ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Cracking Failure Analysis and Improvement of Stellite Hardfacing on Domestic Turbine-Driven Pump Balance Disc

Literature Overview

The paper by Liu Xing from Fujian Fuqing Nuclear Power Co., Ltd., published in Nuclear Science and Engineering (2020, Vol. 40, No. 4), documents a real engineering failure that occurred during the first overhaul of a domestically manufactured turbine-driven pump. Cracks were discovered in the Stellite hardfacing layer on the balance disc, a critical component that manages axial thrust in high-speed rotating machinery. The paper walks through the metallurgical investigation, identifies the root causes, and describes the corrective actions that were validated through factory testing. This is a textbook case of how a seemingly localized welding defect can trace back to systemic issues in process design and machining practice.

Core Technical Points

Failure Investigation Findings

The investigation employed a combination of microscopic examination, energy-dispersive spectroscopy (EDS), and cross-sectional observation of the crack morphology. The key findings are summarized below.

Investigation Method Observation Interpretation
Microscopic morphology Cracks initiated at the surface and propagated inward Surface-originated cracking, typical of thermal or mechanical stress concentration
EDS measurement Compositional anomalies detected at crack locations Possible contamination or segregation during deposition
Cross-section observation Cracks followed the hardfacing/substrate interface or ran through the deposit Weak bonding or excessive residual stress at the interface

The paper concludes that the cracking was not a random event but a consequence of accumulated deficiencies in both the welding process and the subsequent machining operations.

Root Cause Analysis

The authors systematically analyzed the axial force calculation for the turbine-driven pump rotor, reviewed the Stellite hardfacing process, and examined the mechanical machining procedures. The root causes were identified as follows:

  1. Inadequate control of welding parameters — The hardfacing process did not maintain a consistent heat input, leading to uneven dilution and residual stress distribution.
  2. Machining-induced stress concentration — The mechanical machining of the hardfacing layer likely introduced surface damage or residual tensile stresses that acted as crack initiation sites.
  3. Material compatibility issues — The interaction between the Stellite alloy and the substrate material was not fully optimized, leading to interfacial weaknesses.

Engineering Practice Insights

What the Shop Floor Really Cares About

This failure is a reminder that hardfacing is not just about depositing a wear-resistant layer. It is a metallurgical bonding process where the interface quality, dilution control, and residual stress management are equally critical. In my experience, the balance disc of a pump is a component where precision and reliability are non-negotiable — a crack here can lead to catastrophic pump failure and potential nuclear safety implications.

Process Improvement Recommendations

Based on the root cause analysis, the paper proposes several corrective measures:

Improvement Area Specific Action Expected Outcome
Welding process Optimize heat input, preheat, and interpass temperature control Reduced residual stress and uniform dilution
Machining process Use gentler cutting parameters, avoid sharp tool marks Elimination of stress concentration sites
Post-weld treatment Consider stress relief or peening Improved resistance to crack initiation and propagation

The authors report that the new process was validated through factory testing, demonstrating a significant improvement in the hardfacing layer's resistance to crack initiation and propagation. This provides a valuable engineering reference for the optimization of domestic turbine-driven pumps in future Hualong units.

Key Questions and Reflections

  1. Why did the cracks appear only after the pump had been in service? This suggests that the hardfacing layer was already compromised during manufacturing, and the operational stresses during pump operation triggered crack propagation. A more rigorous inspection regime during manufacturing, including phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT) or eddy current testing, could have detected the defects before commissioning.
  2. What is the role of the axial force calculation in this failure? The paper's inclusion of the axial force calculation suggests that the design of the balance disc and the magnitude of axial forces were factors in the failure. If the axial force was higher than anticipated, the hardfacing layer would be subjected to greater compressive or tensile stresses, exacerbating any existing defects.
  3. Could this failure have been prevented by better process control? Absolutely. This is a classic case where the manufacturing process was not robust enough. A well-designed welding procedure specification (WPS) with strict parameter windows, combined with a machining process that respects the hardfacing's brittle nature, would have likely prevented this failure.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable case study for the nuclear power industry and for anyone involved in hardfacing of critical rotating components. It demonstrates the importance of a holistic approach to component manufacturing — from design calculations through welding and machining to final inspection. The failure was not caused by a single defect but by a chain of process deficiencies. The corrective actions, validated through factory testing, provide a clear path forward for similar applications.

For the steel pipe and fitting industry, the lessons are equally applicable. Hardfacing is used on valve seats, gate valve discs, and other wear-prone components in pipeline systems. The same attention to welding parameters, dilution control, and post-weld machining is essential to ensure long-term reliability.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper provides a detailed, well-documented failure analysis that can serve as a reference for any engineer dealing with hardfacing issues. It emphasizes the importance of root cause analysis and the need for systematic process improvement. As the nuclear industry continues to develop domestic equipment, this type of engineering feedback loop is critical for building confidence in locally manufactured components.

The future direction should include more advanced non-destructive testing methods for hardfacing layers, as well as the development of more robust hardfacing alloys that are less sensitive to process variations. This will not only improve reliability but also reduce manufacturing costs by minimizing rework and scrap.