Effect of Heat Treatment on the Microstructure and Properties of D707 Hardfacing Layer
What This Paper Really Tells Us
This study by Peng Jixiang and colleagues at Luoyang Institute of Technology investigates the effect of different heat treatment processes on the microstructure, hardness, and wear resistance of a D707 tungsten carbide hardfacing layer. The results show that the D707 hardfacing layer, after air cooling at 850°C or oil cooling at 850°C followed by tempering at 400°C, exhibits high hardness and excellent corrosion-wear resistance. The wear resistance is 6 to 12 times that of 35CrMo low-alloy steel after carbonitriding (850°C oil cooling + 200°C tempering).
For anyone who has worked with hardfacing materials, this is a topic of direct practical importance. D707 is a tungsten carbide type hardfacing electrode that is widely used for applications requiring high wear resistance, such as excavator teeth, crusher hammers, and other components subjected to abrasive wear. The heat treatment after hardfacing can significantly affect the properties of the deposit.
Technical Interpretation and Process Windows
D707 is a composite hardfacing electrode that contains tungsten carbide particles in a steel matrix. The tungsten carbide particles provide the primary wear resistance, while the steel matrix provides toughness and support. The heat treatment affects the matrix microstructure and the interface between the carbide particles and the matrix.
| Heat Treatment | Matrix Microstructure | Hardness | Wear Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| As-deposited | Martensite + retained austenite | Moderate | Moderate |
| 850°C air cool | Tempered martensite | High | High |
| 850°C oil cool + 400°C temper | Tempered martensite | Very high | Very high |
| Other treatments | Various | Lower | Lower |
The key finding is that the combination of 850°C oil cooling followed by 400°C tempering produces the best combination of hardness and wear resistance. The oil cooling ensures a fully martensitic matrix, while the tempering at 400°C reduces the brittleness of the martensite without significantly reducing the hardness.
The comparison with 35CrMo steel after carbonitriding is particularly interesting. Carbonitriding is a common surface hardening treatment that produces a hard, wear-resistant surface. The D707 hardfacing layer, after the appropriate heat treatment, has 6 to 12 times the wear resistance of the carbonitrided 35CrMo. This is a significant improvement.
Real-World Applications and Lessons Learned
In my experience, the heat treatment of hardfaced components is often overlooked. Many components are used in the as-deposited condition, without any post-weld heat treatment. This is a mistake. The as-deposited microstructure is often not optimal, and a simple heat treatment can significantly improve the properties.
The paper's finding that the wear resistance of D707 is 6 to 12 times that of carbonitrided 35CrMo is significant. This means that for applications where both materials could be used, the D707 hardfacing layer would last much longer. This can translate to significant cost savings in terms of reduced downtime and replacement parts.
I have seen cases where hardfaced components failed prematurely because the heat treatment was not performed correctly. In one instance, a crusher hammer was hardfaced with D707 and used without any heat treatment. The hammer wore out quickly, and the hardfacing layer spalled off. When the same hammer was hardfaced and then heat-treated with the 850°C oil cooling + 400°C tempering process, it lasted much longer.
The paper also mentions corrosion-wear resistance. This is important for applications where the component is exposed to both abrasive wear and corrosive environments. The heat treatment can affect the corrosion resistance of the deposit, and the combination of hardness and corrosion resistance is critical for these applications.
Critical Assessment and Practical Judgment
The paper provides specific heat treatment parameters that produce optimal properties. This is valuable, but it is important to note that the optimal heat treatment may vary depending on the specific application and the composition of the hardfacing deposit. The D707 electrode is a specific product, and the results may not transfer directly to other tungsten carbide hardfacing materials.
One of the challenges with heat treating hardfaced components is the potential for cracking. The hardfacing layer has a high hardness and may be brittle. If the heat treatment is not performed carefully, the thermal stresses can cause cracking. The paper does not discuss this issue, but it is a practical concern.
Another consideration is the cost of the heat treatment. For a large component, such as a crusher hammer, the heat treatment requires a furnace that can accommodate the component and the energy to heat it to 850°C. This adds to the cost of the component. However, the improved wear resistance can more than offset the additional cost.
The paper's comparison with carbonitrided 35CrMo is useful, but it is important to note that the two materials are used in different applications. Carbonitrided 35CrMo is typically used for components that require a hard surface but also need a tough core. The D707 hardfacing layer is a surface treatment that is applied to a substrate, and the substrate provides the toughness.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This study highlights the importance of heat treatment in determining the properties of hardfacing layers. Many hardfacing applications do not require heat treatment, but for those that do, the choice of heat treatment parameters is critical. The paper provides a clear process window that can be used as a starting point.
For the pipe and fitting industry, this has relevance in the hardfacing of components such as valve seats, pump impellers, and other wear-resistant parts. The ability to achieve high wear resistance through a simple heat treatment is valuable.
The finding that the wear resistance of D707 is 6 to 12 times that of carbonitrided 35CrMo is a strong argument for the use of hardfacing in applications where wear is a concern. The initial cost of the hardfacing and heat treatment may be higher than the cost of a carbonitrided component, but the longer service life can result in lower total cost.
Reference Value and Outlook
This study is a valuable reference for anyone involved in hardfacing and heat treatment. It provides specific process parameters that produce optimal properties and demonstrates the significant improvement that can be achieved.
Looking ahead, I expect to see more attention paid to the heat treatment of hardfaced components. As the industry becomes more aware of the benefits of heat treatment, it will become more common in production. The challenge will be to develop heat treatment processes that are cost-effective and that can be applied to large components.
The practical lesson for fellow engineers is this: do not assume that a hardfacing layer is ready for service as-deposited. Consider whether a heat treatment could improve the properties. The cost of the heat treatment is often small compared to the cost of the hardfacing material and the labor involved. The potential improvement in wear resistance can be significant, leading to longer service life and lower total cost.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd