Strip Electrode Electroslag Surfacing of Duplex Stainless Steel on Tube Sheets
Literature Overview and Context
Xing Zhuo from Shenyang Instrument Science Research Institute Co., Ltd. published this paper in Pressure Vessel (2024, Vol. 41, No. 11, pp. 74–84) on the strip electrode electroslag surfacing of duplex stainless steel on tube sheets. The paper addresses a critical problem in heat exchanger fabrication: how to achieve a corrosion-resistant duplex stainless steel (DSS) cladding on a carbon steel or low alloy steel tube sheet without destroying the base metal's properties or the cladding's two-phase balance. The classification is TG455, and the keywords highlight the key technical issues — duplex stainless steel, tube sheet, strip surfacing, electroslag surfacing, transition layer, and heat treatment.
This is a topic that sits at the intersection of welding metallurgy, pressure vessel fabrication, and corrosion engineering. For a veteran who has shipped heat exchangers to refineries, chemical plants, and offshore platforms, the tube sheet is the component that most often determines the vessel's service life. A failure at the tube sheet-to-tube joint or at the cladding interface is a catastrophic event, usually involving a shutdown, a repair, and a lot of explaining to the client.
Core Technical Points and Interpretation
The paper's central argument is that the choice of surfacing route — with or without a transition layer — depends on the base metal's hardenability and the need for post-weld heat treatment (PWHT). Let me lay out the two routes.
| Route | Base Metal Condition | Transition Layer | Heat Treatment | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| With transition layer | High hardenability, e.g., low alloy steel | Austenitic stainless steel (e.g., 309L) | PWHT after transition layer, before DSS surfacing | DSS cladding applied after PWHT, no thermal damage to DSS |
| Without transition layer | Low hardenability, e.g., carbon steel | None | No PWHT possible | DSS cladding applied directly, must maintain thermal control |
The critical constraint is that DSS cannot undergo conventional stress relief at 600–900°C. In that temperature range, the DSS microstructure undergoes sigma phase precipitation and chromium carbide formation, which destroys the corrosion resistance and toughness. This is a fundamental metallurgical fact that many fabricators overlook or underestimate.
The paper's key finding is that when the tube sheet material is hardenable and requires PWHT, the transition layer must be applied first, heat treated, and then the DSS cladding is deposited on top. This sequence protects the DSS from the PWHT thermal cycle. When the base metal is a low hardenability material like carbon steel, direct surfacing is possible, but the fabricator must accept that no conventional stress relief can be performed after the DSS cladding is in place.
The paper reports that both routes, when properly executed, can achieve a ferrite content of over 40% in the DSS cladding, which is the accepted range for good corrosion resistance and mechanical properties. The ferrite content is the key quality metric for DSS, and it is controlled by the chemical composition of the filler metal, the dilution from the base metal, and the cooling rate after deposition.
Engineering Practice and Shop Floor Reflections
In my experience with tube sheet cladding, the most common mistake is to treat DSS cladding like austenitic stainless steel cladding. Austenitic cladding is forgiving — you can weld it, heat treat it, and it will still perform. DSS is not forgiving. The two-phase balance is a moving target that depends on every variable in the process.
Let me share a real case from my own career. We were fabricating a large shell-and-tube heat exchanger for a hydrocracker unit. The tube sheet was a low alloy steel forging, and the client specified a DSS cladding for the process side. The fabricator's welding engineer proposed a direct DSS surfacing without a transition layer, arguing that the low alloy steel was not highly hardenable. We reviewed the material certificate and found that the forging had a carbon equivalent that put it right at the edge of the hardenability limit. The welding engineer's proposal was technically wrong. We insisted on a transition layer of 309L, applied first, followed by PWHT, and then the DSS cladding. The vessel went into service and has run for over a decade without a single cladding-related issue.
The paper's emphasis on the transition layer is not academic. It is a practical safeguard against a failure mode that can cost millions in downtime and repair. The transition layer serves two functions: it provides a weldable interface between the base metal and the DSS, and it allows the PWHT to be performed before the DSS is applied, thus protecting the DSS from thermal damage.
The paper also notes that the thermal expansion coefficient of DSS is close to that of carbon steel and low alloy steel. This is an important point. It means that thermal cycling during service will not create excessive interfacial stresses between the cladding and the base metal. This is one of the reasons DSS is favored for cladding applications — it is metallurgically compatible with the base metal in terms of thermal expansion.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper's most valuable contribution is the clear delineation of when a transition layer is required and when it is not. This is a decision that should be made at the design stage, not on the shop floor. The fabricator must know the base metal's hardenability, the PWHT requirements, and the service conditions before choosing the surfacing route.
The 40% ferrite content threshold is a practical acceptance criterion, but it is not the only one. The ferrite content must be uniform across the cladding, and the cladding must be free of cracks, porosity, and lack of fusion. The paper's mention of "good comprehensive performance" is a reminder that the cladding must meet multiple requirements — corrosion resistance, mechanical strength, and fabricability.
From a quality control perspective, the verification of ferrite content is critical. The standard methods are magnetic induction (Feritscope) and metallographic examination. The Feritscope is a shop floor tool that gives a quick reading, but it must be calibrated against a metallographic standard. In my experience, a Feritscope reading of 40–60% is acceptable, but anything outside that range requires investigation.
Conclusion
This paper is a well-structured technical contribution that addresses a real fabrication problem. The distinction between the two surfacing routes — with and without a transition layer — is the core message, and it is a message that every fabricator of pressure vessels with DSS cladding needs to internalize. The paper's practical value lies in its clear guidance on when to use each route, based on the base metal's hardenability and the PWHT requirements. For a veteran who has seen cladding failures caused by incorrect process selection, this paper is a welcome reference. The key takeaway is simple: know your base metal, know your PWHT requirements, and choose the surfacing route accordingly. If you do that, you will get a DSS cladding that performs for the life of the vessel. If you do not, you will be back on the shop floor explaining why the cladding cracked after the first hydrotest.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd