Numerical Simulation of Martensitic Transformation Effects on Tangential Stress During Hardfacing Cooling
The Problem This Paper Tackles
Cracking during hardfacing is the nightmare of every welding engineer. You lay down a beautiful overlay, it cools, and then — crack. Sometimes it happens immediately, sometimes it happens hours later, sometimes it happens when the component is put into service. This 2012 paper by Zhou Yefei and colleagues at Yanshan University addresses one of the root causes: the development of tangential residual stress during cooling, and specifically the effect of martensitic transformation on that stress.
The researchers used infrared thermography and X-ray stress measurement to determine the temperature field and residual stress field during hardfacing of hot-roll steel. Based on the experimental data and the material's physical and mechanical parameters, they built a two-dimensional finite element model of the stress field and simulated the tangential residual stress. The simulation results matched the measured values, confirming the validity of the model.
The Key Finding
The critical result is that during cooling, when martensitic transformation occurs, a tangential compressive stress appears at the specimen surface. As cooling continues and the amount of martensite increases, the surface begins to develop a large tangential tensile stress, which persists to room temperature.
| Stage of Cooling | Surface Tangential Stress | Physical Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Before martensitic transformation | Tensile | Thermal contraction of the overlay |
| During transformation onset | Compressive | Volume expansion of martensite |
| Transformation progresses | Transition to tensile | Matrix constraint dominates |
| At room temperature | Large tensile | Combined thermal + transformation stress |
This is a counterintuitive result. Common wisdom says that martensitic transformation, which involves a volume expansion, should produce compressive stress. But the paper shows that the compressive stress is transient — it appears at the start of transformation but is quickly overwhelmed by the thermal contraction of the surrounding material as cooling continues. The final state is a large tensile stress, which is exactly what causes cracking.
What This Means for Hardfacing Practice
For anyone hardfacing rolls, mandrels, or other steel components, this paper provides a clear warning: the martensitic transformation does not save you from cracking. The transient compressive stress during transformation may give a false sense of security, but the final residual stress is tensile and can exceed the fracture strength of the overlay.
The practical implications are significant. First, preheating is essential. A preheat temperature above the martensite start temperature reduces the temperature gradient and delays the transformation, allowing the stress to distribute more evenly. Second, post-weld heat treatment is critical. Tempering after hardfacing relieves the residual stress and transforms the brittle martensite into a more ductile tempered martensite. Third, the choice of hardfacing alloy matters. Alloys with a lower martensite start temperature, or those that form bainite instead of martensite, will have lower residual stress.
Veteran's Reflection
I have seen this phenomenon in practice many times, though I did not always understand the mechanism. A hardfaced roll would crack after sitting overnight, and the crack would always be longitudinal — following the tangential stress direction. The paper explains why: the tangential stress is the one that develops most strongly, and it is the one that causes longitudinal cracking.
The paper also highlights the importance of numerical simulation in welding engineering. I remember the days when we relied purely on experience and trial-and-error. Today, with validated finite element models, we can predict the stress state before we ever strike an arc. This is not just an academic exercise — it is a practical tool for selecting preheat temperatures, interpass temperatures, and post-weld heat treatment schedules.
My advice to fellow engineers: if you are hardfacing a component that will be used in a critical application, do not skip the simulation. The cost of a finite element analysis is negligible compared to the cost of a cracked roll that takes down a production line for three days.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd