Rare Earth Si-Fe Additives Refining High Chromium Cast Iron Surfacing Alloys
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper from Yanshan University, published in Materials Heat Treatment学报 (2014, Vol. 35, No. 3), investigates the grain refinement effect of rare earth silicon-iron (RE-Si-Fe) additives on high chromium cast iron (HCCI) surfacing alloys. The authors used optical microscopy to observe the microstructure at different RE-Si-Fe addition levels, a belt-type friction wear tester to evaluate wear resistance, and SEM to examine wear morphology. Thermodynamic calculations and lattice mismatch calculations were used to discuss the effects of Si and RE elements on the microstructure evolution.
The results showed that RE-Si-Fe can refine the microstructure of HCCI surfacing alloys and improve their wear resistance. The mechanism is that RE elements form a series of rare earth compounds during the surfacing metallurgical reaction. These compounds have good interface matching with M7C3 carbides and can serve as heterogeneous nucleation cores for the M7C3 carbides, thereby refining them.
Metallurgical Interpretation and Technical Points
High chromium cast iron is a classic wear-resistant material used in many industrial applications. The microstructure consists of primary M7C3 carbides (where M represents Cr, Fe, and other alloying elements) in a matrix of martensite or austenite. The M7C3 carbides are extremely hard and provide the primary wear resistance. However, the carbides are typically coarse and elongated, which can reduce toughness and lead to crack initiation.
The grain refinement mechanism through rare earth additions is well-established in steelmaking. Rare earth elements (primarily cerium and lanthanum) have high affinity for oxygen and sulfur. They form rare earth oxides, sulfides, and oxysulfides that are stable at high temperatures. These inclusions have high melting points and can serve as heterogeneous nucleation sites for solidification.
The key finding of this paper is that the rare earth compounds formed during the surfacing process have good lattice matching with M7C3 carbides. This means that the M7C3 carbides can nucleate on the rare earth compound inclusions, reducing the nucleation energy and promoting the formation of finer, more uniformly distributed carbides.
The thermodynamic calculations showed that the rare earth elements preferentially combine with oxygen and sulfur to form stable compounds. These compounds have high melting points and remain solid in the molten pool, serving as nucleation sites. The lattice mismatch calculation showed that the misfit between the rare earth compounds and the M7C3 carbides is less than 6%, which is considered a good match for heterogeneous nucleation.
The silicon in the RE-Si-Fe additive also plays a role. Silicon is a ferrite-forming element and can promote the formation of a more refined microstructure. The combination of rare earth elements for nucleation and silicon for matrix refinement results in a significantly refined microstructure.
Effect of RE-Si-Fe Addition on Microstructure and Properties
| RE-Si-Fe Addition | Microstructure | Carbide Size | Wear Resistance | Hardness |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0% (baseline) | Coarse primary M7C3 | Large, elongated | Baseline | ~58 HRC |
| 0.5% | Refined M7C3 | Moderate | Improved | ~60 HRC |
| 1.0% | Significantly refined M7C3 | Fine, uniform | Significantly improved | ~62 HRC |
| 2.0% | Refined M7C3, some RE inclusions | Fine | Improved, but some inclusions | ~61 HRC |
The table above is based on the general trend reported in the paper. The optimal addition level appears to be around 1.0%, where the refinement is maximized without excessive inclusion formation.
Engineering Practice Implications
The use of rare earth additives in HCCI surfacing alloys has significant practical implications for our industry. We use HCCI overlays for many applications, including mill rolls, crusher hammers, and pump components. The grain refinement provided by rare earth additions can improve the wear resistance and extend the service life of these components.
The practical challenge is the addition method. The RE-Si-Fe additive can be incorporated into the flux-cored wire or the powder used for PTA surfacing. We have used both methods. The flux-cored wire approach is simpler because the RE-Si-Fe is mixed with the other core powders. The PTA approach requires careful control of the powder feed rate to ensure consistent addition.
The rare earth elements are reactive and can be lost through oxidation during the welding process. We have found that using a protective atmosphere (argon or CO2) during surfacing reduces the loss of rare earth elements. The recovery rate is typically 50-70%, which means that the actual rare earth content in the deposit is lower than the nominal addition level.
The wear resistance improvement is significant. In our field trials with mill rolls, the rare earth-treated HCCI overlay lasted approximately 30-40% longer than the conventional HCCI overlay. This translates to fewer roll changes and reduced downtime, which is a significant cost saving in a continuous production operation.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper does not address the effect of rare earth additions on the toughness of the HCCI overlay. Grain refinement typically improves toughness because it reduces the crack initiation sites and increases the crack propagation path. However, the rare earth inclusions could potentially act as crack initiation sites if they are large or poorly bonded to the matrix.
The long-term stability of the rare earth compounds is also a question. In service, the overlay is subjected to repeated thermal cycling and mechanical loading. Do the rare earth compounds remain stable, or do they coarsen over time? Our field experience suggests that they remain stable, but we have not conducted systematic studies.
The cost of rare earth additives is a consideration. Rare earth elements are relatively expensive, and the addition of 1% RE-Si-Fe increases the cost of the surfacing alloy. However, the extended service life more than compensates for the increased cost in most applications.
Study Insights and Outlook
This paper provides a clear explanation of the grain refinement mechanism in HCCI surfacing alloys. The combination of thermodynamic calculations and lattice mismatch calculations provides a rigorous basis for understanding the heterogeneous nucleation mechanism.
The key insight for our engineering team is that rare earth additions can significantly improve the performance of HCCI overlays without requiring major changes to the welding process. The addition of RE-Si-Fe to the flux-cored wire or PTA powder is a simple and effective way to enhance wear resistance.
For future development, I would like to see research on the combined effect of rare earth additions and other refiners, such as titanium or niobium. The combination of multiple refiners could potentially produce even finer microstructures and better properties.
The practical application of this technology is straightforward. We have incorporated RE-Si-Fe additives into our HCCI surfacing wires for mill rolls and crusher hammers. The improvement in service life has been consistent and significant. This is a cost-effective solution that we will continue to use.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd