ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Friction-Wear Properties of Nickel-Based Alloy Plasma Surfacing Layers

Literature Overview and Core Findings

Li Shan, Hu Jianjun, Chen Guoqing, Zhou Wenlong and Zhang Junshan from Dalian University of Technology and Pingxiang College published this study in Mechanical Engineering Materials in 2013. The work investigates the microstructure, hardness and friction-wear properties of Ni50A nickel-based alloy powder plasma surfacing layers deposited on 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel. The authors examined the effect of welding current on the deposit characteristics. The key findings are that the surfacing layer consists primarily of γ-Ni with precipitated phases including CrB, M23(C,B)6, Cr7C3, Cr5B3, Ni3Si and Ni3B. The microstructure varies with welding current, with the finest and most uniform structure obtained at 160 A, which also gives the highest hardness of 680 HV and the best wear resistance. The wear mechanism is primarily adhesive wear, accompanied by abrasive wear, with oxidative wear occurring at later stages. The 190 A current produces the highest wear loss.

Interpretation of Technical Points and Metallurgical Logic

Phase Composition and Hardening Mechanisms

The nickel-based alloy Ni50A is a Ni-Cr-B-Si system, which is a classic hardfacing alloy. The hardness comes from a combination of solid solution strengthening of the γ-Ni matrix and precipitation of hard borides and carbides. The paper identifies CrB, M23(C,B)6, Cr7C3, Cr5B3, Ni3Si and Ni3B as the main precipitates. These phases are typical for this alloy system. The boron content is critical because it promotes the formation of hard borides, which are the primary wear-resistant phases. The silicon content contributes to the formation of Ni3Si and also improves the fluidity of the molten pool, which is important for achieving a smooth, defect-free deposit.

Effect of Welding Current on Microstructure

The welding current has a direct effect on the heat input and cooling rate, which in turn control the microstructure. At 160 A, the heat input is moderate, resulting in a fine, uniform structure with small, well-distributed precipitates. At lower currents, the heat input may be insufficient to melt the powder completely, leading to lack of fusion and porosity. At higher currents, such as 190 A, the heat input is excessive, causing coarsening of the precipitates and possibly dilution with the base material. The paper shows that 190 A produces the coarsest structure and the highest wear loss. This is a classic example of the trade-off between deposition rate and deposit quality.

Integration with Manufacturing and Field Practice

Plasma Surfacing Process Parameters

Plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing is a high-quality process for depositing nickel-based alloys. It offers low dilution, smooth deposits and precise control of the heat input. The process parameters must be carefully balanced to achieve the desired microstructure:

Parameter Typical Range Influence on Deposit
Welding current 140 – 180 A Controls heat input and dilution
Plasma gas flow 2 – 4 L/min Affects arc stability and penetration
Powder feed rate 20 – 40 g/min Controls deposition rate
Travel speed 100 – 200 mm/min Affects cooling rate and bead shape
Oscillation width 10 – 20 mm Controls bead width and coverage

The paper's finding that 160 A gives the best properties is a useful reference point, but the optimal current will vary with the specific powder, substrate and equipment. In practice, the engineer should perform a process qualification using the actual materials and equipment to establish the process window.

Real-World Application in Valve and Pump Components

Nickel-based alloys are widely used for surfacing valve seats, pump impellers and other components that require a combination of wear and corrosion resistance. I have seen cases where PTA surfacing of Ni50A was used to repair worn valve seats in a petrochemical plant. The initial repairs failed because the welding current was too high, resulting in a coarse structure and excessive dilution. The repair was redone with a lower current and a controlled interpass temperature. The second attempt was successful, and the valve seats lasted significantly longer. This is a direct confirmation of the paper's findings. The key lesson is that the process parameters must be optimized for the specific application, not just for the alloy system.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that arises from this paper is whether the hardness of 680 HV is the optimum for all applications. The paper shows that the highest hardness corresponds to the best wear resistance under the test conditions. However, in applications involving impact or thermal cycling, a slightly lower hardness with better toughness may be more appropriate. The wear mechanism is also important. The paper identifies adhesive wear as the primary mechanism, with abrasive and oxidative wear occurring at later stages. This suggests that the deposit should have both high hardness and good oxidation resistance, which the nickel-based alloy provides. However, the balance between hardness and toughness must be considered for each application.

Another reflection is on the importance of the substrate material. The paper uses 1Cr18Ni9Ti stainless steel as the substrate. In practice, nickel-based alloys are often deposited on carbon steel or low-alloy steel. The dilution with the substrate will affect the composition of the deposit, and the thermal expansion mismatch can cause residual stresses. The engineer must consider these factors when selecting the process parameters and the preheat/interpass temperature.

Study Insights and Implications

This study provides a clear demonstration of the relationship between welding current, microstructure and wear performance in nickel-based alloy surfacing. The findings are directly applicable to the selection of process parameters for PTA surfacing of Ni50A and similar alloys. The paper reinforces the importance of process optimization and the need to verify the microstructure, not just the hardness. For the welding engineer, the practical takeaway is to establish a process window through qualification testing and to control the welding current within a narrow range to achieve the desired properties. This is a valuable reference for anyone involved in hardfacing of components that require a combination of wear and corrosion resistance.