ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

CCT Diagram of Surface Cladding Metal: Transformation Behaviour and Practical Implications

Literature Overview

This 1999 study by Wang Jianguo and colleagues at Baotou Iron and Steel College and Baotou Iron and Steel Group is one of the more useful pieces of work I have seen on the continuous cooling transformation behaviour of hardfacing deposits. The team used a Japanese Formastor-Digital automatic phase transformation recorder to simulate the thermal cycles experienced during surface cladding, then determined the CCT diagram for the deposited metal and studied the resulting transformation microstructures and mechanical properties. The work was supported by a key project from Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, which tells you it was aimed at real industrial applications, not just academic curiosity.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

The most striking finding is that the cladding metal exhibits exceptionally high hardenability and hardening capacity. The austenite-to-pearlite transformation is strongly suppressed and essentially does not occur under the tested conditions, while the austenite-to-bainite transformation is significantly delayed. The critical quenching cooling rate is approximately 300 degrees Celsius per minute. This is a critical number for anyone who specifies or performs post-cladding heat treatment.

The study also reveals serious transformation inhomogeneity under cladding thermal cycle conditions. When the cooling rate is slightly slower, the transformation behaviour becomes uneven across the deposit, which directly affects the uniformity of hardness and wear resistance in the final component.

Parameter Value Practical Significance
Critical quenching cooling rate ~300 degrees C/min Below this rate, soft transformation products form
Austenite to pearlite transformation Strongly suppressed Practically absent in cladding conditions
Austenite to bainite transformation Significantly delayed Requires careful cooling control
Transformation uniformity Poor at slower cooling rates Causes hardness scatter in service

Integration with Engineering Practice

This is where the paper earns its keep. In my years running hardfacing lines for mill rolls, valve seats and crusher components, the CCT diagram is the single most useful tool for avoiding two failure modes: soft zones and hydrogen-induced cracking. If you cool too slowly, you get bainite or even pearlite in the deposit, and the component fails by premature wear. If you cool too fast, you get untempered martensite with high residual stress, and the component cracks in service or during machining.

I have seen a hardfaced continuous caster roll fail after only three weeks in service because the shop ignored the CCT curve and allowed the roll to cool in still air after cladding. The deposit showed hardness scatter from 38 HRC to 55 HRC across the same surface. That is exactly the transformation inhomogeneity this paper describes.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not address the effect of multiple passes on the CCT behaviour. In real cladding, you are always building up multiple layers, and each subsequent pass reheats the previous deposit, partially tempering it. The CCT diagram for a single thermal cycle is a starting point, but the real transformation path is far more complex.

Another point worth raising is the interaction between dilution and hardenability. The cladding metal in this study was deposited on a carbon steel substrate, and some dilution of the deposit by the base metal is inevitable. Dilution changes the alloy content of the deposit, which shifts the CCT curve. This is a practical concern that the paper does not fully explore.

Study Insights and Implications

The practical takeaway from this work is that cladding process control must be treated as a heat treatment operation, not just a deposition operation. The cooling rate after deposition is as important as the welding parameters themselves. For thick deposits, controlled cooling with insulation blankets or even forced air cooling may be necessary to stay within the safe transformation window.

The critical cooling rate of 300 degrees Celsius per minute also sets a practical limit on preheat and interpass temperature. If you preheat too high, you slow the cooling rate below the critical value, and you risk soft transformation products. If you preheat too low, you risk cold cracking in the HAZ. The window is narrow, and it demands disciplined process control.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study remains a useful reference for anyone who specifies hardfacing consumables and needs to understand the transformation behaviour of the deposit. The methodology using a Formastor-Digital recorder to simulate cladding thermal cycles is sound and has been widely adopted in subsequent research. For the industry, the key lesson is that the CCT diagram is not just a laboratory curiosity; it is a practical tool for process design, and ignoring it leads to field failures that are expensive and embarrassing.