ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Literature Study Note on Comparison of Stainless Steel Strip Electroslag and Submerged Arc Surfacing for Thick-Walled Pressure Vessels

Overview of the Literature

This paper by Wang Jiachun and Sun Dunwu from Harbin Welding Research Institute, published in Welding (1997, No.7), presents a comprehensive comparison of stainless steel strip electroslag surfacing and strip submerged arc surfacing for the internal cladding of thick-walled pressure vessels. The study examined surfacing process, weld bead formation, base metal dilution rate, cladding layer performance, and fusion zone characteristics. The authors concluded that strip electroslag surfacing is superior to strip submerged arc surfacing and can replace the latter for the internal cladding of thick-walled pressure vessels.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

The Need for Corrosion-Resistant Cladding

Thick-walled pressure vessels used in the chemical, petrochemical, and nuclear industries are often made of low-alloy steel for strength and economy. However, the process media inside these vessels are often corrosive, requiring a corrosion-resistant cladding on the internal surface. Stainless steel is the most common cladding material. The cladding must be metallurgically bonded to the base metal, have a uniform chemical composition, and exhibit good corrosion resistance.

Strip Electroslag vs. Strip Submerged Arc Surfacing

The paper compared two processes for applying the stainless steel cladding: strip electroslag surfacing and strip submerged arc surfacing. Both processes use a wide strip electrode, but the heat transfer and deposition mechanisms are different. In strip submerged arc surfacing, the arc is the primary heat source, and the strip is melted and deposited onto the base metal. In strip electroslag surfacing, the heat is generated by the resistance of the molten slag, and the strip is melted by the slag's heat.

Dilution Rate and Cladding Performance

One of the key differences between the two processes is the dilution rate. Dilution is the percentage of base metal in the deposited cladding. A high dilution rate is undesirable because it increases the carbon and alloy content of the cladding, which can reduce its corrosion resistance. The paper's results showed that strip electroslag surfacing produces a lower dilution rate than strip submerged arc surfacing. This is a significant advantage because it allows the cladding to maintain its intended chemical composition and corrosion resistance.

Fusion Zone Characteristics

The paper also examined the fusion zone characteristics of the two processes. The fusion zone is the region where the cladding is metallurgically bonded to the base metal. The paper's results showed that strip electroslag surfacing produces a more uniform fusion zone with fewer defects than strip submerged arc surfacing. This is important for ensuring the integrity of the cladding and preventing failure during service.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

The Economic Case for Strip Electroslag Surfacing

The paper's conclusion that strip electroslag surfacing can replace strip submerged arc surfacing has significant economic implications. Strip electroslag surfacing typically has a higher deposition rate than strip submerged arc surfacing, which means that the cladding can be applied in less time. This reduces the manufacturing cost of the pressure vessel. The lower dilution rate also means that less expensive cladding material can be used, as the chemical composition of the cladding is more predictable.

Process Control and Quality Assurance

The paper's comparison of the two processes highlights the importance of process control. In strip electroslag surfacing, the slag pool depth and the electrical parameters must be carefully controlled to ensure a consistent deposit. In strip submerged arc surfacing, the arc voltage and current must be controlled to achieve the desired bead shape and penetration. The practical engineer must understand the process parameters and their effect on the cladding quality.

Non-Destructive Testing and Cladding Integrity

The integrity of the cladding is critical for the performance of the pressure vessel. Non-destructive testing, such as ultrasonic testing and liquid penetrant testing, is used to detect defects in the cladding and the fusion zone. The paper's results suggest that strip electroslag surfacing produces a more uniform cladding with fewer defects, which simplifies the NDT process and reduces the risk of missing a defect.

Key Questions and Reflections

Why Is Dilution Rate So Important?

The dilution rate is a critical parameter in cladding because it determines the chemical composition of the cladding. A high dilution rate can lead to a cladding that is not fully corrosion-resistant, which can cause premature failure of the pressure vessel. The paper's finding that strip electroslag surfacing produces a lower dilution rate is a key advantage of this process.

What Are the Limitations of Strip Electroslag Surfacing?

The paper does not extensively discuss the limitations of strip electroslag surfacing. One potential limitation is that the process is more sensitive to the condition of the base metal surface. If the base metal is not properly prepared, the slag pool may not form correctly, leading to defects. Another limitation is that the process may not be suitable for all cladding materials. The practical engineer should consider the specific application when selecting a cladding process.

How Does This Compare to Modern Practices?

The paper was published in 1997, and the field of cladding technology has evolved significantly since then. Modern cladding processes, such as laser cladding and cold metal transfer, offer different advantages and disadvantages. However, the fundamental principles of cladding metallurgy remain the same. The paper's comparison of strip electroslag and strip submerged arc surfacing provides a solid foundation for understanding the differences between these two processes.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper reinforces the importance of selecting the right cladding process for the specific application. The paper's conclusion that strip electroslag surfacing is superior to strip submerged arc surfacing for thick-walled pressure vessels is a valuable insight. The lower dilution rate and more uniform fusion zone of strip electroslag surfacing make it a better choice for applications where corrosion resistance is critical.

For the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, the principles of cladding technology are directly applicable. Clad pipes and fittings are used in corrosive service environments, and the quality of the cladding is critical for their performance. The paper's comparison of cladding processes provides valuable information for anyone involved in the manufacture of clad products.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in cladding technology, particularly for thick-walled pressure vessels. The comprehensive comparison of strip electroslag and strip submerged arc surfacing provides a solid foundation for understanding the differences between these two processes. The paper's conclusion that strip electroslag surfacing is superior is a valuable insight for anyone involved in the manufacture of clad products.

Looking to the future, the demand for clad products will continue to grow as the industry moves towards more corrosive service environments. The development of new cladding processes will benefit from the systematic approach demonstrated in this paper. The lessons learned about process control and cladding quality will remain valuable. The paper is a reminder that the best cladding process is the one that produces a high-quality, corrosion-resistant cladding at the lowest cost.