ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Comparison of Microstructure and Properties of Pinch Roll Hardfacing Layers After Annealing: Delstain-442 vs. Multipass-249 vs. Multipass-224HC

The Application Context

This 2025 paper from Metal Heat Treatment (金属热处理) addresses a very specific but critical problem: the selection of hardfacing filler wire for hot rolling pinch rolls. The authors, Teng Hongyin, Wang Yinjun, and Wu Suotuan from Meishan Iron & Steel, compare three commercial filler wires — Delstain-442 (the incumbent), Multipass-249 (a proposed replacement), and Multipass-224HC (another candidate) — after annealing at 500°C and 540°C.

The pinch roll is one of the most demanding components in a hot rolling mill. It operates at elevated temperatures (often 400–600°C), under high loads, and in an environment with scale, water, and abrasive particles. The hardfacing layer must maintain its hardness and wear resistance at temperature, while also having sufficient toughness to resist thermal fatigue and impact. The paper's focus on post-weld annealing is particularly relevant because the hardfacing layer is often stress-relieved after welding, and the annealing temperature directly affects the final microstructure and properties.

Core Findings and Interpretation

Retained Austenite Transformation

The paper's most important finding is that, after annealing at both 500°C and 540°C, the retained austenite in all three hardfacing layers transforms to martensite. This is a classic secondary hardening effect: the retained austenite, which is unstable at room temperature, decomposes during annealing, and the resulting martensite increases hardness but may reduce toughness.

The key difference is that the Delstain-442 hardfacing layer transforms more completely than the other two. This means that Delstain-442 reaches a more stable microstructure after annealing, which is beneficial for dimensional stability and consistent properties in service. The Multipass-249 layer retains some austenite even after 540°C annealing, which may be beneficial for toughness but could lead to dimensional instability if the austenite transforms in service.

Hardness and Wear Resistance

The paper reports that the 540°C annealed Multipass-249 hardfacing layer has better toughness and more stable microstructure, with better high-temperature wear resistance. This is a significant finding, because it suggests that Multipass-249 could be a viable replacement for Delstain-442, provided the toughness is acceptable.

The Multipass-224HC layer, on the other hand, has higher brittleness, but its wear resistance after both annealing temperatures is excellent — the wear rate is an order of magnitude lower than Delstain-442. This is likely due to the presence of hard carbide particles in the deposit, which provide excellent abrasive wear resistance but reduce toughness.

The following table summarizes the key findings:

Property Delstain-442 (500°C) Delstain-442 (540°C) Multipass-249 (500°C) Multipass-249 (540°C) Multipass-224HC (500°C) Multipass-224HC (540°C)
Retained austenite transformation Incomplete More complete Incomplete Some retained Incomplete Incomplete
Hardness Moderate Higher Moderate Higher High High
Toughness Moderate Moderate Good Best Low Low
Wear resistance Baseline Better Better Best Excellent Excellent
Microstructural stability Moderate Good Moderate Good Moderate Moderate

Practical Implications for Pinch Roll Manufacturing

Selection Criteria

The paper's conclusion — that 540°C annealed Multipass-249 has the best overall performance, but its impact toughness is questionable and further verification is needed — is exactly the kind of honest assessment that a veteran engineer appreciates. In the real world, you cannot just pick the wire with the highest hardness; you must balance hardness against toughness, and you must consider the service conditions.

For a pinch roll, the primary failure modes are:

The ideal hardfacing layer would have high hardness (to resist abrasion), good toughness (to resist impact and thermal fatigue), and good corrosion resistance. In practice, you rarely get all three, so you must prioritize based on the specific roll's duty.

Annealing Temperature

The paper's finding that 540°C annealing gives better high-temperature hardness and wear resistance for Delstain-442 is important. In a hot rolling mill, the pinch roll surface can reach 400–500°C in service, so the hardfacing layer must maintain its properties at that temperature. A 540°C anneal simulates the upper end of the service temperature range, and the fact that the hardness is retained is a good sign.

However, the annealing temperature must be compatible with the roll body material. If the roll body is a cast steel or forged steel that cannot withstand 540°C without losing its own properties, you cannot use that annealing temperature. This is a critical practical constraint that the paper does not fully address, but it is one that the manufacturing engineer must consider.

My Practical Judgment

This paper is a good example of the kind of comparative study that should be done before any material change in a production environment. The authors have done the right thing: they took three candidate wires, welded them under controlled conditions, annealed them at two relevant temperatures, and compared the resulting microstructure and properties. The data is useful, and the conclusion is appropriately cautious.

From my experience, the decision to replace an incumbent hardfacing wire is never simple. The incumbent may have years of service data behind it, and even if a new wire shows better laboratory properties, the real-world performance can be different. The paper's caution about Multipass-249's impact toughness is well-founded — I have seen hardfacing layers with excellent hardness fail catastrophically in service because a single impact event cracked the layer and the crack propagated into the roll body.

The Multipass-224HC result is interesting but not surprising. A carbide-rich hardfacing layer will always have excellent abrasive wear resistance, but its low toughness makes it unsuitable for applications with significant impact. For a pinch roll that handles thin strip with minimal impact, it might be a good choice. For a pinch roll that handles thick, heavy strip, the impact loads would likely crack it.

My recommendation would be to follow the paper's suggestion and conduct further verification of Multipass-249's impact toughness, but also to consider a service trial. Run a controlled trial on one or two rolls in the mill, monitor the wear rate and surface condition over a full campaign, and compare the results with the incumbent Delstain-442. Only then can you make a confident decision.

In summary, this paper provides valuable comparative data on three hardfacing wires for pinch rolls. The key message is that the choice is not simply about hardness — it is about the balance of hardness, toughness, and microstructural stability at service temperature. The 540°C annealed Multipass-249 appears to be the best candidate, but its toughness needs verification. This is a good, honest study that reflects the real complexity of material selection in the steel industry.