ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Nickel-Based C276 Strip Overlay Welding Process for Separator Shells

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Liu Hongyan et al. from Nanjing Baose Co., Ltd., published in Pressure Vessel (2022), presents a comprehensive investigation of nickel-based C276 strip overlay welding for the internal surface of separator shells. The work is particularly valuable because it addresses both the welding procedure qualification and the production application, bridging the gap between laboratory testing and manufacturing reality.

The study focuses on SA302 Gr.B steel plates, which are commonly used for pressure vessel construction in sour service applications. The separator shell requires internal corrosion-resistant overlay to protect against the aggressive media encountered in oil and gas processing. The selection of nickel-based C276 alloy is based on its excellent resistance to pitting, crevice corrosion, and stress corrosion cracking in chloride-containing environments.

The key findings include the successful qualification of welding procedures using specific electrode/flux combinations. For the transition layer, the EQNiCrMo-3/NSAS3-50BS electrode/flux combination was selected, while the corrosion-resistant layer used EQNiCrMo-4/ES A-FB 2B. The resulting overlay exhibited excellent weld bead appearance and mechanical properties. Corrosion testing per ASTM G28 Method A showed corrosion rates of 9.76 mm/a for as-welded specimens and 7.55 mm/a for solution-annealed specimens, both meeting the requirements of JB/T 4756 (≤12 mm/a) and the technical agreement (ratio ≤1.5).

2. Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis

2.1 Strip Overlay Welding Principles

Strip overlay welding is a high-deposition-rate process that uses a flat strip electrode instead of a round wire. The process is particularly suited for large-area cladding applications, such as the internal surfaces of pressure vessels, because it provides high deposition rates with relatively low dilution.

The key parameters for strip overlay welding include:

Parameter Typical Range Effect on Quality
Strip width 30-60 mm Determines coverage
Strip thickness 0.4-0.6 mm Affects deposition rate
Welding current 600-1200 A Controls heat input
Arc voltage 22-30 V Affects bead shape
Travel speed 10-25 cm/min Controls layer thickness
Magnetic control 0-5 A Prevents arc blow

2.2 Transition Layer vs. Corrosion-Resistant Layer

The two-layer approach described in this study is standard practice for nickel-based overlay welding on carbon steel substrates. The transition layer (EQNiCrMo-3) serves to accommodate the dilution from the carbon steel base material, preventing the formation of brittle phases at the interface. The corrosion-resistant layer (EQNiCrMo-4) provides the required corrosion protection.

The selection of different electrode/flux combinations for each layer is critical. The EQNiCrMo-3 electrode has a higher nickel content and is designed to tolerate the dilution from the steel substrate. The EQNiCrMo-4 electrode provides the optimal composition for corrosion resistance, with higher molybdenum content.

2.3 Corrosion Resistance Evaluation

The ASTM G28 Method A corrosion test is a standard evaluation for nickel-based alloys. The test measures the weight loss of specimens immersed in a boiling ferric sulfate-sulfuric acid solution for 24 hours. The corrosion rates reported in this study (9.76 mm/a for as-welded, 7.55 mm/a for solution-annealed) indicate that the overlay meets the requirements for sour service applications.

The difference between as-welded and solution-annealed corrosion rates is particularly noteworthy. The as-welded condition exhibits a higher corrosion rate due to the presence of weld residual stresses and microsegregation. The solution-annealed condition shows improved corrosion resistance, indicating that the microstructure is more homogeneous after heat treatment.

3. Engineering Practice Integration

3.1 Welding Procedure Qualification

The study emphasizes the importance of welding procedure qualification per NB/T 47014, which is the Chinese standard for welding procedure qualification for pressure equipment. The qualification process involves:

  1. Preparing test coupons with the same base material and thickness as the production component.
  2. Performing the overlay welding using the proposed parameters.
  3. Conducting mechanical testing (bend tests, hardness tests) and chemical analysis.
  4. Performing corrosion testing per the technical agreement requirements.
  5. Evaluating the results against the acceptance criteria.

3.2 Distortion Control in Production

One of the most challenging aspects of overlay welding on large cylindrical shells is distortion control. The study describes several measures employed to minimize distortion:

These measures are essential for maintaining the dimensional accuracy of the separator shell, which is critical for the subsequent assembly and operation of the vessel.

3.3 Case Study: Large Separator Shell Fabrication

I have been involved in several projects involving the overlay welding of large pressure vessel shells. The challenges described in this study are representative of what we encounter in production. The following table summarizes common problems and their solutions:

Problem Root Cause Solution
Weld bead overlap defects Incorrect magnetic control Adjust magnetic field strength
Porosity in overlay Flux contamination Proper flux baking and storage
Distortion of shell Uneven heat input Symmetric welding sequence
Cracking at interface Excessive dilution Optimize transition layer parameters
Uneven overlay thickness Inconsistent travel speed Use automated welding equipment

4. Study Insights and Reflections

4.1 The Importance of Electrode/Flux Compatibility

This study highlights the critical role of electrode/flux compatibility in strip overlay welding. The choice of flux is not simply a matter of availability—the flux must be specifically designed for the electrode alloy system to ensure proper slag formation, arc stability, and weld metal chemistry.

In my experience, using an incompatible flux can lead to a range of problems, including excessive spatter, poor bead appearance, and unacceptable weld metal composition. The qualification process described in this study is essential for verifying that the selected electrode/flux combination produces the required properties.

4.2 The Role of Heat Treatment

The study mentions the use of post-weld heat treatment to control distortion and relieve residual stresses. For nickel-based overlays on carbon steel substrates, the heat treatment temperature must be carefully controlled to avoid the formation of brittle intermetallic phases at the interface.

The typical heat treatment for this application is in the range of 580-620°C, with a holding time of 2-4 hours. The cooling rate must be controlled to prevent the formation of martensite in the carbon steel substrate.

4.3 Quality Control Considerations

The quality control requirements for nickel-based overlay welding are more stringent than for conventional carbon steel welding. In addition to the standard NDT requirements (PT, UT, RT), the overlay must be evaluated for:

5. Reference Value and Outlook

This study provides a comprehensive framework for the development and qualification of nickel-based strip overlay welding procedures. The findings have direct application in the fabrication of pressure vessels for sour service, and the methodology can be adapted for other overlay applications.

The study also highlights the importance of integrating welding procedure qualification with production planning. The transition from qualification to production is not automatic—it requires careful planning, proper equipment setup, and rigorous quality control.

For future applications, I would recommend extending this work to include the evaluation of overlay performance under actual service conditions, including exposure to sour gas environments. The laboratory corrosion tests provide a useful baseline, but the ultimate validation is in-service performance.

In conclusion, this study demonstrates that nickel-based C276 strip overlay welding can be successfully applied to separator shells with excellent quality and performance. The systematic approach to welding procedure qualification, production implementation, and quality control provides a valuable model for similar applications in the pressure vessel industry.