ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Rapid Laser Cladding of Ni/Stainless Steel on CT90 Coiled Tubing: Microstructure, Corrosion Resistance, and Practical Implications for Oilfield Service

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Dong Hui and colleagues from Xi'an Shiyou University and CNPC Tubular Goods Research Institute addresses a critical problem in the oil and gas industry: the corrosion of CT90 coiled tubing in service. The authors employed rapid laser cladding to deposit a Ni/316L stainless steel coating on the surface of CT90 coiled tubing, with the dual objectives of improving corrosion resistance and increasing the cladding efficiency. The key findings are that a single laser scan produced a coating approximately 200 μm thick, consisting of a 50 μm diffusion zone and a 150 μm coating zone. The coating was highly dense, with porosity of only about 0.4% and dilution of about 1.7%. The coating grains grew predominantly as columnar crystals perpendicular to the coating/substrate interface, with some equiaxed and plate-like grains at the surface. The chromium content at the grain boundaries was approximately 1.2% lower than in the grain interiors. Electrochemical testing showed that the coated CT90 tubing had a corrosion potential approximately 0.55 V higher, a corrosion current density approximately 95% lower, and a pitting potential of approximately 0.34 V compared to the uncoated substrate.

Technical Interpretation of Coating Characteristics

Coating Thickness and Dilution Control

The 200 μm coating thickness achieved in a single pass is a remarkable result, and it demonstrates the potential of rapid laser cladding to improve productivity while maintaining quality. The 50 μm diffusion zone is particularly important because it represents the metallurgical bond between the coating and the substrate. A diffusion zone that is too thin may indicate poor bonding, while a diffusion zone that is too thick may indicate excessive dilution. The 1.7% dilution rate is excellent for a laser cladding process, and it ensures that the coating chemistry is close to the nominal composition of the Ni/316L alloy.

Microstructural Development and Chromium Segregation

The columnar grain growth perpendicular to the coating/substrate interface is a characteristic feature of laser cladding, where the solidification front advances from the substrate toward the surface. The columnar grains provide a path for heat conduction away from the surface, which helps to maintain a stable solidification front. The chromium segregation at the grain boundaries, with a reduction of about 1.2% compared to the grain interiors, is a potential concern for corrosion resistance. Chromium is the primary element responsible for the passivation of stainless steel, and a reduction in chromium content at the grain boundaries can lead to sensitisation and intergranular corrosion in aggressive environments.

Porosity and Defect Control

The porosity of approximately 0.4% is very low for a laser cladding process, and it demonstrates the effectiveness of the rapid laser cladding technique in producing a dense coating. Porosity in laser cladding is typically caused by gas entrapment, which can result from inadequate shielding gas coverage, contamination of the substrate or the powder, or instabilities in the melt pool. The low porosity achieved in this study suggests that the process parameters were well controlled and that the shielding gas environment was adequate.

Comparative Analysis of Corrosion Performance

Parameter Uncoated CT90 Coated CT90 (Ni/316L) Improvement
Corrosion potential Baseline +0.55 V Significant increase (more noble)
Corrosion current density Baseline -95% Dramatic reduction
Pitting potential Not reported 0.34 V Positive (indicates pitting resistance)
Corrosion morphology Severe general corrosion Minimal localised corrosion (honeycomb pattern) Improved resistance
Coating porosity N/A 0.4% Low (good density)
Dilution rate N/A 1.7% Low (good chemistry retention)

Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

The Challenge of Coiled Tubing Corrosion

Coiled tubing is used extensively in oil and gas well intervention operations, where it is subjected to a wide range of corrosive environments, including produced water, acid stimulation fluids, and sour gas. The corrosion of coiled tubing is a major operational and safety concern, as it can lead to premature failure and costly workover operations. The use of a corrosion-resistant coating is a logical solution, but the coating must be able to withstand the mechanical stresses associated with coiling and uncoiling operations, as well as the thermal and chemical environment of the wellbore.

The Importance of Coating Adhesion and Flexibility

One of the key challenges in coating coiled tubing is the requirement for the coating to remain intact during the repeated bending and straightening cycles that occur during deployment and retrieval. The Ni/316L coating described in this study has a thickness of 200 μm, which is relatively thin and should be able to accommodate the bending strains without cracking or delamination. However, the coating must have good adhesion to the substrate, which is provided by the 50 μm diffusion zone. The diffusion zone represents a gradual transition from the substrate to the coating, which helps to distribute the interfacial stresses and prevent delamination.

A Real-World Case: Coiled Tubing Failure Analysis

I recall a failure analysis of a coiled tubing string that had failed during a well intervention operation. The failure was attributed to pitting corrosion on the internal surface of the tubing, which had been caused by the presence of carbon dioxide and hydrogen sulfide in the produced fluid. The pitting had initiated at inclusions and surface defects, and it had propagated through the wall thickness, ultimately leading to a rupture. The failure analysis highlighted the importance of surface quality and the need for a corrosion-resistant coating or cladding to protect the tubing from the aggressive wellbore environment.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises several important questions that are not fully addressed in the abstract. First, what is the effect of the coating on the mechanical properties of the coiled tubing? The coating adds a layer of Ni/316L stainless steel, which has different mechanical properties than the CT90 substrate. The effect of the coating on the fatigue life, the yield strength, and the burst pressure of the tubing must be evaluated. Second, what is the effect of the coating on the coiling and uncoiling operations? The coating must be able to withstand the bending strains without cracking or delamination. Third, what is the long-term corrosion performance of the coating in the actual wellbore environment? The electrochemical testing provides a good indication of the corrosion resistance, but it does not fully simulate the complex environment of a real wellbore.

Study Insights and Implications for the Industry

This study provides valuable insight into the use of rapid laser cladding to improve the corrosion resistance of CT90 coiled tubing. The key takeaway for the practicing engineer is that rapid laser cladding can produce a dense, low-dilution coating with excellent corrosion resistance, and it can do so at a high production rate. The technology has significant potential for the protection of coiled tubing and other oilfield tubulars, but it requires careful process control to achieve the desired coating quality.

The study also highlights the importance of considering the entire lifecycle of the component when evaluating the benefits of a coating. The initial cost of the coating must be weighed against the cost of premature failure, the cost of workover operations, and the cost of lost production. In many cases, the coating will be economically justified even if the initial cost is significant, because the cost of failure is even more significant.

Concluding Remarks

This study is a valuable contribution to the field of corrosion protection for oilfield tubulars. It demonstrates that rapid laser cladding can produce a high-quality Ni/316L coating on CT90 coiled tubing, with excellent corrosion resistance and low porosity. The technology has significant potential for the protection of coiled tubing and other oilfield tubulars, and it represents a major step forward in the effort to extend the service life of these critical components. For the practicing engineer, the key takeaway is that rapid laser cladding is a viable and effective method for protecting coiled tubing from corrosion, but it requires careful process control and a thorough understanding of the coating's microstructure and properties. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the specification of corrosion protection for oilfield tubulars, and I would encourage them to consider rapid laser cladding as a viable alternative to traditional coating methods.