ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Fe-Cr-C Wear-Resistant Hardfacing Alloy Abrasive Wear Behavior

Introduction and Literature Context

This study by Wang Zhihui et al. from Beijing University of Technology investigates the abrasive wear mechanism of Fe-Cr-C hardfacing alloys deposited by submerged arc welding on Q235 steel. The authors used a MLS-225 wet rubber wheel abrasive wear tester with quartz sand as the abrasive medium, and analyzed the worn surfaces using scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive spectroscopy. The key finding is that under the wet quartz sand abrasive conditions, the dominant wear mechanism is spalling caused by microcracks, with a secondary contribution from micro-cutting caused by plowing or plowing-induced wrinkling. The energy dispersive spectroscopy analysis shows that the Cr content in the spalling pits corresponds to the (Cr,Fe)7C3 carbide composition range, indicating that the spalling is caused by carbide fracture.

Wear Mechanism Analysis

This paper addresses a question that has significant practical implications: what actually causes material loss in abrasive wear? The conventional wisdom has been that abrasive wear is primarily caused by cutting or plowing, where the abrasive particles cut grooves into the surface and remove material as chips. However, this study shows that in Fe-Cr-C hardfacing alloys, the dominant mechanism is spalling, where microcracks initiate in the carbides and propagate to the surface, causing large chunks of material to break away.

The fact that the spalling pits have a Cr content corresponding to (Cr,Fe)7C3 is a critical observation. It means that the carbides are not simply being worn away by abrasion, but are actually fracturing under the cyclic loading of the abrasive particles. This is a fatigue-like mechanism, where the repeated impact of the abrasive particles creates microcracks in the brittle carbides, which then propagate and cause the carbide to fracture and fall out.

Practical Implications for Hardfacing Alloy Design

This finding has direct implications for how we design hardfacing alloys for abrasive wear applications. If the wear mechanism is dominated by carbide fracture, then the key design parameter is not simply the hardness or the volume fraction of carbides, but the fracture toughness of the carbides and the strength of the matrix-carbide interface.

In my experience, the following design principles are critical:

  1. The carbide size should be controlled to avoid large, blocky carbides that are more susceptible to fracture.
  2. The matrix should have sufficient toughness to absorb the impact energy and prevent crack propagation.
  3. The carbide-matrix interface should be strong enough to prevent the carbides from being plucked out.
  4. The carbide morphology should be oriented to resist the direction of the abrasive flow.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

The spalling mechanism described in this paper is a common cause of premature failure in hardfaced components. I have seen this in pipe mill rolls, where the hardfacing layer appears to be worn evenly, but on closer inspection, there are large spalling pits that are not visible to the naked eye. These pits can grow and cause catastrophic failure of the roll.

The countermeasures for spalling are:

  1. Reduce the carbide size by controlling the cooling rate and the alloy composition.
  2. Add elements such as vanadium or niobium to refine the carbide structure.
  3. Use a multi-layer deposit to ensure a uniform carbide distribution in the working surface.
  4. Avoid excessive heat input, which can cause carbide coarsening.
  5. Use a post-weld heat treatment to reduce residual stresses.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not address the effect of the abrasive particle size on the wear mechanism. In practice, the abrasive particle size has a significant effect on the wear rate and the wear mechanism. Larger particles tend to cause more cutting and less spalling, while smaller particles tend to cause more spalling and less cutting. This should be investigated to understand the behavior of the alloy in different service conditions.

Another question is the effect of the hardfacing layer thickness on the wear mechanism. In practice, a thicker layer provides more wear allowance, but the residual stresses increase with thickness, which may promote spalling. The optimal thickness depends on the specific application and the expected wear rate.

Summary and Engineering Takeaway

This paper provides a valuable insight into the wear mechanism of Fe-Cr-C hardfacing alloys. The finding that spalling caused by carbide fracture is the dominant wear mechanism under wet abrasive conditions challenges the conventional wisdom that abrasive wear is primarily caused by cutting. For practical applications, this means that the design of hardfacing alloys should focus on the fracture toughness of the carbides and the strength of the matrix-carbide interface, rather than simply maximizing hardness. I would recommend conducting a wear test under actual service conditions before selecting a hardfacing alloy, because the wear mechanism can change significantly with the abrasive type, particle size, and impact energy.