Spherical WC Reinforced Iron-Based Composite Plasma Hardfacing: Microstructure and Tribological Properties
Literature Overview
The paper by Fan Li et al. from Shanghai Maritime University investigates the use of spherical tungsten carbide (WC) particles to reinforce iron-based composite coatings on 304 stainless steel. Using plasma hardfacing, the authors prepared coatings with 30% and 60% WC by weight, and evaluated their microstructure, phase composition, microhardness, and dry sliding wear behaviour. The key finding is that WC addition significantly improves hardness and wear resistance, with the 60% WC coating showing the best performance, but the wear mechanism changes with WC content.
Core Technical Points
Microstructure and Hardness
The coatings consisted of a Cr-rich solid-solution-strengthened austenite matrix, with Cr7C3 and WC as hard phases. The WC particles were distributed throughout the matrix, providing reinforcement.
| Coating | Microhardness (HV0.2) | Relative to Fe-based | Relative to 304 Substrate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fe-based | 549 | 100% | 3.1x |
| 30% WC | 665 | 121.1% | 3.7x |
| 60% WC | 724 | 131.9% | 4.0x |
The hardness increased with WC content, but the increment was not linear. The 60% WC coating showed a 31.9% improvement over the Fe-based coating, compared to 21.1% for the 30% WC coating. This suggests that the WC particles are providing effective reinforcement, but there may be a limit to the benefit.
Friction and Wear Behaviour
The dry sliding wear tests were conducted at a constant load of 50 N and sliding speed of 20 mm/s.
| Coating | Friction Coefficient | Wear Rate (mm³·N⁻¹·m⁻¹) |
|---|---|---|
| Fe-based | Not reported | Not reported |
| 30% WC | 0.59 | 2.639 × 10⁻⁶ |
| 60% WC | 0.42 | 1.111 × 10⁻⁶ |
The 60% WC coating showed a lower friction coefficient and a significantly lower wear rate. The wear rate of the 60% WC coating was less than half that of the 30% WC coating.
Wear Mechanisms
The wear mechanisms were analysed through SEM observation of the worn surfaces. The 30% WC coating showed a mixed mechanism of adhesive wear and two-body abrasive wear. The 60% WC coating showed three-body abrasive wear.
The difference in wear mechanism is significant. Three-body abrasive wear, where wear particles act as abrasive media between the sliding surfaces, is typically more severe than two-body abrasive wear. However, the 60% WC coating still showed better wear resistance, indicating that the WC particles provide effective protection even under more severe wear conditions.
Engineering Practice and Reflection
Why Spherical WC?
The use of spherical WC particles is a deliberate choice. Spherical particles have a more uniform stress distribution and better bonding with the matrix compared to irregular or angular particles. This is particularly important in plasma hardfacing, where the particles are injected into the molten pool and may not fully dissolve.
Practical Considerations for Plasma Hardfacing
- Powder Injection: The WC particles must be injected into the plasma jet with precise control. The carrier gas flow rate and powder feed rate determine the particle distribution in the deposit.
- Particle Dissolution: WC can dissolve in the molten pool, leading to the formation of W-rich phases and a loss of the reinforcement effect. The heat input must be controlled to minimise dissolution.
- Particle Settling: The density difference between WC and the iron-based matrix can cause particle settling or floating, leading to non-uniform distribution. This is a common problem in composite coatings.
Lessons from the Field
I have used WC-reinforced composite coatings on pipe fittings for abrasive service in slurry pipelines. The performance improvement is dramatic, but the application requires careful process control. In one case, a contractor applied a WC-reinforced coating with excessive heat input, leading to significant WC dissolution and a deposit that was barely better than the un-reinforced matrix. The coating failed within six months. A subsequent application with optimised parameters lasted over three years.
Key Questions and Reflections
- What is the optimal WC content? The paper shows that 60% WC provides better performance than 30%, but the trend may not continue. At very high WC contents, the matrix may not be able to bind the particles effectively, leading to poor cohesion and premature failure.
- How does the WC content affect the matrix? The addition of WC changes the composition of the matrix through dissolution and diffusion. This can affect the formation of other phases and the overall properties of the deposit.
- What is the effect of WC particle size? The paper uses a specific particle size. The optimal particle size depends on the application and the coating thickness. Finer particles provide more uniform distribution but may dissolve more readily.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper demonstrates the significant potential of WC-reinforced composite coatings for wear resistance. The improvement in hardness and wear resistance is substantial, and the change in wear mechanism with WC content provides valuable insight into the reinforcement mechanism.
The practical implications are clear: WC-reinforced coatings can provide a step-change in wear performance for components in abrasive service. However, the process must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired microstructure and avoid the pitfalls of particle dissolution and non-uniform distribution.
Reference Value and Outlook
This work is highly relevant for applications where extreme wear resistance is required, such as pipe fittings, valves, and pump components in slurry service. The use of spherical WC particles is a sound engineering choice, and the systematic evaluation of the wear behaviour provides a solid foundation for practical application.
Future work should focus on:
- Determining the optimal WC content for different wear conditions.
- Investigating the effect of WC particle size and distribution.
- Evaluating the performance in corrosive-wear and erosive-wear conditions.
- Developing process parameters for consistent production.
In my experience, WC-reinforced composite coatings are a powerful tool for wear protection, but they require a level of process control that is often underestimated. This paper provides a good foundation for understanding the material behaviour, and I would recommend it to anyone considering this technology for their applications.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd