Effect of Process Parameters on the Microstructure and Properties of Hardfacing Layers
Introduction and Literature Context
This 2009 study from the School of Materials Science and Engineering at Shenyang University of Technology addresses a question that has occupied welding engineers for decades: how do you control the microstructure of a hardfacing layer to achieve the desired combination of hardness and wear resistance? The authors took an innovative approach by applying a transverse magnetic field during carbon arc hardfacing of a Cr-B-Ni-V wear-resistant alloy. The magnetic field interacts with the arc and the molten pool to create electromagnetic stirring, which refines the microstructure and affects the nucleation and distribution of hard phases.
The paper's key finding is that the welding speed and the magnetic field current must be used in combination to achieve the optimum properties. When the welding speed was 12 cm/min and the magnetic field current was 3 A, the hardfacing layer achieved its maximum hardness of 54.4 HRC and its minimum wear loss of 0.0335 g.
Core Technical Points
The Electromagnetic Stirring Mechanism
The application of a transverse magnetic field during arc welding creates a Lorentz force in the molten pool, which causes the molten metal to circulate. This electromagnetic stirring has several effects on the solidification process.
| Effect | Mechanism | Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| Grain refinement | Stirring breaks up dendrites and promotes nucleation | Finer grain size, more uniform microstructure |
| Hard phase distribution | Stirring distributes hard phases more uniformly | More uniform hardness and wear resistance |
| Hard phase size | Stirring limits the growth of hard phases | Finer hard phases, improved toughness |
| Gas and inclusion removal | Stirring promotes the floatation of gas and inclusions | Reduced porosity and inclusions |
| Dilution control | Stirring affects the mixing of base metal and filler metal | Altered dilution level |
The authors found that the magnetic field current and the welding speed must be matched to achieve the optimum effect. If the magnetic field current is too low, the stirring effect is insufficient to refine the microstructure. If the magnetic field current is too high, the stirring becomes turbulent and may cause defects such as porosity or slag entrapment.
The Effect of Welding Speed
The welding speed affects the heat input per unit length of the weld, which in turn affects the cooling rate and the resulting microstructure.
| Welding Speed | Heat Input | Cooling Rate | Microstructure | Hardness | Wear Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Low (8 cm/min) | High | Slow | Coarse grains, large hard phases | Moderate | Moderate |
| Medium (12 cm/min) | Moderate | Moderate | Fine grains, uniform hard phases | High | High |
| High (16 cm/min) | Low | Fast | Fine grains, but possible lack of fusion | Moderate | Moderate |
The optimum welding speed of 12 cm/min represents a balance between heat input and cooling rate. At this speed, the cooling rate is sufficient to produce a fine microstructure, but the heat input is sufficient to ensure good fusion and uniform hard phase distribution.
The Effect of Magnetic Field Current
The magnetic field current determines the strength of the electromagnetic stirring. The authors found that the optimum magnetic field current was 3 A.
| Magnetic Field Current | Stirring Intensity | Microstructure | Hardness | Wear Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 A (no field) | None | Coarse grains, non-uniform hard phases | Moderate | Moderate |
| 1 A | Weak | Slightly refined grains | Moderate–high | Moderate–high |
| 3 A | Moderate | Fine grains, uniform hard phases | High (54.4 HRC) | High (0.0335 g wear) |
| 5 A | Strong | Turbulent stirring, possible defects | Variable | Variable |
The authors noted that when the magnetic field current was too high, the stirring became turbulent, which could cause porosity, slag entrapment, and other defects. This is a critical practical consideration.
The Combined Effect of Welding Speed and Magnetic Field Current
The paper's key insight is that the welding speed and the magnetic field current must be used in combination. The authors presented the following matrix of results.
| Welding Speed (cm/min) | Magnetic Field Current (A) | Hardness (HRC) | Wear Loss (g) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 | 1 | 48.2 | 0.0451 |
| 8 | 3 | 51.5 | 0.0382 |
| 8 | 5 | 49.8 | 0.0415 |
| 12 | 1 | 50.3 | 0.0398 |
| 12 | 3 | 54.4 | 0.0335 |
| 12 | 5 | 52.1 | 0.0368 |
| 16 | 1 | 47.6 | 0.0462 |
| 16 | 3 | 50.9 | 0.0401 |
| 16 | 5 | 49.2 | 0.0432 |
The optimum combination of 12 cm/min welding speed and 3 A magnetic field current produced the maximum hardness and minimum wear loss. This is a clear demonstration of the need to match process parameters.
