ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Burn-Off Mechanisms of WC Cemented Carbide Particles During Hardfacing

What This Paper Really Tells Us

I have spent thirty years watching hardfacing wire burn into rolls, mandrels, and forming dies, and I can tell you that the loss of tungsten carbide particles is not a nuisance — it is the single biggest cost driver in wear-resistant overlays. This 2001 study by Qu Shiyao and colleagues at Shandong University goes straight to the root cause. Using scanning electron microscopy, X-ray diffraction, and electron probe microanalysis, they documented what actually happens to WC particles during the hardfacing process, and their findings match what I have seen under a microscope a thousand times.

The paper identifies three distinct forms of burn-off: particle edge melting, dissolution burn-off, and diffusion-reaction burn-off. The fundamental mechanism is that the binder phase at the edge of the carbide particles melts first, the carbide grains grow and the spacing between single-crystal WC particles increases. Then, the carbide at the particle edge decomposes, and elemental diffusion occurs between the carbide and the matrix metal, forming a diffusion layer with a concentration gradient. At the outer edge of this diffusion layer, where atomic concentration is highest, microstructural transformation occurs and new compounds form — and this is what degrades the performance of the hardfacing layer.

What This Means on the Shop Floor

Parameter Practical Observation
Binder phase melting Occurs at particle edges; leads to loss of mechanical locking of WC grains
Carbide grain growth Single crystals coarsen; spacing between them increases; wear resistance drops
Diffusion layer formation Concentration gradient develops; new brittle compounds form at the outer edge
Degree of burn-off Depends on carbide type, particle size, and welding heat input

When I specify a hardfacing alloy for a pipe forming roll or a mandrel bar, I now insist on knowing the exact particle size distribution and the binder composition. The paper confirms what I have learned the hard way: finer WC particles burn off more readily because they have a higher surface-area-to-volume ratio. Coarser particles survive better but provide less uniform distribution in the matrix. The sweet spot, in my experience, is a bimodal distribution — coarse particles for bulk wear resistance, fine particles for filling the interstices.

Practical Countermeasures for the Plant

The paper does not offer a magic cure, but it does point to practical measures. First, control the heat input. Lower current and faster travel speed reduce the time the carbide spends in the molten pool. Second, choose the right carbide grade. The binder phase composition matters enormously — cobalt binders wet the carbide better but are more prone to dissolution; nickel binders are more stable but less ductile. Third, consider the dilution rate. When hardfacing a steel substrate, the base metal dilutes the overlay, increasing the effective temperature and promoting diffusion. A buffer layer of austenitic stainless steel can reduce this dilution effect.

I have seen components fail prematurely because the hardfacing was applied with excessive heat input, causing almost complete dissolution of the WC particles. The overlay looked fine on the surface — shiny and dense — but within weeks of service, the wear rate was three times higher than expected. The lesson is simple: the burn-off is invisible to the naked eye but devastating in performance.

Veteran's Reflection

This paper is a classic because it does not just describe the problem; it explains the mechanism at a level that allows an engineer to make informed decisions. The key insight for me is that burn-off is not a single event but a sequence — melting, dissolution, diffusion, and reaction — and each step can be controlled independently. If you control the heat input, you reduce melting. If you control the dilution, you reduce diffusion. If you control the binder chemistry, you reduce reaction. It is a systems approach, and that is exactly how I run my hardfacing operations today.

The practical takeaway for anyone hardfacing rolls, mandrels, or forming tools in the pipe industry: never specify a WC hardfacing alloy without understanding the burn-off characteristics. Ask the supplier for the particle size distribution, the binder composition, and the recommended welding parameters. Then verify with a metallographic cross-section before you put the component into service. The cost of a metallographic check is negligible compared to the cost of a premature failure on a production line.