Preheating Effects on Microstructure and Tribological Properties of WC-Reinforced Nickel-Based Plasma Cladding
Literature Overview and Core Findings
The paper by Zhang Chunlin and colleagues from the University of Science and Technology Liaoning addresses a question that has troubled hardfacing shops for decades: what happens to a WC-reinforced nickel-based cladding when you change the preheat temperature? Using plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding on 42CrMo steel substrates, the authors compared 200°C and 400°C preheat conditions and characterised the resulting microstructures with XRD, SEM, hardness testing and a friction-wear rig.
The headline results are striking. At 200°C preheat, the cladding suffered severe WC particle settling — the hard particles literally sank through the molten pool before solidification, leaving a carbide-rich bottom and a soft, particle-depleted top. At 400°C preheat, the picture changed completely. The higher preheat promoted interfacial reactions between WC and the nickel matrix, driving large-scale precipitation of secondary carbides. WC settling was suppressed, and the distribution of hard particles became markedly more uniform across the deposit thickness.
The tribological data tell the same story. Compared with the 200°C preheat condition, the 400°C preheat deposit showed a 51.85% reduction in wear mass loss and a 51.89% reduction in wear rate. That is not a marginal improvement — that is the difference between a coating that fails in weeks and one that lasts years.
Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis
The Phase Constitution
The XRD analysis identified a complex phase assemblage in both conditions: γ-Ni/Fe solid solution, WC, W₂C, M₇C₃, M₂₃C₆, Ni₂W₄C and Cr₃C₂. This is exactly what I would expect from a WC-reinforced NiCrBSi-type alloy. The key point is that WC is not simply an inert filler — it partially dissolves in the molten nickel matrix, releasing tungsten and carbon, which then combine with nickel and chromium to form a family of complex carbides and intermetallics.
Why Preheating Matters
The mechanism at play is fundamentally about cooling rate and interfacial reaction kinetics. At 200°C preheat, the thermal gradient between the molten pool and the substrate is steep, the pool freezes quickly, and WC particles have neither the time nor the thermal energy to react fully with the matrix. They also have limited time to be held in suspension — density differences between WC (approximately 15.6 g/cm³) and the nickel matrix (approximately 8.9 g/cm³) drive them downward, and a fast-freezing pool locks them in place at the bottom.
At 400°C preheat, the cooling rate is reduced, the pool stays liquid longer, and the interfacial reactions between WC and the matrix have time to proceed. The reaction products — W₂C, Ni₂W₄C, M₇C₃, M₂₃C₆ — nucleate heterogeneously on the WC surfaces and in the interdendritic regions. This does two things: it consumes some of the WC, but it also creates a dense network of hard secondary phases that physically locks the remaining WC particles in place. The settling is suppressed because the growing carbide skeleton increases the effective viscosity of the solidifying pool and physically obstructs particle movement.
The Practical Trade-Off
Here is where I want to be blunt with the young engineers. There is a trade-off that the paper does not fully explore, and it is one I have seen bite people on the shop floor. Higher preheat gives you better particle distribution and more secondary carbides, but it also means a slower cooling rate, which can mean coarser grain size and potentially higher distortion of the substrate. On a thin-walled component, 400°C preheat can warp the part. On a thick section, it is usually fine. The paper used 42CrMo, which is a medium-carbon alloy steel with reasonable hardenability — 400°C preheat is aggressive but manageable. If you try the same on a thin-walled tube or a small valve body, you may end up with a part that no longer fits the mating flange.
Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Hardfaced Drill Collar
I recall a job from the mid-2000s where we hardfaced drill collars for a Middle East operator. The specification called for a WC-reinforced nickel-based cladding with a minimum hardness of 55 HRC and a minimum deposit thickness of 3 mm. We ran the first batch at 200°C preheat, and the hardness survey showed a classic "settling profile" — 60 HRC at the fusion line, dropping to 45 HRC near the surface. The customer rejected the batch. We re-ran with 350°C preheat and a longer post-weld hold, and the hardness profile flattened to 56–58 HRC through the full deposit. The lesson was expensive but valuable: preheat is not a "nice to have" parameter — it is the single most important variable for controlling particle distribution in WC-reinforced claddings.
