Roll Hardfacing: Equipment, Materials and Process Trends
The Economic Case for Roll Hardfacing
The paper by Zhang Yingyue and colleagues from Hohai University, published in Electric Welding Machine in 2010, provides a comprehensive overview of the status and development trends of roll hardfacing. This is a topic that I know intimately, having spent years managing the hardfacing of work rolls and back-up rolls for hot strip mills, cold rolling mills and bar mills. The economic case for roll hardfacing is compelling. A new work roll can cost hundreds of thousands of dollars, and it typically has a limited service life before it must be re-ground or replaced. Hardfacing extends the life of the roll by depositing a wear-resistant layer on the surface, allowing the roll to be reused multiple times. The cost of hardfacing is typically 10% to 20% of the cost of a new roll, and the service life can be extended by a factor of two to three.
The authors identify three key areas of roll hardfacing: equipment, materials and process. They point out that in China, most of the hardfacing equipment is retrofitted from general-purpose welding machines rather than being purpose-built. This results in lower automation and inconsistent quality. The welding materials used for roll hardfacing are limited in variety and heavily dependent on imports. The process is often developed by trial and error, without the benefit of a systematic expert system.
Equipment: The Need for Automation and Precision
| Equipment Aspect | Current Status (2010) | Desired Status |
|---|---|---|
| Machine type | Mostly retrofitted from general-purpose welders | Purpose-built hardfacing machines |
| Automation level | Low, manual or semi-automatic | Fully automatic with CNC control |
| Process control | Manual adjustment of parameters | Closed-loop control of current, voltage and speed |
| Deposition rate | Limited by manual operation | High deposition rate with multi-wire or tandem processes |
| Quality consistency | Variable, dependent on operator skill | Consistent, independent of operator skill |
The table above illustrates the gap between the current status and the desired status. I have seen the consequences of using retrofitted equipment. In one case, a roll hardfacing operation was using a converted submerged arc welding machine with manual adjustment of the welding parameters. The operator had to adjust the current and voltage by hand as the roll rotated, and the resulting deposit had variations in hardness and thickness. The roll had to be re-machined and re-hardfaced because the deposit was not uniform. A purpose-built machine with CNC control would have produced a consistent deposit, saving both time and money.
The trend toward automation is essential for the future of roll hardfacing. The welding parameters must be precisely controlled to achieve the desired deposit chemistry and hardness. The roll must rotate at a constant speed, and the welding head must traverse at a constant rate. The arc length must be maintained at a constant value, which requires a closed-loop control system. The authors correctly identify that the development of automated hardfacing machines is a key priority.
Materials: The Need for Domestic Development
The materials used for roll hardfacing are typically high-alloy steels, such as high-chromium cast iron, martensitic stainless steel, and tool steels. The selection of the material depends on the application. Hot strip mill work rolls require a material that can withstand high temperature and thermal fatigue, while cold mill rolls require a material that can resist abrasive wear and galling. The authors point out that the range of available welding materials in China is limited, and that many high-performance materials must be imported. This is a significant disadvantage because it increases cost and lead time, and it makes the manufacturer dependent on foreign suppliers.
I have experienced this problem firsthand. In the early 2000s, we had to import a high-performance flux-cored wire for the hardfacing of a large backup roll. The wire was expensive and the lead time was six months. We had to plan the production schedule around the delivery of the wire, which was a significant constraint. The development of domestic welding materials with equivalent performance is a strategic priority for the Chinese roll hardfacing industry.
The authors suggest that the development of welding materials with independent intellectual property rights is the way forward. This requires a systematic approach to alloy design, with a focus on the specific wear mechanisms that occur in roll service. The materials must also be compatible with the welding process, whether it is submerged arc welding, electroslag welding, or open arc welding.
Process: The Need for Expert Systems
The welding process for roll hardfacing is complex, with many interacting parameters. The welding current, voltage, speed, preheat temperature, interpass temperature, and the composition of the welding material all affect the quality of the deposit. The authors argue that the development of a welding process expert system is essential to improve the quality and reduce the time required for process development.
An expert system would encode the knowledge of experienced welding engineers and provide guidance on the optimal parameters for a given application. It would also allow the process to be optimised for specific roll materials and service conditions. I have seen the value of such a system in my own work. When we developed a new hardfacing procedure for a high-speed steel roll, we had to conduct dozens of trial welds to find the optimal parameters. An expert system would have reduced this to a few trials, saving both time and material.
The authors also mention the importance of developing clean, low-consumption and flexible hardfacing processes. This is a reference to the growing interest in laser cladding and other advanced processes that offer higher deposition rates and lower heat input. Laser cladding is particularly attractive for roll hardfacing because it produces a deposit with a fine microstructure and minimal dilution. However, the equipment is expensive and the process is not yet widely used in China.
A Practical Perspective
This paper is a useful review of the state of the art in roll hardfacing, but it is important to recognise that it was published in 2010. The situation has improved since then, but many of the challenges identified by the authors are still relevant. The need for automated equipment, domestic materials and process expert systems is still a priority.
From my experience, the most important factor in roll hardfacing is not the equipment or the materials, but the process control. A well-designed process with consistent parameters will produce a high-quality deposit, even with relatively simple equipment. Conversely, a poorly controlled process will produce a defective deposit, even with the best equipment and materials. The authors are correct to emphasise the need for an expert system, but I would also emphasise the need for a robust quality control system that includes dimensional inspection, hardness testing, ultrasonic testing and dye penetrant testing.
Final Thoughts
Roll hardfacing is a mature technology, but it is still evolving. The development of new materials, new processes and new equipment will continue to improve the performance and reduce the cost of roll hardfacing. The key to success is to understand the wear mechanisms that occur in roll service and to select the appropriate material and process for the specific application. The paper by Zhang Yingyue and colleagues provides a good foundation for this understanding, and it is a valuable reference for any engineer who is involved in roll hardfacing. The future of roll hardfacing lies in automation, material innovation and process optimisation, and the industry must invest in these areas to remain competitive.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd