ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Wear-Resistant Surfacing for Coal Gangue Moulded Boards

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Ying Pengzhan, Ge Changlu and Liu Fabin from China University of Mining and Technology addresses a very specific industrial problem: the wear of coal gangue moulded boards in brick making machines. Coal gangue is the waste rock from coal mining, and it is used as a raw material for brick production. The moulded boards are the components that form the brick shape, and they are subjected to severe abrasive wear from the coal gangue slurry.

The paper describes the development of a wear-resistant surfacing electrode and the welding procedure for applying it to the moulded boards. The authors analysed the working conditions and wear characteristics of the boards, selected an appropriate hardfacing alloy, developed the welding procedure, and then validated the performance through hardness testing, wear testing and industrial trial.

The industrial trial results are the most striking part of the paper. The average service life of the surfacing boards was increased by a factor of 13.37 compared to the un-surfaced boards. This is a dramatic improvement, and it demonstrates the value of a systematic approach to wear problem solving. The improvement was not achieved by a single change. It was achieved by the combination of the correct alloy, the correct welding procedure and the correct application technique.

2. Technical Parameter Analysis

Parameter Value / Description Practical Significance
Substrate material Coal gangue moulded board High abrasive wear from coal gangue slurry
Surfacing alloy Wear-resistant hardfacing electrode Designed for abrasive wear resistance
Hardness of deposit Not specified in abstract, but likely HRC 50-60 Sufficient for abrasive wear resistance
Service life improvement 13.37 times Dramatic improvement over un-surfaced boards
Application method Manual shielded metal arc welding Suitable for on-site repair and maintenance

The 13.37 times improvement is a number that deserves attention. It is not a laboratory result. It is an industrial result, achieved in actual production conditions. This means that the surfacing process was not just technically successful. It was economically successful. The cost of the surfacing operation was recovered many times over by the extended service life of the boards.

The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the wear mechanism before selecting the surfacing alloy. The authors did not simply choose the hardest alloy available. They analysed the wear characteristics of the boards and selected an alloy that matched the wear mechanism. This is the correct approach, and it is the approach that should be used in any wear problem.

3. Integration with Engineering Practice

This paper is a textbook example of how to solve a wear problem in an industrial setting. The process is straightforward: analyse the wear mechanism, select the alloy, develop the welding procedure, validate in the laboratory, and then prove it in production. The 13.37 times improvement is the reward for following this process.

The practical challenge is the welding procedure. Coal gangue moulded boards are likely to be made of a low-alloy steel or a cast iron, and the welding of these materials requires care. The surfacing electrode must be compatible with the substrate, and the welding parameters must be selected to minimise the risk of cracking. The paper does not provide the detailed welding parameters, but the industrial success suggests that the procedure was well developed.

The economic case is compelling. If a moulded board costs a certain amount and lasts a certain time, and if the surfacing operation costs a fraction of the board cost and extends the life by 13 times, the return on investment is enormous. This is the kind of calculation that convinces a plant manager to invest in hardfacing.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not discuss the wear mechanism in detail. The abstract mentions that the authors analysed the wear characteristics, but it does not describe the mechanism. This is a limitation. A more detailed understanding of the wear mechanism would allow the alloy to be optimised further.

The paper also does not discuss the effect of the coal gangue composition. Coal gangue varies significantly depending on the coal seam and the mining method. A surfacing alloy that works well for one type of coal gangue may not work as well for another. The industrial trial was conducted with a specific coal gangue, and the results may not be transferable to other sources.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of the value of a systematic approach to wear problems. The authors did not guess. They analysed, selected, developed, validated and proved. The 13.37 times improvement is the result of this process, and it is a number that should be quoted whenever someone questions the value of hardfacing.

For a production engineer, the lesson is to always start with the wear mechanism. Do not select an alloy based on hardness alone. Analyse the wear mechanism, understand the service conditions, and then select the alloy that matches. The hardness is important, but it is not the only factor. The alloy must also have the right toughness, the right corrosion resistance and the right weldability.

The economic case is also important. Hardfacing is not just a repair technique. It is a way to extend the service life of components and reduce the total cost of ownership. The 13.37 times improvement in this paper is a dramatic example, but even a two or three times improvement is often enough to justify the cost of hardfacing.