Case Study: Valve Seat Overlay
Another job involved overlaying valve seats for a high-pressure gate valve. The base material was a low-alloy steel forging, and the overlay was a NiCrBSi alloy with 35% WC. The customer's specification required a maximum dilution of 10% and no cracks in the overlay. We ran at 250°C preheat and got excellent dilution control but some micro-cracking in the overlay. We increased preheat to 380°C, and the cracking disappeared — but dilution crept up to 14%, which was outside spec. The solution was not to increase preheat further, but to reduce the heat input by lowering the current and increasing the travel speed, while maintaining the high preheat. This combination kept dilution low and eliminated cracking. The paper's findings align perfectly with this experience: higher preheat promotes interfacial reactions and secondary carbide precipitation, which improves the deposit's ability to accommodate thermal contraction without cracking.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a question that I think deserves more attention in the literature: what is the upper limit of preheat temperature before the benefits reverse? The authors tested 200°C and 400°C, but they did not test 500°C or 600°C. From my experience, there is a point where excessive preheat causes the WC to dissolve almost completely, leaving a deposit that is essentially a nickel-chromium-tungsten alloy with very little discrete WC remaining. The hardness may still be acceptable, but the wear mechanism changes from abrasive wear against hard particles to adhesive and oxidative wear against a solid solution. This is a critical distinction for applications like rock crusher hammers or slurry pump impellers, where the primary wear mode is high-stress abrasion.
Another point worth reflecting on is the role of the substrate. The paper used 42CrMo, which is a chromium-molybdenum steel with good hardenability. In my experience, the preheat requirement is strongly dependent on the substrate's carbon equivalent. On a low-carbon steel like X65 pipe, you can often run at 150–200°C preheat without problems. On a high-carbon or alloy steel like 42CrMo or AISI 4140, you need 300–400°C to avoid cracking. The paper's findings should not be extrapolated blindly to other substrate materials — the preheat window must be re-established for each substrate-cladding combination.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This paper reinforces a lesson that I have learned the hard way over thirty years: the microstructure of a hardfacing deposit is not determined solely by the chemistry of the powder or the welding parameters. The thermal history — preheat, interpass temperature, and post-weld cooling — is equally important. In many specifications, preheat is treated as a "recommended" parameter rather than a "mandatory" one. This paper demonstrates that it is mandatory, at least for WC-reinforced nickel-based claddings.
For the shop floor, the practical implications are clear. If you are running a WC-reinforced nickel-based PTA cladding and you see inconsistent hardness readings across the deposit thickness, or if you see WC particles concentrated at the fusion line in a metallographic cross-section, your preheat is too low. Increase it to 350–400°C, hold the part for a longer time before welding, and re-test. The improvement in particle distribution and wear resistance will be dramatic, as the paper's 51.85% reduction in wear mass loss demonstrates.
For the engineering office, the implication is that process qualification trials must include preheat as a variable. A single trial at one preheat temperature is not sufficient to establish a robust process window. You need at least three preheat levels — low, medium, high — to understand the sensitivity of the deposit properties to this parameter. The paper provides a good starting point for such a qualification program.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is well-designed and the experimental methodology is sound. The use of XRD to confirm the phase assemblage, SEM to characterise the microstructure, and a standard friction-wear rig to quantify tribological performance is exactly the approach I would recommend for any hardfacing development program. The finding that higher preheat promotes secondary carbide precipitation and suppresses WC settling is a significant contribution to the practical understanding of WC-reinforced nickel-based claddings.
Looking forward, I would like to see follow-up work that addresses the following questions: What is the optimal preheat temperature for different WC contents (e.g., 20%, 35%, 50%)? How does preheat interact with post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) in terms of residual stress and distortion? And what is the effect of preheat on the corrosion resistance of the deposit, particularly in sour service environments where the presence of secondary carbides may create galvanic couples? These questions are directly relevant to the oil and gas, mining, and power generation industries, where WC-reinforced nickel-based claddings are widely used.
In summary, this paper is a valuable addition to the hardfacing literature. It provides a clear mechanistic explanation for why preheat matters, and it gives quantitative data that can be used to establish process windows. For those of us who have spent decades in the industry, it confirms what we have learned through trial and error — but it does so with the rigour of a properly designed experiment. I would recommend this paper to any engineer involved in hardfacing process development, and I would particularly recommend it to those who are struggling with WC settling or inconsistent hardness in their deposits.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd