ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Computer Simulation of Residual Stress Field in Cladding Metal: Validation and Size Effects

Literature Overview

This 2001 paper from Yanshan University, supported by the Doctoral Program Fund of the Ministry of Education and the State Key Laboratory of Advanced Welding Production Technology, addresses a problem that has caused more field failures than almost any other in hardfacing: residual stress. The team used 60CrMnMo steel as the substrate material and measured the residual stress field using an AST-type X-ray stress analyser. They then used ANSYS finite element software to simulate the temperature field and residual stress field during cladding, taking into account martensitic transformation, Young's modulus and other parameters.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

The experimental measurements revealed two residual tensile stress peaks: one at the centre of the cladding metal and one in the heat-affected zone near the fusion line. This is a classic distribution for hardfacing deposits, and it explains why cracks often initiate in these two locations.

The finite element model, which incorporated martensitic transformation and temperature-dependent material properties, produced residual stress values that agreed well with the measured values. This validation is important because it demonstrates that the model is physically sound and can be used for predictive purposes.

The model was then used to simulate the effect of specimen size on the residual stress distribution. The results show that as specimen size increases, the residual stress peak increases, and the position of the peak shifts. This is a significant finding because it means that laboratory-scale specimens may not be representative of full-scale components.

Location Residual Stress Type Practical Consequence
Cladding metal centre Tensile peak Cracks initiate here in service
HAZ near fusion line Tensile peak Cracks initiate here in service
Specimen size increase Higher peak stress Lab results not scalable to full size

Integration with Engineering Practice

This paper is a reminder that residual stress is not just a theoretical concern; it is a practical problem that causes real failures. I have seen hardfaced rolls crack during machining because the residual stress was not relieved before the machining operation. I have seen hardfaced valve seats crack in service because the residual stress combined with the service stress exceeded the yield strength of the deposit.

The finding that residual stress increases with specimen size is particularly important for large components. A hardfaced mill roll or a large valve body will have higher residual stress than a small test coupon, even if the cladding process is identical. This means that the process qualification on a small coupon may not guarantee the performance of the full-size component.

The two-peak distribution is also a useful diagnostic. If a hardfaced component fails by cracking, the location of the crack tells you whether the failure was driven by residual stress in the deposit or by residual stress in the HAZ. This information is valuable for root cause analysis.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not address the effect of post-cladding heat treatment on the residual stress distribution. Stress relief heat treatment is the most common method for reducing residual stress, but it also affects the microstructure and the mechanical properties of the deposit. The optimal stress relief temperature is a balance between stress reduction and property retention, and it is not always straightforward.

Another question is the effect of multiple-pass cladding on the residual stress distribution. Each subsequent pass reheats the previous deposit and partially relieves the residual stress, but it also introduces new residual stress. The final distribution is the result of a complex thermal history, and it is not simply the sum of the individual passes.

Study Insights and Implications

The key insight from this work is that residual stress simulation, when properly validated, is a powerful tool for process design and failure analysis. The model can be used to predict the residual stress distribution for different cladding parameters, substrate geometries and material combinations, which reduces the need for expensive trial-and-error experiments.

The size effect is a critical practical consideration. It means that process qualification must be performed on representative geometry, not just on small coupons. This is a lesson that is often ignored in the industry, and it leads to field failures that could have been prevented.

Reference Value and Outlook

This study remains a valuable reference for anyone who needs to understand and manage residual stress in hardfacing deposits. The validation of the finite element model against experimental measurements provides confidence in the predictive capability, and the size effect findings are directly relevant to real components. For the industry, the key takeaway is that residual stress is a design parameter, not an afterthought, and it must be managed throughout the cladding process, from preheat to post-weld heat treatment.