ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Defect Analysis and Countermeasures for NCu30 Surfacing on 16MnII Base Metal

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Zhang Juli, Fu Lin, Wang Lijun, Zhang Juan, Li Yanan and Zhao Xiuli from Xi'an Aerospace Huawel Chemical and Biological Engineering Co., Ltd. and the National Key Laboratory of Nickel-Cobalt Co-associated Resource Development and Comprehensive Utilisation addresses a specific and recurring problem: porosity and cracking in NCu30 (nickel-copper alloy) surfacing on a 16MnII low-alloy steel base metal. The paper is dated 2025, which means it reflects current practice and current understanding of the problem.

The paper identifies two primary defects: porosity and cracking. The porosity is caused by hydrogen, which cannot escape from the molten pool because the cooling rate is too fast. The cracking is caused by the combination of high thermal expansion coefficient, high thermal conductivity and the inherent susceptibility of the nickel-copper alloy to hot cracking. The paper proposes a specific solution: use ENi-1 electrode as a transition layer between the 16MnII base metal and the NCu30 surfacing layer.

The key technical insight is that the copper content of the NCu30 alloy is the root cause of the problem. Copper has high thermal conductivity, high thermal expansion coefficient and high electrical resistivity. These properties combine to produce a fast cooling rate in the molten pool, which prevents hydrogen from escaping and causes porosity. The copper also promotes hot cracking because of its low melting point and its tendency to form low-melting-point eutectics with other elements.

2. Technical Parameter Analysis

Parameter Value / Requirement Practical Significance
Base metal 16MnII low-alloy steel Standard pressure vessel steel
Surfacing alloy NCu30 (Ni-Cu alloy) Corrosion-resistant alloy for chemical service
Transition layer ENi-1 electrode Prevents copper contamination of the base metal
Preheat temperature Required to prevent porosity Reduces cooling rate and allows hydrogen to escape
Interpass temperature 60-100°C Must be controlled to balance cooling rate and hydrogen escape
Welding environment Clean and protected Prevents contamination of the molten pool
Welding energy input Low heat input Reduces thermal stress and hot cracking risk

The interpass temperature requirement of 60-100°C is the most interesting parameter. It is a narrow window, and it reflects the fundamental tension in welding this material. The temperature must be high enough to allow hydrogen to escape from the molten pool, but low enough to prevent excessive thermal stress and hot cracking. The paper notes that copper has a high thermal conductivity, which means the temperature drops quickly, and the welding operator must maintain the temperature within the specified range.

The use of ENi-1 as a transition layer is a standard practice for dissimilar metal welding, but the paper explains the reasoning clearly. The ENi-1 electrode does not contain copper, so it does not have the same thermal properties as the NCu30 alloy. It provides a buffer layer that reduces the thermal gradient between the base metal and the surfacing layer, and it prevents the copper from diffusing into the base metal.

3. Integration with Engineering Practice

This paper addresses a problem that I have seen many times in the fabrication of chemical equipment. Nickel-copper alloys are used for their corrosion resistance, but they are notoriously difficult to weld. The porosity problem is particularly common, and it is often blamed on the welding operator. This paper shows that the problem is not the operator. It is the material.

The practical solution is to control the interpass temperature within the specified range. This is easier said than done. The welding operator must measure the temperature between passes, and if the temperature drops below 60°C, the component must be reheated. This adds time to the welding operation, but it is essential for producing a sound weld.

The paper also emphasises the importance of a clean welding environment. Nickel-copper alloys are sensitive to contamination, and any oil, grease or moisture on the surface can cause porosity. The welding area must be clean, and the shielding gas must be of high purity. This is a basic requirement, but it is often overlooked in production.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not discuss the effect of welding process. The NCu30 alloy can be welded by gas tungsten arc welding, gas metal arc welding or shielded metal arc welding, and each process has different characteristics. The paper appears to focus on shielded metal arc welding with ENi-1 and ENCu-7 electrodes, but the welding process should be selected based on the specific application.

The paper also does not discuss the effect of joint design. The surfacing operation is typically performed on a flat surface, but the joint design can affect the cooling rate and the hydrogen escape. A thick deposit may require multiple passes, and the interpass temperature control becomes more critical as the deposit thickness increases.

5. Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of how a materials science understanding can solve a practical welding problem. The authors did not simply recommend a preheat. They explained why the preheat is necessary, and they identified the specific material properties that cause the problem. This is the kind of understanding that separates a good welding engineer from a mediocre one.

The practical lesson is that the interpass temperature is not a suggestion. It is a requirement. If the temperature is outside the specified range, the weld will be defective. The welding operator must be trained to measure the temperature and to maintain it within the range. This is a basic quality control requirement, and it should be part of the welding procedure specification.

For a production engineer, the key takeaway is to always understand the material before developing the welding procedure. The NCu30 alloy is not difficult to weld because of the operator. It is difficult to weld because of the material properties. The solution is to control the thermal cycle, and that requires a thorough understanding of the thermal properties of the alloy.