deposit. This is a critical finding because intergranular corrosion is a common failure mode in stainless steel cladding, especially in applications where the vessel is welded and then exposed to a corrosive environment.

The reason for the better intergranular corrosion resistance in the ESW deposit is likely related to the lower dilution and the more uniform composition. With less dilution, the chromium content in the deposit is higher, which means the chromium depletion at the grain boundaries is less severe. The ESW deposit also has a more uniform distribution of carbon and chromium, which reduces the driving force for chromium carbide precipitation.

Engineering Practice: Pressure Vessels and Chemical Equipment

Let me translate this into what it means for the shop floor and the delivery site.

Application Recommended Cladding Method Why
Pressure vessel for sulfuric acid service ESW Better passivation, lower dilution, more uniform composition