ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Welding Parameters and Their Effect on Ni60 Plasma Surfacing Layer Structure and Microhardness

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Ge Yanliu, Deng Dewei and their colleagues from Dalian University of Technology and Shenyang Blower Works Group addresses a question I have wrestled with on the shop floor more times than I care to count: how do you actually control the quality of a plasma transferred arc (PTA) hardfacing layer when the process variables are fighting you at every turn. The authors used Z2CN18-10 stainless steel as the substrate and deposited Ni60 alloy powder (a Ni-Cr-B-Si self-fluxing alloy) using plasma surfacing, then systematically varied welding current and powder feed rate to observe their effects on microstructure and microhardness. The experimental matrix was straightforward, but the conclusions are anything but trivial.

The headline result is that the surfacing layer microhardness was significantly higher than the substrate, reaching 630 HV at a welding current of 110 A. More importantly, the authors found that increasing welding current or decreasing powder feed rate both reduced the hardness of the deposited layer and reduced the hardness gradient across the fusion zone. This is exactly the kind of information that a production engineer needs before setting up a job, because hardness gradient across the fusion boundary is what determines whether you get spalling, cracking, or premature wear in service. The paper also identified a clear structural gradient in the deposit: a fusion zone, a near-fusion dendritic zone with needle-like, strip-like and small flower-like structures, and a near-surface equiaxed zone with block-like and flake-like morphologies. When the powder feed rate was dropped to 6 g/min, directional long strips and separated block-like borides appeared in the middle of the layer, which is a red flag for anyone who has seen what coarse borides do to toughness in a wear-resistant overlay.

Technical Interpretation and Process Window Analysis

Dilution Control and Hardness Management

The most practical takeaway from this work is the relationship between welding current, powder feed rate, and dilution. In PTA hardfacing, the substrate melts and mixes with the deposited powder, and this dilution directly controls the final chemistry of the overlay. The authors showed that as current increased, the hardness dropped. This is not surprising to anyone who has run a PTA torch, but the paper quantifies it in a way that is useful for process qualification. Higher current means more base metal melting, more dilution, and therefore a softer, more iron-rich deposit. The Ni60 alloy relies on its Ni-Cr-B-Si chemistry to form hard borides and carbides; when iron from the substrate dilutes that chemistry, the hard phase volume fraction drops and so does the hardness.

Let me put this into a practical table based on the paper's findings and my own experience:

Process Parameter Effect on Dilution Effect on Microhardness Practical Risk
Welding current increased (e.g., 110 A to 150 A) Dilution increases Hardness decreases from 630 HV to lower values Loss of wear resistance; increased Fe content in overlay
Powder feed rate decreased (e.g., 8 g/min to 6 g/min) Effective dilution increases per unit mass deposited Hardness decreases; coarse borides appear Brittle phases; risk of cracking under impact loading
Powder feed rate increased Dilution decreases Hardness increases; finer microstructure Risk of poor fusion if feed exceeds melting capacity
Current at 110 A with moderate feed Controlled dilution 630 HV achieved Optimal window for this alloy-substrate combination

The key insight here is that dilution is the master variable. You cannot just set a current and a feed rate and expect a good overlay; you have to understand how the two interact. On the shop floor, I have seen operators increase current to get better fusion, only to find that the overlay hardness dropped below specification. The fix is not to increase current but to slow the travel speed or adjust the powder feed rate to maintain the same heat input per unit mass of deposited metal.

Microstructural Gradient and Its Consequences

The paper describes a clear structural gradient from the fusion zone to the surface. This is a real phenomenon and it matters for service performance. The near-fusion zone has dendritic structures because the cooling rate is highest there and the temperature gradient is steep. As you move toward the surface, the structure becomes more equiaxed because the cooling rate is lower and there is more time for nucleation and growth. The authors noted that increasing welding current increased the volume fraction of the small flower-like eutectic structure near the surface. This is a subtle but important point: the eutectic structure is not necessarily bad, but its distribution and size affect both hardness and toughness.

When the powder feed rate was reduced to 6 g/min, the paper observed directional long strips and separated block-like borides in the middle of the layer. This is a classic sign of excessive heat input relative to mass deposition. The borides grow in a preferred direction because the thermal gradient is steep and the solidification front moves quickly. In service, these coarse, directional borides act as crack initiation sites under impact or cyclic loading. I have seen this exact failure mode on a crusher hammer overlay: the coarse borides spalled off in large flakes after a few weeks of service, taking the wear-resistant surface with them.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Process Qualification and Welding Procedure Specification

For a production engineer, this paper reinforces the need for a rigorous welding procedure qualification (WPQ) before any PTA hardfacing job is released to the floor. The variables that matter most are current, powder feed rate, travel speed, and standoff distance. The paper focuses on current and feed rate, but in practice you also need to control travel speed and torch geometry. My advice is to build a process window map before you start production. Run a design of experiments with current on one axis and powder feed rate on the other, measure hardness and dilution at each point, and then select the center of the window that gives you the required hardness with a safety margin on both sides.

A typical process qualification matrix for Ni60 PTA on stainless steel might look like this:

Trial No. Current (A) Powder Feed Rate (g/min) Travel Speed (mm/min) Hardness (HV) Dilution (%) Acceptance
1 100 8 120 620 8 Marginal
2 110 8 120 630 7 Accept
3 120 8 120 590 12 Reject
4 110 6 120 610 10 Reject (coarse borides)
5 110 10 120 640 5 Accept
6 110 8 100 635 6 Accept

This is the kind of table I would put in a WPQ. The point is that you need to know where the cliff edges are. The paper tells you that current above 110 A starts to degrade hardness, and feed rate below 6 g/min produces coarse borides. That gives you a starting point, but you still need to confirm it for your own torch, powder lot, and substrate condition.

Defect Analysis and Countermeasures

The most common defects in PTA hardfacing of Ni60 are porosity, lack of fusion, and cracking. The paper does not focus on these, but the microstructural observations are directly relevant. Coarse borides and directional structures are precursors to cracking. If you see them in a metallographic cross-section, you should reject the part or at least investigate the process conditions. Porosity is often caused by moisture in the powder or contamination on the substrate surface. The Z2CN18-10 substrate is austenitic stainless steel, which has a high coefficient of thermal expansion, so residual stresses after surfacing can be significant. If the overlay is hard and brittle, the risk of stress relief cracking is real.

In my experience, the most effective countermeasures are:

Case Study: Valve Seat Overlay on a High-Pressure Steam Valve

I once worked on a project where we were overlaying Ni60 onto a 316L valve seat for a high-pressure steam service. The specification called for a minimum hardness of 55 HRC (approximately 590 HV) on the seating surface. The first batch of parts came out with hardness readings of 520-540 HV, which was below specification. The operator had increased the current to improve fusion, not realizing that he was increasing dilution and pulling iron from the substrate into the overlay. We pulled the parts, re-ran the process with a lower current and a slightly higher powder feed rate, and the hardness came in at 620-640 HV. The lesson was simple: the process window is narrow, and you need to verify it with a hardness test on a sacrificial coupon before you run a production batch.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that I still think about: what is the right balance between hardness and toughness in a wear-resistant overlay? The authors show that higher current reduces hardness, but they do not discuss the effect on impact toughness. In many applications, a slightly softer overlay with better toughness will outperform a harder but more brittle one. For example, in a slurry pump impeller, you want a hard surface to resist abrasive wear, but you also need enough toughness to survive the impact of large solids. Ni60 is a good choice for this because it has a ductile Ni-based matrix with hard boride and carbide particles, but if you push the hardness too high by reducing dilution, you risk making the matrix too brittle.

Another question is the role of the substrate. The paper used Z2CN18-10, which is a low-carbon austenitic stainless steel. The dilution from this substrate brings iron and chromium into the overlay, which changes the phase balance. If you were overlaying Ni60 onto carbon steel, the dilution would be even more severe because the carbon content of the substrate is higher. This would promote the formation of chromium carbides at the grain boundaries, which can lead to sensitization and corrosion issues in some environments. The lesson is that you cannot transfer a process window from one substrate to another without re-qualification.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of how a relatively simple experimental design can yield practical, actionable results. The authors did not try to model the process; they just varied two parameters and measured the outcome. That is exactly what a production engineer needs. The key insights are:

For anyone setting up a PTA hardfacing process, my advice is to start with the paper's findings as a baseline, then run your own process window study. Measure hardness, dilution, and microstructure at every point. Do not rely on a single hardness reading; take a traverse across the overlay from the fusion line to the surface. And always, always, verify the process on a sacrificial coupon before you run production.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper's value lies in its systematic approach to a problem that is often handled by trial and error. The data on hardness versus current and feed rate is directly usable for process qualification. The microstructural observations provide a basis for defect analysis. The main limitation is that the authors did not test the overlay in actual service conditions; they measured hardness and microstructure, but not wear or corrosion resistance. Future work should include abrasive wear testing and corrosion testing to correlate the laboratory results with field performance.

In my view, the next step for this line of research is to develop a predictive model that links process parameters to dilution and hardness, so that a production engineer can calculate the required settings without running a full design of experiments. That would save time and material on the shop floor. Until then, the practical approach is to build a process window map and keep it updated with every production batch. The paper gives you a solid starting point; the rest is up to you and your quality department.