ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Surfacing Current on Ni-Based Alloy Plasma Surfacing Layers

Literature Overview

This study by Cui Wendong and colleagues from Shenyang Blower Works Group Nuclear Pump Co., Ltd. and Shenyang University of Technology addresses a practical problem we face repeatedly in the field: improving the wear resistance of austenitic stainless steel components without compromising their corrosion resistance. The authors employed plasma surfacing technology to deposit a Ni-based alloy layer on Z2CN18-10 austenitic stainless steel, systematically investigating the effect of surfacing current on microstructure, phase composition, hardness, and wear resistance. This is exactly the kind of work that matters when we are asked to repair or hardface pump casings, valve bodies, or impeller shafts that have seen service and need a wear-resistant overlay. The research is funded by national key R&D programs, which tells me the industry recognizes the importance of this technology for nuclear and petrochemical applications.

Technical Interpretation of Key Points

Phase Composition and Microstructure Evolution

The authors identified the phase constitution of the Ni-based alloy surfacing layer as γ-Ni solid solution with eutectic structures of FeNi₃, Cr₂₃C₆, Cr₇C₃, and CrB. This is a classic Ni-Cr-B-Si hardfacing alloy system, where boron and silicon act as fluxing agents and form hard borides and carbides. What is particularly interesting is the morphological transition as surfacing current increases. The microstructure changes from clustered petal-like forms to waterweed-like and elongated strip-like structures. This tells me that heat input, controlled by current, directly affects the solidification mode and the size and distribution of hard phases.

Hardness and Wear Resistance

The critical finding is that at 110 A surfacing current, the average microhardness reached a maximum of 898 HV, with relative wear resistance of 13.8 compared to the substrate. The wear mechanism was identified as a mixed mode: adhesive and abrasive wear in the early stage, transitioning to oxidative wear in the later stage. This is a significant result because it demonstrates that there is an optimal current window where the hard phase distribution and matrix strength combine to give maximum wear performance. Too low a current and the dilution from the substrate may be insufficient to form the desired phases; too high a current and the hard phases become coarsened and less effective.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Practical Implications for Pump and Valve Components

In my experience with nuclear pump components and valve bodies, plasma surfacing with Ni-based alloys is a preferred method for restoring dimensions and improving wear resistance on sealing surfaces, shaft journals, and wear rings. The Z2CN18-10 stainless steel is widely used in nuclear service, and its relatively low hardness makes it susceptible to galling and adhesive wear. The data from this study confirms that a properly optimized plasma surfacing process can achieve hardness values approaching 900 HV, which is more than sufficient for most sealing and bearing applications.

Process Window Considerations

The study's focus on current as the primary variable is well-placed. In production, we typically control current, voltage, travel speed, and powder feed rate. Current is the most direct control over heat input and deposition rate. From a practical standpoint, the 110 A optimum found in this study would need to be verified for the specific component geometry and thickness. For thin-walled components, excessive current can cause distortion or burn-through. For thick sections, we may need to consider preheat and interpass temperature control to prevent cracking.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

One issue not explicitly addressed but critical in practice is the potential for cracking in Ni-based hardfacing layers due to the high hardness and brittle phases. The presence of Cr₇C₃ and CrB in the eutectic structure increases hardness but also reduces ductility. In my experience, preheating the substrate to 150-200°C and controlling interpass temperature is essential to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking and solidification cracking. Post-weld heat treatment may also be required for certain components to relieve residual stresses.

Lessons and Reflections

What This Study Teaches Us

This study reinforces a fundamental principle we often overlook: process parameters are not just about productivity, they directly determine the metallurgical quality and service performance of the surfacing layer. The morphological transition from petal-like to elongated structures with increasing current is a clear indication that the solidification front velocity and thermal gradient are being altered. A shop floor technician might see the change in bead appearance, but without understanding the microstructural implications, they might not appreciate the significance.

The Practical Takeaway

For my engineering colleagues, the key takeaway is that you cannot simply select a surfacing current based on deposition rate or operator comfort. You must understand the relationship between current, dilution, phase formation, and final properties. The 898 HV maximum at 110 A is a data point, but the real lesson is that the process window is narrow and must be validated for each application. I would recommend that any shop performing this type of surfacing develop a process qualification procedure that includes microhardness testing, metallographic examination, and wear testing on representative coupons before committing to production.

A Cautionary Note

I have seen cases where Ni-based surfacing layers failed in service due to spalling or delamination. This often occurs when the dilution from the substrate is too high, resulting in a hard layer that is too thin or has insufficient bond strength. The study's finding that the wear mechanism includes adhesive wear in the early stage is a reminder that the surface quality and the integrity of the interface are critical. Proper surface preparation, including machining and cleaning, is essential to ensure a sound metallurgical bond.

Conclusion

This study provides valuable data on the effect of surfacing current on Ni-based alloy plasma surfacing layers, demonstrating that an optimal current of 110 A yields maximum hardness and wear resistance. The phase analysis and wear mechanism identification offer practical guidance for process optimization. For the industry, the key insight is that plasma surfacing of austenitic stainless steel with Ni-based alloys is a viable method for improving wear resistance, but it requires careful process control and validation. I would recommend that any engineer involved in hardfacing of pump and valve components study this work carefully and use it as a basis for developing their own process qualification tests. The findings are directly applicable to nuclear and petrochemical service where wear resistance and corrosion resistance must be balanced. This is the kind of literature that should be on the desk of every welding engineer responsible for surfacing operations.