ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tube Sheet Electroslag Strip Cladding with Duplex Stainless Steel: A Metallurgical and Practical Analysis

Background and Problem Statement

The 2024 paper from Shenyang Instrument Science Research Institute, published in Pressure Vessel, addresses the cladding of tube sheets with duplex stainless steel to improve corrosion resistance. This is a critical application in heat exchangers and pressure vessels, where the tube sheet is exposed to aggressive process fluids. The challenge is twofold: achieving the correct phase balance in the duplex stainless steel cladding layer, and managing the heat treatment requirements of the base material. The paper explores two approaches: cladding directly onto a weldable carbon steel or low alloy steel tube sheet, and cladding onto a tube sheet that requires post-weld heat treatment, in which case an austenitic stainless steel transition layer is used. The paper reports that both approaches can produce a cladding layer with more than 40% ferrite, which is the key to good corrosion resistance and mechanical properties.

Welding Metallurgy of Duplex Stainless Steel Cladding

Duplex stainless steel, typically UNS S32205 or S31803, has a microstructure of approximately 50% austenite and 50% ferrite. The ferrite content must be maintained within a specific range, typically 35 to 55%, to ensure good corrosion resistance and toughness. Too much ferrite leads to reduced toughness and susceptibility to sigma phase precipitation; too little ferrite reduces stress corrosion cracking resistance. The electroslag strip cladding process is well suited to duplex stainless steel because it produces a low dilution layer with a uniform composition. The paper emphasizes that the cladding layer cannot be subjected to conventional stress relief heat treatment at 600 to 900°C, because this temperature range promotes the formation of sigma phase and other intermetallic phases, which severely degrade the properties of the duplex stainless steel.

Parameter Direct Cladding (No Transition Layer) Cladding with Transition Layer
Base Material Weldable carbon steel or low alloy steel High hardenability steel requiring PWHT
Transition Layer Not required Austenitic stainless steel, e.g., 309L or 308L
Heat Treatment None, or low temperature only PWHT performed after transition layer, before duplex cladding
Ferrite Content 40 to 55% 40 to 55%
Corrosion Resistance Good Good, but transition layer adds a potential interface

Process Options, Heat Treatment, and Practical Lessons

The paper presents two process routes. The first route is direct cladding of duplex stainless steel onto a weldable base material, such as carbon steel or low alloy steel with good weldability. This is the simpler approach, but it requires that the base material does not require post-weld heat treatment. If the base material has high hardenability and requires PWHT, the second route is used: an austenitic stainless steel transition layer is deposited first, the PWHT is performed on the transition layer, and then the duplex stainless steel cladding is applied. This approach isolates the duplex layer from the PWHT, preventing sigma phase formation.

From my experience in pressure vessel fabrication, I would add several practical observations. First, the electroslag strip cladding process is sensitive to the strip width and the specific energy input. A wider strip, typically 60 to 100 mm, provides higher deposition rates but requires careful control of the slag pool depth and the welding current to ensure uniform fusion. Second, the ferrite content must be verified after cladding, using a ferrite scope or metallographic examination. A ferrite content below 35% indicates excessive dilution or incorrect alloy composition, while a content above 55% may indicate insufficient austenite formation. Third, the interface between the cladding and the base material must be inspected for lack of fusion, slag inclusions, or cracks. This is particularly important for the transition layer route, where the interface between the austenitic transition layer and the duplex cladding is a potential weak point. Fourth, the heat treatment of the transition layer must be performed before the duplex cladding is applied, and the temperature must be controlled to avoid sensitization of the austenitic stainless steel. In practice, a PWHT at 600 to 650°C is often used for low alloy steel, but this can cause chromium carbide precipitation in the austenitic transition layer. A stabilised grade, such as 347L, may be a better choice for the transition layer to avoid sensitization.

Test Results, Application, and Conclusions

The paper reports that both process routes produced cladding layers with ferrite content above 40% and good overall properties. The application example confirms that the process is viable for industrial tube sheets. From a practical standpoint, I would recommend that fabricators qualify both process routes before production, using a representative tube sheet mock-up. The qualification should include ferrite content measurement, metallographic examination, hardness testing, and corrosion testing, such as the ASTM G48 pitting test. The choice between the two routes depends on the base material and the heat treatment requirements. If the base material is weldable and does not require PWHT, direct cladding is simpler and more economical. If the base material requires PWHT, the transition layer route is necessary, but it adds complexity and cost. In either case, the ferrite content of the duplex cladding layer is the critical quality parameter, and it must be controlled through the selection of the filler metal, the welding parameters, and the heat input. This paper provides a solid foundation for fabricators who are considering duplex stainless steel cladding for tube sheets, and it highlights the importance of understanding the metallurgical constraints before committing to a process route.