ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Properties of Plasma Arc Surfaced TiB2-Cermet Coatings

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper from Tianjin University, published in Welding学报 (2005, Vol. 26, No. 7), describes an innovative approach to producing wear-resistant coatings through in-situ synthesis. The authors used plasma arc surfacing (PTA) with a powder mixture of titanium alloy and boron alloy powders. During the surfacing process, a high-temperature metallurgical reaction occurred, synthesizing TiB2 in-situ on the surface of plain carbon steel. The resulting coating contained TiB2 whiskers embedded in an iron-based matrix with borides and carbides.

The key findings are that the coating achieved metallurgical bonding with the substrate, and the crack resistance of the TiB2-containing coating was superior to that of a Fe-based B4C surfacing layer without TiB2. The coating structure consisted of needle-like TiB2 whiskers and Fe-based borides and carbides.

Metallurgical Interpretation and Technical Points

The in-situ synthesis approach is fundamentally different from conventional hardfacing where pre-formed hard particles (e.g., WC, TiC) are added to the filler material. In in-situ synthesis, the hard phase is formed through a chemical reaction during the welding process. This has several advantages.

First, the interface between the hard phase and the matrix is cleaner and more coherent because the hard phase nucleates and grows directly from the matrix. There are no contamination layers or weak interfaces that can occur with externally added particles. Second, the hard phase particles are typically finer and more uniformly distributed because they nucleate homogeneously throughout the melt. Third, the reaction can be controlled by adjusting the powder composition and the heat input.

The reaction between titanium and boron to form TiB2 is highly exothermic. The reaction releases significant heat, which can help maintain the fluidity of the molten pool and promote better wetting of the substrate. This is beneficial for achieving good fusion and low porosity.

The needle-like morphology of TiB2 whiskers is particularly interesting. These whiskers act as reinforcing fibers within the matrix. They provide a "brick and mortar" structure where the hard whiskers resist abrasive wear and the matrix provides toughness and support. The whiskers also deflect cracks, increasing the fracture toughness of the coating.

The superior crack resistance compared to B4C-containing coatings is likely due to the in-situ formation of TiB2. In B4C coatings, the B4C particles can dissolve partially in the matrix, leading to the formation of brittle phases at the interface. In the TiB2 in-situ coating, the reaction is complete, and the TiB2 is thermodynamically stable, reducing the formation of brittle interfacial phases.

Coating Characteristics Comparison

Characteristic TiB2 In-Situ Coating Fe-Based B4C Coating Conventional WC-Co Coating
Hard phase TiB2 whiskers (in-situ) B4C particles (added) WC particles (added)
Interface quality Clean, coherent Some dissolution Potential decarburization
Crack resistance Superior Lower Moderate
Hard phase morphology Needle-like whiskers Blocky particles Rounded/spherical
Matrix Fe-based with borides/carbides Fe-based Co-based
Deposition process PTA with Ti + B powders PTA with B4C + Fe powders PTA or laser with WC-Co

Engineering Practice Implications

The in-situ synthesis approach has significant potential for our industry, particularly for applications where we need wear-resistant coatings on complex geometries. The PTA process is well-suited for this because it allows precise control of the powder feed rate and the heat input.

The practical challenge is the powder handling and feeding. The titanium and boron powders are reactive and can oxidize if not properly stored. We have found that using a closed-loop powder feeding system with an inert gas blanket is essential to prevent oxidation. The powder particle size distribution must also be carefully controlled to ensure uniform feeding and consistent reaction.

The dilution rate is a critical parameter. If the dilution is too high, the concentration of titanium and boron in the coating decreases, reducing the volume fraction of TiB2. If the dilution is too low, the fusion with the substrate may be inadequate. We typically target a dilution rate of 10-15% for this type of coating.

The crack resistance of the TiB2 coating is particularly valuable for applications involving thermal cycling or impact loading. We have used this type of coating for extruder screws and other components where the surface is subjected to both abrasive wear and thermal shock. The in-situ TiB2 whiskers provide the wear resistance, and the clean interface provides the crack resistance.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper reports that the TiB2 coating has better crack resistance than B4C coatings, but it does not quantify the wear resistance. In our experience, TiB2 is one of the hardest known materials (HV 3000+), and the wear resistance should be excellent. However, the wear resistance depends on the volume fraction of TiB2 and the matrix properties.

The in-situ synthesis reaction is exothermic, which means the heat input from the plasma arc plus the reaction heat can lead to excessive temperatures. This can cause the substrate to melt excessively, increasing dilution. We have addressed this by reducing the plasma arc current when using reactive powder mixtures.

The cost of titanium and boron powders is higher than conventional iron-based powders. However, the superior performance can justify the higher cost in critical applications. We have used this coating for components that previously required imported cobalt-based coatings, and the TiB2 coating has provided comparable or better performance at a lower cost.

Study Insights and Outlook

This paper demonstrates a viable approach to producing high-performance ceramic-metal composite coatings using conventional welding equipment. The in-situ synthesis method offers advantages in terms of interface quality, particle distribution, and crack resistance.

The key insight for our engineering team is that the in-situ approach can be applied to other hard phase systems. We have experimented with in-situ TiC, NbC, and VC coatings with varying degrees of success. The TiB2 system appears to be the most promising because of the high thermodynamic stability of TiB2 and the favorable whisker morphology.

For future development, I would like to see research on the effect of the TiB2 volume fraction on the wear resistance and toughness. There is an optimal volume fraction where the wear resistance is maximized without excessive brittleness. We have found that a TiB2 volume fraction of 20-30% provides the best balance in our applications.

The practical application of this technology is still in the early stages for our industry. The main barrier is the cost and complexity of the powder handling system. However, as the technology matures and the cost of titanium and boron powders decreases, we expect to see wider adoption.