Hot Rolling Roll Surfacing Electrode: A 1997 Lesson That Still Holds
The Problem That Never Goes Away
Hot rolling rolls are among the most abused components in a steel mill. They run at surface temperatures of 500-700°C, carry loads measured in hundreds of tonnes, and wear by a combination of abrasive, adhesive, and thermal fatigue mechanisms. A roll that wears out prematurely costs the mill not just the replacement cost, but the downtime and the quality penalties on the rolled product.
This 1997 paper from China University of Mining and Technology addresses the problem from the electrode side. The authors developed a wear-resistant surfacing electrode for hot rolling rolls and characterised the deposit in terms of microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance. The paper is old, but the principles it establishes are still relevant — and the data it reports are still useful as a benchmark.
The Alloy Design and Microstructure
The electrode deposits an alloy whose microstructure is martensite plus retained austenite plus carbides. That is a classic hardfacing structure — the martensite provides hardness, the carbides provide wear resistance, and the retained austenite provides toughness and the ability to work-harden under stress.
The XRD phase analysis confirms this three-phase structure. The carbon content is balanced to give a martensitic matrix with a controlled amount of retained austenite. Too much retained austenite and the hardness drops; too little and the deposit becomes brittle. The authors found a window that delivers HRC58-60 as deposited, which is a good target for hot roll surfaces.
The table below summarises the key properties reported.
| Property | Value |
|---|---|
| As-deposited hardness | HRC 58-60 |
| Hardness after 580°C × 1000 min aging | HRC 58-59 |
| Microstructure | Martensite + retained austenite + carbides |
| Wear resistance vs 45 steel | 6.1× |
| Test method | High-stress abrasive wear |
The Aging Stability: Why This Matters for Hot Rolls
The most important result in this paper is the aging stability. After 580°C × 1000 minutes, the hardness drops by only 1-2 HRC. That is remarkable for a martensitic alloy. Most martensitic hardfacing alloys soften significantly at 580°C because the martensite tempers and the carbides coarsen. This alloy holds its hardness because the carbide population is stable and the matrix resists over-tempering.
For a hot rolling roll, this is the difference between a surface that lasts a full campaign and one that needs re-surfacing mid-campaign. The 580°C aging test simulates the service temperature of the roll surface. If the alloy can hold HRC58-59 after 1000 minutes at that temperature, it will maintain its wear resistance throughout the roll life.
The retained austenite also plays a role. Under high-stress abrasive wear, retained austenite can transform to martensite, which is a work-hardening mechanism. This TRIP effect can actually improve the wear resistance in service, even if the as-deposited hardness is slightly lower than a fully martensitic structure.
Wear Performance: The 6.1× Benchmark
The high-stress abrasive wear test shows the deposit is 6.1 times more wear resistant than 45 steel. That is a significant improvement. 45 steel is a common roll material, so this is a meaningful benchmark. In practice, a 6× improvement in wear resistance translates to roughly a 6× extension in roll life, assuming the failure mode is abrasive wear and not thermal fatigue or cracking.
The industrial trial mentioned in the abstract confirms this. The authors report that the alloy performed well in service, which is the ultimate validation. A lab test can be misleading, but an industrial trial on a real rolling mill is the proof that matters.
What I Have Learned Applying This in Practice
I have seen hot roll surfacing done well and done badly. The alloy is only half the story. The other half is the process.
- Preheating is non-negotiable. Hot rolls are large, massive components. If you weld on a cold roll, the thermal gradient will crack the deposit and the roll. A preheat of 200-350°C, depending on the roll size and alloy, is essential.
- Interpass temperature control. For a martensitic deposit, the interpass temperature must be controlled to prevent the deposit from cooling too fast (which causes cracking) or too slow (which causes over-tempering and softening). The multi-functional device described in another paper in this batch addresses exactly this issue.
- Post-weld heat treatment. The 580°C × 1000 min aging in this paper is not just a test — it is a process step. After surfacing, the roll should be stress-relieved at a similar temperature to temper the martensite and reduce residual stresses. Skipping this step leads to spalling and cracking in service.
- Deposit thickness. The deposit should be thick enough to provide a wear allowance but not so thick that the residual stresses become unmanageable. Typically, 5-10 mm is a practical range for hot roll re-surfacing.
The Economics of Roll Re-Surfacing
The economic case for roll re-surfacing is compelling. A new hot rolling roll can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars. Re-surfacing costs a fraction of that, and a roll can be re-surfaced multiple times before it is scrapped. The 6.1× wear resistance means the re-surfaced roll lasts six times longer than a 45 steel roll, which means fewer roll changes, less downtime, and better product quality.
The key is to get the process right. A poorly executed re-surfacing job can ruin the roll, which is worse than not doing it at all. The paper provides a solid technical foundation, but the execution requires experienced welders, proper equipment, and rigorous quality control.
Key Questions and Reflections
- What is the carbon equivalent of the roll substrate? The electrode is designed for hot rolling rolls, but rolls come in various grades. If the substrate has a high carbon equivalent, preheating becomes even more critical.
- What is the maximum deposit thickness? The paper does not specify this. In practice, I would limit the deposit to 10 mm to control residual stresses.
- What is the crack resistance? Martensitic deposits are prone to cracking. The retained austenite helps, but the preheat and interpass temperature control are the real safeguards.
- How does this compare to modern flux-cored wires? The paper uses a coated electrode, which is a manual process. Modern mills use flux-cored wires and automated systems for higher deposition rates. The alloy design principles, however, are the same.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a reminder that good engineering never goes out of date. The alloy design — martensite plus retained austenite plus carbides — is still the right approach for hot roll surfacing. The aging stability at 580°C is the key property, and the 6.1× wear resistance is a strong benchmark.
For a modern shop, the takeaway is to use this alloy as a baseline and improve upon it with better process control. The electrode chemistry is proven, but the process — preheat, interpass temperature, and PWHT — is where the real gains are made.
Conclusion
This 1997 paper establishes a solid foundation for hot rolling roll surfacing. The electrode deposits a martensite plus retained austenite plus carbide structure with HRC58-60 hardness, excellent aging stability at 580°C, and 6.1 times the wear resistance of 45 steel. The key insight is that the alloy holds its hardness at service temperature, which is what matters for hot rolls. For anyone involved in roll re-surfacing, this is a valuable reference and a reminder that the process — preheat, interpass control, and PWHT — is as important as the alloy chemistry.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd