ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Welding Current on Plasma Surfaced Fe90 Alloy: Microstructure, Hardness, Wear and Corrosion

Literature Overview and Experimental Setup

The paper by Deng et al. (2017) investigates the effect of welding current on the microstructure and properties of Fe90 self-fluxing alloy powder plasma surfacing on 304L stainless steel. Fe90 is a popular hardfacing alloy that contains iron, chromium, boron, and silicon, and it is designed to form hard borides and carbides in the deposit.

The authors used plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, which is a high-quality process that produces low dilution and a smooth deposit. The substrate was 304L stainless steel, which is a common material for pump shafts, valve seats, and other components that require corrosion resistance. The welding current was varied, and the microstructure was characterized using optical microscopy, X-ray diffraction, and transmission electron microscopy. The hardness was measured, and wear and corrosion tests were conducted.

The key findings are summarized below.

Parameter Result
Deposit phases Martensite, (Cr,Fe)7C3, CrFeB, CrB, Fe3Si
Hardness 3.5-5.2 times that of the base metal
Wear loss Reduced by 80-85% compared to base metal
Corrosion resistance Essentially unchanged
Optimal current 130 A (highest hardness, best wear resistance)

Microstructure and Phase Analysis

The deposit consists of martensite with dispersed carbides and borides. The presence of Fe3Si is interesting because silicon is typically added to self-fluxing alloys to improve the wetting and flow of the molten pool. However, Fe3Si is a hard intermetallic phase that contributes to wear resistance.

The martensite matrix provides a hard, strong base, while the (Cr,Fe)7C3 carbides and CrFeB/CrB borides provide the primary wear resistance. The combination of these phases results in a hardness that is 3.5-5.2 times that of the 304L substrate. This is a significant improvement and demonstrates the effectiveness of Fe90 as a hardfacing alloy.

The wear test showed an 80-85% reduction in wear loss, which is excellent. The corrosion resistance was essentially unchanged, which is important because the substrate is stainless steel and the deposit must not compromise the corrosion performance of the component. This is a key advantage of Fe90 over some other hardfacing alloys that may be corrosion-resistant but have poor wear resistance, or vice versa.

The effect of welding current is critical. At 130 A, the deposit has the highest hardness and best wear resistance. This is likely because the heat input at this current is optimal for the formation of hard phases. At lower currents, the deposit may have insufficient melting and poor bonding. At higher currents, the dilution from the base metal increases, which reduces the concentration of hard-phase-forming elements and softens the deposit. The authors found that 130 A is the sweet spot.

Mechanical and Tribological Performance

The hardness of the deposit is a direct function of the microstructure. The martensite matrix and the dispersed carbides and borides contribute to the overall hardness. The fact that the hardness is 3.5-5.2 times that of the base metal is a strong indication of the deposit's effectiveness.

The wear resistance is closely related to the hardness, but it is also influenced by the morphology and distribution of the hard phases. The authors found that the wear loss is reduced by 80-85%, which is a substantial improvement. This is consistent with the high hardness and the presence of hard carbides and borides.

The corrosion resistance is essentially unchanged, which is a positive result. Fe90 contains chromium, which provides some corrosion resistance. However, the presence of boron and silicon may form phases that are less corrosion-resistant than the austenitic matrix. The fact that the corrosion resistance is unchanged suggests that the deposit is compatible with the substrate in this regard.

Process Window and Shop Floor Implications

The optimal current of 130 A is a practical finding. In a production environment, you would set the welding current to 130 A and adjust the other parameters, such as travel speed, powder feed rate, and plasma gas flow, to achieve the desired deposit thickness and quality.

However, the welding current is not the only parameter that affects the deposit. The powder feed rate, plasma gas flow, and travel speed all influence the heat input and dilution. In practice, you must optimize all of these parameters together. The authors focused on current, but I would recommend a more comprehensive optimization study.

From a shop floor perspective, plasma surfacing is a high-quality process that is well-suited for precision components such as pump shafts and valve seats. The low dilution and smooth deposit are significant advantages. However, the process is more complex than conventional welding, and it requires skilled operators and careful control of the equipment.

One practical concern is the distortion of the component. Plasma surfacing can produce significant heat input, which can distort thin-walled components. In my experience, you must use fixturing and possibly a preheat to control distortion. The authors did not discuss this, but it is a critical practical consideration.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question that arises is the effect of the welding current on the dilution. The authors did not measure the dilution, but I know from experience that higher currents lead to higher dilution. At 130 A, the dilution is likely around 10-15%, which is acceptable. At higher currents, the dilution may increase to 20-30%, which would reduce the hardness and wear resistance.

Another question is the effect of the substrate on the deposit. The authors used 304L stainless steel, which has a high nickel and chromium content. This can affect the microstructure of the deposit through dilution. In practice, you may be surfacing a different substrate, such as carbon steel or a low-alloy steel. The dilution will be different, and the optimal current may be different. This is an important consideration for process transfer.

The corrosion resistance is a key property for many applications. The authors found that it is essentially unchanged, which is good. However, they used a simple electrochemical test. In practice, the corrosion resistance may be affected by the presence of a heat-affected zone, which can have a different microstructure and be more susceptible to corrosion. This is a common issue in dissimilar metal welds.

Study Insights and Outlook

This paper provides valuable information on the effect of welding current on the microstructure and properties of Fe90 plasma surfacing. The finding that 130 A is optimal is a practical guideline that can be used in production. The deposit has excellent hardness and wear resistance while maintaining the corrosion resistance of the substrate.

Looking ahead, I would like to see more research on the effect of other welding parameters, such as powder feed rate and travel speed, on the deposit properties. I would also like to see a more detailed study of the corrosion resistance, including the effect of the heat-affected zone. The use of Fe90 on stainless steel substrates is a common application, and this paper provides a useful foundation for process optimization.