ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

CCT Diagram and Transformation Structure and Properties of Surface Surfacing Metal

Literature Overview and Context

Wang Jianguo, Wang Gui, Liu Xiaogang, and Hou Chunqing from Baotou Iron and Steel College and Baotou Iron and Steel Group published this paper in Ordnance Material Science and Engineering (1999, Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 37–40). The paper uses a Japanese Formastor-Digital automatic phase transformation recorder to simulate surfacing thermal cycle conditions, measures the CCT (continuous cooling transformation) diagram of the surfacing metal, and studies the transformation structure and properties. The classification is TG455, and the keywords highlight the core topics — surfacing, CCT diagram, transformation structure, and surface surfacing.

This is a fundamental metallurgical study that has direct implications for the shop floor. The CCT diagram tells us how the surfacing metal transforms as it cools, and this determines the final microstructure and properties. For a veteran who has specified surfacing consumables and processes for everything from mill rolls to pressure vessel cladding, the CCT diagram is the roadmap that tells us what we are going to get.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

The paper's key findings are striking and have significant practical implications.

Finding Interpretation Practical Impact
Very high hardenability The surfacing metal transforms to hard, brittle phases even at moderate cooling rates Risk of cracking in the deposit
Very high hardness capability The as-deposited metal can reach very high hardness Good for wear resistance, but risk of brittle failure
A→P transformation strongly retarded Pearlite formation is suppressed The deposit will not soften through pearlite formation
A→B transformation significantly retarded Bainite formation is delayed The deposit will transform to martensite at relatively low cooling rates
Critical quenching cooling rate ≈ 300°C/min Below this rate, the transformation is incomplete Cooling rate must be controlled to achieve desired microstructure
Severe inhomogeneity in transformation Different regions of the deposit transform at different rates Non-uniform properties across the deposit

The critical quenching cooling rate of about 300°C/min is the most important number in the paper. It means that if the cooling rate is below this value, the austenite will not fully transform to martensite, and the deposit will contain retained austenite or other intermediate phases. Above this rate, the deposit will be fully martensitic, which is hard but potentially brittle.

The paper also notes that under surfacing thermal cycle conditions, the transformation is severely inhomogeneous. This is a practical concern. In a real surfacing operation, the cooling rate varies across the deposit — the surface cools faster than the interior, and the heat-affected zone cools at a different rate than the deposit. This inhomogeneity leads to non-uniform hardness and microstructure, which can cause localized wear or cracking in service.

Engineering Practice and Shop Floor Reflections

The CCT diagram is a tool that should be used on the shop floor, not just in the laboratory. When we specify a surfacing process, we need to know the cooling rate that the deposit will experience. This depends on the preheat temperature, the interlayer temperature, the base metal thickness, and the ambient conditions. If the cooling rate is too high, the deposit will be hard and brittle. If it is too low, the deposit will be soft and may not have the required wear resistance.

Let me give a practical example. In roll surfacing, we typically use a preheat of 200–300°C to prevent cracking. But preheating also slows the cooling rate. If the preheat is too high, the cooling rate may fall below the critical value, and the deposit will not reach the desired hardness. The paper's finding that the critical cooling rate is about 300°C/min tells us that we have a narrow process window. We need to balance preheat temperature, deposition rate, and interlayer temperature to keep the cooling rate in the right range.

The inhomogeneity issue is also a practical concern. In a multi-pass surfacing operation, the first pass cools faster than the last pass, because the base metal is cold and acts as a heat sink. This means the first pass may be harder than the last pass. If the deposit is used in a wear application, the uneven hardness will cause uneven wear, which can lead to premature failure.

The paper's emphasis on the high hardenability and hardness capability of the surfacing metal is a warning. High hardness is desirable for wear resistance, but it comes with a risk of cracking. The deposit must be able to accommodate the residual stresses that develop during cooling. If the deposit is too hard and too brittle, it will crack. This is a classic trade-off that every surfacing engineer has to manage.

Study Insights and Implications

The CCT diagram is a fundamental tool that should be part of every surfacing consumable qualification. It tells us the process window for achieving the desired microstructure and properties. The paper's finding that the critical cooling rate is about 300°C/min is a specific number that can be used to set process parameters.

For a shop floor engineer, the practical implication is that cooling rate control is not optional. It is a process parameter that must be monitored and controlled. This means using preheat, interlayer temperature control, and post-weld cooling management. It also means that the surfacing process must be designed with the CCT diagram in mind, not just the chemical composition of the consumable.

The inhomogeneity issue is a reminder that a surfacing deposit is not a homogeneous material. It is a composite of multiple passes, each with its own thermal history. The properties of the deposit are the average of the properties of individual passes, but the average can be misleading. A deposit with an average hardness of 50 HRC may have passes ranging from 40 to 60 HRC, and the soft passes will wear first.

Conclusion

This paper is a classic metallurgical study that has enduring practical value. The CCT diagram is a fundamental tool for understanding how surfacing metal transforms during cooling, and the paper provides specific data — a critical cooling rate of about 300°C/min — that can be used to set process parameters. The finding that the transformation is inhomogeneous under surfacing conditions is a warning that the deposit properties are not uniform, and this must be accounted for in design and application. For a veteran who has spent decades specifying surfacing processes, this paper is a reminder that the CCT diagram is not just an academic exercise. It is the roadmap that tells us what we are going to get, and if we ignore it, we will get surprises. The key takeaway is simple: know the CCT diagram of your surfacing metal, control your cooling rate, and expect inhomogeneity. If you do that, you will get a deposit that performs as designed.