ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Post-Weld Heat Treatment and the Fe-Cr-C Hardfacing Dilemma

Why This Paper Still Matters After Fifteen Years

I have signed off on hundreds of tonnes of hardfaced rolls, crusher hammers and chute liners, and I can tell you that the Fe-Cr-C system is one of the workhorses of the abrasion-resistant industry. The paper by Wang Zhihui and colleagues from Beijing University of Technology, published in the Journal of Materials Heat Treatment in 2009, addresses a question that still gets asked in my shop every time a customer specifies a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) on a hardfaced component. The question is simple: if I heat-treat this part to relieve residual stress, what am I giving up in wear life?

The authors used submerged arc welding to deposit an Fe-Cr-C hardfacing layer on Q235 low-carbon steel, then subjected the specimens to PWHT at 850°C to 1000°C for 30 minutes. They measured macro hardness, micro hardness of the primary carbides and the matrix, and then ran abrasive wear tests. The results were sobering. The macro hardness dropped by about 25% compared to the as-welded condition. The primary carbides only lost about 5% of their hardness, but the matrix lost an average of 39%. The relative wear resistance plummeted to just 16% to 32% of the as-welded value. In other words, a standard stress-relief heat treatment can destroy the wear performance of a hardfaced component.

The Metallurgical Root Cause

What is happening here is a classic case of property mismatch. The Fe-Cr-C alloy consists of hard primary carbides (typically M7C3 type) embedded in a matrix that is a mixture of austenite, martensite and retained austenite in the as-welded condition. The matrix is hard and supports the carbides, preventing them from being pulled out of the surface during abrasive contact. When you heat treat at 850°C to 1000°C, the matrix transforms and softens significantly. The carbides remain hard, but the supporting structure around them is no longer strong enough to hold them in place. The carbides become like loose pebbles in soft mud. Under abrasive wear, the matrix wears away quickly and the carbides are torn out, leaving a surface that is actually more vulnerable than a softer but more homogeneous material.

The authors correctly identify that the deterioration of the carbide-matrix matching relationship is the main cause of the reduced wear resistance. This is a fundamental principle that I have seen play out on real equipment. I recall a case where a customer specified a stress-relief treatment on a set of crusher hammers that were hardfaced with a similar alloy. The hammers looked fine after heat treatment, but they failed in less than half the expected service life. The failure mode was not fracture but rapid abrasive wear, exactly as this paper predicts.

Practical Implications for the Shop Floor

Parameter As-Welded After PWHT at 850-1000°C
Macro hardness (HRC) Baseline (100%) Approximately 75% of baseline
Primary carbide hardness Baseline (100%) Approximately 95% of baseline
Matrix hardness Baseline (100%) Approximately 61% of baseline
Relative wear resistance 100% 16% to 32%

The table above summarises the key findings. The message to any production engineer is clear: if a hardfaced component must be stress-relieved, you are accepting a substantial reduction in wear life. There are three practical options. First, avoid PWHT entirely if the residual stress is acceptable for the application. Second, use a lower temperature PWHT in the range of 400°C to 600°C, which will not cause the same matrix softening but will still provide some stress relief. Third, if a high-temperature PWHT is mandatory, consider changing the hardfacing alloy to one that is more stable at elevated temperatures, such as a martensitic stainless steel type or a nickel-based alloy.

I have also learned the hard way that the heat treatment atmosphere matters. If you heat treat in air at 850°C or above, you will get significant oxidation and decarburisation of the surface. This further degrades the wear layer. A controlled atmosphere or vacuum furnace is preferable, but that adds cost and scheduling complexity. The best approach is to discuss the PWHT requirement with the customer before welding, not after. Once the hardfacing is applied, the metallurgical cards are already on the table.

A Candid Reflection

This paper is a valuable reminder that heat treatment is not a neutral operation. It changes the microstructure and properties of the deposit in ways that are not always obvious from a simple hardness check. I have seen too many specifications that call for a standard PWHT without considering the effect on the hardfacing layer. The result is a component that meets the hardness requirement but fails in service because the wear resistance has been compromised.

My advice to fellow engineers is to treat the PWHT of hardfaced components as a design decision, not a routine step. Consider the service conditions, the expected wear mechanism, and the consequences of reduced wear life. If the component is going to be exposed to severe abrasive wear, question the need for a high-temperature PWHT. If stress relief is absolutely necessary, look for alternative methods such as controlled shot peening or low-temperature heat treatment. The 25% hardness drop and the 68% to 84% wear resistance drop are not numbers to be ignored. They are the difference between a component that lasts a full campaign and one that fails halfway through.

Key Takeaways

The Fe-Cr-C hardfacing alloy is a robust and economical choice for abrasive wear applications, but it is not immune to the effects of post-weld heat treatment. The primary carbides are stable, but the matrix is not. Any heat treatment above approximately 800°C will soften the matrix and destroy the carbide-matrix synergy that gives the alloy its wear resistance. This is a fundamental metallurgical fact that has not changed since this paper was published. The practical lesson is to communicate this clearly to design engineers and customers before the welding starts, and to make PWHT decisions based on a full understanding of the service environment. The cost of a premature failure is always far higher than the cost of a thoughtful heat treatment strategy.