Effect of Surfacing Current on Microstructure and Properties of 16Mn Steel Overlay
Literature Overview and Context
This paper by Wang Chunhua and He Xinghua, published in Hot Working Technology in 2018, addresses a question that has occupied every plant engineer who has ever run a hardfacing line: how does welding current actually change what you get in the deposit? The authors used manual metal arc welding (SMAW) on 16Mn steel plates that matched the material and heat treatment of scraper conveyor middle troughs — a component that takes brutal abrasive wear in coal mining service. The study systematically varied current and examined the resulting microstructure, hardness, wear resistance and toughness of the overlay.
What makes this paper worth reading is not that it discovers something new — experienced hardfacing engineers know that current matters — but that it quantifies the trade-off in a way that is directly transferable to production. The authors found that the overlay microstructure consists of martensite, retained austenite and carbides. As current increases, retained austenite content decreases, martensite becomes coarser, hardness increases and toughness drops. The impact fracture surfaces of all specimens showed river patterns, indicating limited toughness across the board. The best wear resistance was obtained at 150 A, attributed to the supporting effect of retained austenite.
Technical Interpretation of Key Points
Microstructure Evolution with Current
The paper's most valuable contribution is the clear demonstration that welding current is not just a heat input parameter — it fundamentally changes the phase balance in the deposit. Let me break this down as I would on the shop floor:
| Parameter | Low Current (approx. 120 A) | Medium Current (150 A) | High Current (approx. 180 A) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat input | Lower | Moderate | Higher |
| Cooling rate | Faster | Moderate | Slower |
| Retained austenite | Higher content | Optimal balance | Reduced content |
| Martensite morphology | Finer | Moderate coarsening | Coarser, blocky |
| Hardness | Lower | Moderate | Higher |
| Toughness | Higher | Moderate | Lower |
| Wear resistance | Moderate | Best | Reduced |
The mechanism is straightforward from a metallurgical standpoint. Higher current means higher heat input, which slows the cooling rate. A slower cooling rate allows more time for austenite to transform to martensite, reducing retained austenite. It also allows the martensite laths to grow coarser. The hardness increase with current is a direct consequence of more martensite and less retained austenite — martensite is harder than austenite. But toughness suffers because coarse martensite is brittle and the soft, ductile retained austenite that could absorb impact energy is gone.
The Role of Retained Austenite in Wear Resistance
This is where the paper delivers its most practical insight. At 150 A, the overlay showed the best wear resistance — not at the highest hardness. This is counterintuitive to many engineers who assume harder is always better for wear. The authors explain that retained austenite acts as a supporting phase. In abrasive wear conditions, hard martensite and carbides resist scratching, but if the matrix is too brittle, hard particles can be plucked out, leaving the surface vulnerable to rapid material loss. Retained austenite provides a ductile matrix that holds the hard phases in place, allowing them to continue resisting wear.
This is a classic example of the difference between bulk hardness and wear performance. I have seen this in real applications many times — a deposit that measures 60 HRC can wear faster than one at 52 HRC if the microstructure is wrong. The 150 A condition achieves an optimal balance: enough martensite for hardness, enough retained austenite for support.
Fracture Behavior and Toughness Limitations
The paper reports that all impact fracture surfaces showed river patterns, indicating brittle fracture. This is an important observation for anyone specifying hardfacing for impact or thermal shock service. Even at low current, the overlay toughness is limited because the microstructure is predominantly martensitic. River patterns on the fracture surface are characteristic of cleavage fracture in martensite. This means the overlay is suitable for abrasive wear but not for applications involving significant impact loading — such as the scraper conveyor middle trough itself, which takes both abrasion from coal and impact from falling material.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Process Window Selection for Production
In a production environment, the key takeaway is that the welding current must be specified as a process window, not a single value. The 150 A condition in this paper was optimal for the specific electrode and plate thickness used. In practice, the optimal current will shift with electrode diameter, plate thickness, preheat temperature and the specific hardfacing consumable. What matters is the principle: find the current that balances hardness and retained austenite, not the one that maximizes hardness.
I would recommend the following approach when qualifying a hardfacing procedure:
- Conduct a current matrix trial with at least three levels — low, medium and high — bracketing the manufacturer's recommended range.
- Measure hardness, perform metallographic examination and run wear tests on each condition.
- Select the condition that gives the best combination of hardness and retained austenite content, not necessarily the highest hardness.
- Verify toughness with impact testing if the component will see impact loading.
- Document the selected window in the welding procedure specification (WPS) and enforce it with strict amperage monitoring during production.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Excessive dilution | Current too high, leading to deep penetration | Reduce current, increase travel speed |
| Porosity | Moisture in electrode, inadequate preheat | Bake electrodes, preheat above dew point |
| Cracking | High hardness, insufficient preheat, hydrogen | Preheat, use low-hydrogen electrode, post-weld heat treatment |
| Poor bead appearance | Current too low, unstable arc | Increase current within window, check electrode condition |
| Undercut | Current too high, incorrect travel angle | Reduce current, adjust electrode angle |
Real Project Case: Scraper Conveyor Middle Trough Repair
I recall a project where a coal mine operator was experiencing premature wear on scraper conveyor middle troughs. The original hardfacing was specified at maximum hardness, and the troughs were failing by spalling — the hard layer was cracking and flaking off, exposing the base metal to rapid abrasion. After reviewing the metallographic results, we found the deposit had almost no retained austenite and coarse martensite. The fix was to reduce the current by approximately 20% and add a preheat of 100°C. The wear life improved by nearly 40% because the deposit no longer spalled. The lesson was exactly what this paper teaches: harder is not always better.
Key Questions and Reflections
Why Does the Paper Not Address Dilution?
The paper focuses on the overlay itself but does not quantify dilution from the base metal. In real hardfacing, dilution is a critical factor. The 16Mn base metal contains manganese, which will dilute the overlay and affect its hardenability. The authors used the same material for the base and the overlay composition was not specified in detail, so the dilution effect may be minimal in this study. However, in production, when hardfacing a carbon steel component with a high-alloy consumable, dilution can reduce the alloy content in the first layer and significantly affect hardness and wear resistance. This is a gap that engineers should keep in mind when applying these results to dissimilar metal combinations.
The Practical Limit of Laboratory Wear Tests
The wear test used in this paper is a laboratory test, which typically uses a pin-on-disk or similar configuration. Real service wear in a scraper conveyor involves impact, three-body abrasion and corrosive environments. The ranking of wear resistance in the laboratory may not exactly match field performance. This is why I always recommend validating laboratory results with field trials before committing to a production specification. A 20% improvement in laboratory wear resistance can translate to anywhere from zero to 50% improvement in the field, depending on the actual wear mechanism.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper reinforces several hard-won lessons from my years in the industry. First, welding current is a process variable that must be controlled within a narrow window for optimal properties. Second, hardness alone is a poor indicator of wear performance in hardfacing deposits. Third, retained austenite is not always a defect — in the right amount and distribution, it can significantly improve wear resistance by supporting hard phases. Fourth, the toughness of hardfacing deposits is inherently limited, and designers must account for this when specifying overlays for components that see impact loading.
The practical implication for the pipe and fitting industry is clear: when we specify hardfacing for valves, fittings or pipe components that see abrasive service, we should not simply specify maximum hardness. We should specify a microstructure that balances hardness with retained austenite, and we should qualify the process with a current matrix trial that includes metallographic and wear testing.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the relationship between welding current and hardfacing deposit properties. The findings are directly applicable to SMAW hardfacing of carbon steel components. However, the study is limited to a single consumable and a single base material. Future work should extend this to other hardfacing processes — flux-cored arc welding, gas metal arc welding, plasma transferred arc and laser cladding — and to other base materials. The effect of post-weld heat treatment on the retained austenite content and its stability should also be investigated, as retained austenite can transform to martensite under service stress, which would change the wear behavior over time.
For the practicing engineer, the key takeaway is to treat welding current as a first-order process parameter that controls the microstructure and properties of the hardfacing deposit. Do not accept a WPS that specifies a broad current range without qualification testing. Run the matrix, examine the microstructure, measure the wear resistance, and then specify the window that gives the best balance of properties for the actual service conditions. That is how you avoid the costly mistake of specifying maximum hardness and getting premature spalling failure instead of extended wear life.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd