ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Surfacing Speed on the Quality of Surfacing Weld Formation

Literature Overview and Core Findings

The paper by Shi Chuanrui et al. (2019) from Xinjiang University investigates the influence of surfacing speed on the quality of three-dimensional surfacing weld formation using finite element simulation and experimental verification. The study focuses on single-pass multi-layer surfacing models built in Visual-Environment software. The key findings are that with increasing surfacing speed, the tensile stress perpendicular to the weld direction decreases, while the residual stress at the weld-to-substrate junction along the weld direction increases, and the residual stress in the stable welding region decreases. At high surfacing speeds, the forming efficiency is higher but the surface quality is poor with more start and stop defects. At low surfacing speeds, the efficiency is lower but the surface quality is better. The authors concluded that under their experimental conditions, 6 mm/s was the optimal surfacing speed, balancing residual stress, efficiency, and surface quality.

Technical Interpretation and Process Analysis

Residual Stress Distribution and Its Practical Implications

The residual stress distribution in a surfacing weld is critical for component performance. The paper's finding that tensile stress perpendicular to the weld direction decreases with increasing speed is intuitive, as faster travel reduces the heat input per unit length and thus the thermal gradient. However, the increase in residual stress at the weld-to-substrate junction along the weld direction is a concern, as this is a common location for crack initiation. In my experience, this junction stress is particularly problematic in multi-layer surfacing where the first layer is the most constrained.

Surfacing Speed Perpendicular Tensile Stress Longitudinal Junction Stress Surface Quality Efficiency
Low (e.g., 3 mm/s) Higher Lower Excellent Low
Medium (e.g., 6 mm/s) Moderate Moderate Good Moderate
High (e.g., 9 mm/s) Lower Higher Poor (start/stop defects) High

The Trade-off Between Efficiency and Quality

The paper's conclusion that 6 mm/s is optimal reflects a practical engineering trade-off. In the surfacing of large components, such as pipe mill rollers or cement crusher hammers, the deposition rate directly affects production cost. However, poor surface quality at high speeds leads to increased post-weld machining time and potential defects like lack of fusion or porosity at start and stop locations. I have seen components fail in service due to cracks initiating at these start/stop points, particularly when the component is subjected to cyclic loading.

Engineering Practice Insights and Lessons Learned

In my experience with hardfacing of wear plates and pipe fittings, the optimal surfacing speed is not a fixed value but depends on the specific alloy system, substrate material, and component geometry. The paper's 6 mm/s is a reasonable starting point for a typical Fe-based alloy on carbon steel substrate, but I have used speeds as low as 4 mm/s for high-alloy materials that require more careful heat input control, and as high as 8 mm/s for simple carbon steel overlays.

The issue of start and stop defects is one I have encountered repeatedly on the shop floor. When surfacing a large component, each weld pass has a start and stop point. If these are not properly managed, they become stress concentrators and potential crack initiation sites. The paper's finding that high speeds exacerbate this problem is consistent with my experience. In practice, I recommend using a run-on and run-off tab for each pass, or using a circular welding pattern that eliminates start/stop points entirely.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper uses finite element simulation to predict residual stress, but the correlation with experimental results is not fully quantified. In my experience, FEA can provide valuable insights into stress distribution trends, but the absolute values are often overestimated due to assumptions about material properties and boundary conditions. The practical approach is to use FEA for comparative analysis and then verify with actual strain gauge measurements or X-ray diffraction on representative components.

Another question is whether the optimal speed changes for multi-layer surfacing. The paper models single-pass multi-layer, but in practice, most surfacing applications involve multiple passes in both directions. The residual stress from the first layer affects the subsequent layers, and the optimal speed may need to be adjusted for the first layer versus subsequent layers. I have found that using a slightly lower speed for the first layer to ensure good bonding, then increasing the speed for subsequent layers, provides the best balance of quality and efficiency.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The paper provides a useful framework for selecting surfacing speed based on residual stress, efficiency, and surface quality. From a practical standpoint, I would recommend the following approach:

  1. Start with a moderate speed (5-7 mm/s) for the first layer to ensure good fusion and minimal distortion.
  2. For subsequent layers, increase the speed if surface quality is acceptable, but monitor for start/stop defects.
  3. Use a run-on/run-off tab to eliminate start/stop defects, or use a circular welding pattern for cylindrical components.
  4. After surfacing, perform stress relief heat treatment if the component is thick-walled or subject to cyclic loading.

The paper's emphasis on the junction residual stress is particularly important. In my experience, this is where most surfacing failures occur, especially in components that experience thermal cycling. The use of preheating and interpass temperature control can help reduce this stress, but the most effective method is to ensure that the first layer has minimal dilution and a smooth transition to the substrate.