ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Dissimilar Steel Welding and Cladding in Hydrogenation Equipment

Literature Overview and Core Message

This study by Chai Xiangdong addresses a critical issue in the fabrication of hydrogenation equipment: the welding and cladding of dissimilar steel joints. The author, drawing on experience from Sinopec Guangzhou Engineering, discusses the challenges of dissimilar steel welding, the mechanisms of hydrogen disbonding, and the selection of appropriate welding methods and materials.

The core message is that dissimilar steel welding in hydrogenation equipment is inherently problematic due to differences in material properties, thermal expansion and carbon migration. The key failure mode is hydrogen disbonding, which occurs when hydrogen accumulates at the interface between the cladding and the base metal, causing the cladding to separate. The author recommends specific cladding schemes based on practical experience: single-layer cladding using strip submerged arc welding, and double-layer cladding using strip submerged arc welding plus strip electroslag welding.

Technical Parameters and Process Window

The following table summarises the key considerations for dissimilar steel welding and cladding in hydrogenation equipment.

Parameter Consideration Practical Significance
Dissimilar steel joint Differences in composition, thermal expansion Causes interfacial stress and carbon migration
Hydrogen disbonding H accumulation at interface, H concentration gradient Critical failure mode in hydrogenation service
Carbon migration C diffuses from low-alloy to high-alloy side Weakens the interface, promotes disbonding
Single-layer cladding Strip submerged arc welding Recommended for single-layer applications
Double-layer cladding Strip SAW + strip electroslag welding Recommended for double-layer applications
Interface stress Thermal mismatch, residual stress Contributes to disbonding
H concentration Higher at interface than in bulk Drives disbonding mechanism

The key technical insight is that hydrogen disbonding is driven by three factors: interfacial stress, hydrogen concentration at the interface, and carbon migration during cladding. The cladding method affects the interface microstructure and the hydrogen disbonding tendency. Therefore, the choice of cladding method is critical.

Process Analysis and Metallurgical Considerations

The recommended cladding schemes are based on practical experience. For single-layer cladding, strip submerged arc welding is preferred because it provides a uniform, low-dilution deposit with good bond quality. For double-layer cladding, the first layer is applied by strip submerged arc welding, and the second layer is applied by strip electroslag welding. The electroslag process provides a higher deposition rate and a smoother surface, which is beneficial for the second layer.

The carbon migration issue is particularly important. During cladding, carbon diffuses from the low-alloy steel substrate into the high-alloy cladding, creating a carbon-depleted zone in the substrate and a carbon-enriched zone in the cladding. This weakens the interface and promotes hydrogen disbonding. The choice of cladding method can influence the extent of carbon migration. Lower heat input and faster cooling reduce the time available for diffusion, which reduces carbon migration.

The hydrogen disbonding mechanism is complex. Hydrogen from the process environment diffuses into the steel and accumulates at the interface. The interfacial stress, combined with the hydrogen concentration, causes the cladding to separate. The critical factors are the hydrogen partial pressure, the operating temperature, and the interface microstructure.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have seen hydrogen disbonding failures in real hydrogenation equipment. The typical failure mode is a blister or a crack at the interface between the cladding and the base metal. The failure is often not detected until the equipment is inspected, and by then the damage is significant.

The practical lesson is that the cladding method matters. A poorly chosen cladding method can lead to a high hydrogen disbonding tendency, which is a safety risk in hydrogenation service. The recommended schemes — single-layer strip SAW and double-layer strip SAW plus strip electroslag — have been proven in service and are a sound basis for specification.

Another lesson is the importance of post-weld heat treatment (PWHT). Hydrogen disbonding is exacerbated by residual stress. PWHT reduces residual stress and improves the resistance to hydrogen disbonding. However, PWHT must be carefully controlled to avoid other problems, such as temper embrittlement or reheat cracking.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper recommends specific cladding schemes, but it does not provide quantitative data on the hydrogen disbonding resistance of each scheme. I would want to see test data from hydrogen disbonding tests, such as those specified in API 941 or similar standards, to confirm the recommendations.

Another question is the effect of the cladding thickness. In hydrogenation service, the cladding must be thick enough to prevent hydrogen from reaching the base metal. The recommended thickness depends on the hydrogen partial pressure and the operating temperature. This is a critical design consideration that must be addressed in the equipment specification.

The choice of welding consumables is also critical. The filler metal must be compatible with both the base metal and the cladding material. For dissimilar steel joints, the filler metal is often selected to match the lower-alloy side, but this can lead to problems on the higher-alloy side. A careful analysis of the service conditions is required.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the fabrication of hydrogenation equipment. It highlights the key challenges of dissimilar steel welding and cladding, and it provides practical recommendations based on real experience. The recommended cladding schemes — single-layer strip SAW and double-layer strip SAW plus strip electroslag — are proven in service and should be considered as a baseline for specification.

For our industry, the key takeaway is that hydrogen disbonding is a serious failure mode that must be addressed in the design and fabrication of hydrogenation equipment. The choice of cladding method, welding consumables and PWHT are all critical factors. The paper provides a sound basis for making these decisions.

Concluding Summary

Dissimilar steel welding and cladding in hydrogenation equipment presents significant challenges due to differences in material properties, thermal expansion and carbon migration. Hydrogen disbonding is the critical failure mode, driven by interfacial stress, hydrogen concentration and carbon migration. The recommended cladding schemes — single-layer strip submerged arc welding and double-layer strip submerged arc welding plus strip electroslag welding — are proven in service and provide a sound basis for specification. The key to success is careful selection of cladding method, welding consumables and post-weld heat treatment, combined with rigorous quality control and inspection.