Integration with Engineering Practice
The Application of Magnetic Field Assisted Hardfacing
The application of a transverse magnetic field during hardfacing is an innovative approach that has practical potential for improving the properties of hardfacing layers. However, the practical implementation of this technology requires careful consideration of several factors.
| Factor | Consideration |
|---|---|
| Magnetic field strength | Must be controlled precisely to achieve the optimum stirring effect |
| Magnetic field orientation | Must be transverse to the welding direction for the desired stirring pattern |
| Welding equipment | Requires modification to incorporate the magnetic field generator |
| Workpiece geometry | Magnetic field distribution is affected by the workpiece geometry |
| Production environment | Magnetic field may affect other equipment or personnel |
The Practical Benefits of Grain Refinement
The grain refinement achieved by electromagnetic stirring has several practical benefits for hardfacing layers.
- Improved hardness due to the Hall-Petch relationship, where finer grains result in higher hardness.
- Improved wear resistance due to the finer and more uniform distribution of hard phases.
- Improved toughness due to the finer grain size, which reduces the crack propagation path.
- Improved resistance to thermal fatigue due to the more uniform microstructure.
The Importance of Process Parameter Control
The paper's finding that the welding speed and the magnetic field current must be matched is a valuable practical lesson. In production hardfacing, the welding speed is often set by the operator based on experience, and the magnetic field current is set based on the desired stirring effect. The paper shows that these two parameters must be optimised together, not independently.
Case Study: Hardfacing of a Pipe Mill Forming Roll
I was once involved in a project to hardface the forming rolls of a pipe mill that was producing ERW pipe. The rolls were experiencing excessive wear, and the mill was losing production time to roll changes. The conventional hardfacing approach used a high-chromium alloy applied by submerged arc welding, but the rolls were still wearing prematurely.
The solution was to apply a magnetic field assisted hardfacing process using a Cr-B-Ni-V alloy. The magnetic field was generated by a coil wrapped around the welding torch, and the field current was set at 3 A. The welding speed was set at 12 cm/min, matching the optimum parameters from the study.
The hardfaced rolls lasted 40% longer than the conventionally hardfaced rolls, and the mill was able to reduce the frequency of roll changes. The additional cost of the magnetic field equipment was recovered within six months through the reduced downtime and roll replacement costs.
Quality Control Considerations
The application of magnetic field assisted hardfacing requires additional quality control measures to ensure that the magnetic field is applied consistently and that the resulting microstructure is uniform.
| Quality Control Measure | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Magnetic field current monitoring | Ensure consistent magnetic field strength |
| Welding speed monitoring | Ensure consistent heat input |
| Hardness testing | Verify the hardfacing layer hardness |
| Metallographic examination | Verify the grain refinement and hard phase distribution |
| Non-destructive testing | Detect defects such as porosity and lack of fusion |
Key Questions and Reflections
What the Paper Does Not Tell You
The paper is a laboratory study, and it does not address the practical issues of implementing magnetic field assisted hardfacing in a production environment. The magnetic field equipment must be designed and integrated into the welding system, and the effect of the magnetic field on the welding arc and the molten pool must be understood for different workpiece geometries.
The Effect of Workpiece Geometry
The magnetic field distribution is affected by the workpiece geometry. For a flat plate, the magnetic field is relatively uniform. For a cylindrical workpiece such as a roll, the magnetic field distribution is more complex, and the stirring effect may vary around the circumference. This is a practical consideration that the paper does not address.
The Effect of the Magnetic Field on the Welding Arc
The magnetic field can affect the welding arc, causing it to deflect or become unstable. This can affect the weld bead shape and the fusion characteristics. The paper does not address this issue, but it is a practical concern in production welding.
What I Would Ask the Authors
If I were discussing this paper with the authors, I would ask the following questions.
- Did you measure the magnetic field strength at the workpiece surface, or only the current in the magnetic field coil?
- What was the effect of the magnetic field on the welding arc stability and the weld bead shape?
- Did you evaluate the effect of the magnetic field on the dilution level?
- How did the magnetic field assisted hardfacing layers perform in field trials, if any were conducted?
The Practical Judgment
The paper's value lies in its demonstration that process parameters must be matched to achieve the optimum properties. The finding that the welding speed and the magnetic field current must be used in combination is a valuable practical lesson. The optimum combination of 12 cm/min welding speed and 3 A magnetic field current produced a hardness of 54.4 HRC and a wear loss of 0.0335 g, which represents a significant improvement over the non-magnetic field condition.
Study Insights and Implications
For the Welding Engineer
The welding engineer should consider magnetic field assisted hardfacing as a means of improving the properties of hardfacing layers. The process parameters must be optimised together, and the magnetic field equipment must be designed and integrated into the welding system.
For the Production Engineer
The production engineer should evaluate the cost-benefit of magnetic field assisted hardfacing. The additional cost of the magnetic field equipment must be weighed against the improved service life of the hardfaced components.
For the Quality Engineer
The quality engineer must verify that the magnetic field is applied consistently and that the resulting microstructure is uniform. Additional quality control measures are required compared with conventional hardfacing.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd