Microstructure and Low-Temperature Wear Resistance of Spherical WC-Reinforced Co-Based Surfacing Coatings
Overview and the Polar Steel Context
This paper from 2022, published in Surface Technology, deals with a topic that is increasingly relevant as the world turns its attention to polar shipping and Arctic development. The authors are from Shanghai Maritime University and Guangzhou Maritime College, and the work is funded by the National Key R&D Program and the National Natural Science Foundation. The goal is to improve the wear resistance of low-temperature steel E32, which is used in polar ship hulls and other cold-weather applications.
The authors use plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing to deposit spherical WC-reinforced cobalt-based coatings on E32 steel. The WC content is varied in three groups, and the coatings are tested for friction and wear at -20°C. The results are compared with the base E32 steel.
Coating Fabrication and Microstructure
The PTA process is a well-established method for depositing hardfacing coatings. It uses a transferred arc to melt the substrate and the filler material, creating a metallurgical bond. The authors use a cobalt-based powder with spherical WC particles added in different weight percentages.
The microstructure analysis reveals that the coatings contain a variety of hard phases: WC, W2C, Cr23C6, Cr7C3, Co6W6C, and Fe6W6C. These carbides provide the hardness and wear resistance. The spherical WC particles are particularly effective because they are uniformly distributed and they resist pull-out during wear.
| Coating | WC Content (wt.%) | Hard Phases | Wear Mechanism |
|---|---|---|---|
| Co-based | 0 | Cr23C6, Cr7C3, Co6W6C, Fe6W6C | Abrasive and adhesive wear |
| Co-based + WC | 30 | WC, W2C + above carbides | Three-body abrasive wear |
| Co-based + WC | 60 | WC, W2C + above carbides | Three-body abrasive wear |
Low-Temperature Wear Performance and Mechanisms
The wear tests are conducted at -20°C with a load of 50 N and a sliding speed of 20 mm/s for 2 hours. The results show that all three coatings have lower friction coefficients and lower volumetric wear rates than the base E32 steel. The wear track width and depth are also smaller.
The key finding is that the wear resistance increases with WC content. The coating without WC has the lowest wear resistance, and the coating with 60% WC has the highest. The wear mechanism changes with WC content. The coating without WC shows abrasive and adhesive wear, which means that material is removed by both hard particles and by adhesion between the sliding surfaces. The coatings with 30% and 60% WC show three-body abrasive wear, which means that the hard WC particles are embedded in the matrix and act as abrasives, removing material from the counterface.
The improvement in wear resistance is attributed to the combination of hard phases. The WC and W2C provide primary hardness, while the Cr23C6, Cr7C3, Co6W6C, and Fe6W6C provide secondary hardening. The spherical WC particles are particularly effective because they are uniformly distributed and they resist pull-out.
Practical Application Insights for Polar Ship Repair
This paper has direct implications for the repair and life extension of polar ship components. The E32 steel is used in hull plates, and it is subject to wear from ice, sand, and other abrasive materials. The PTA-surfaced WC-reinforced Co-based coating can significantly improve the wear resistance and extend the service life of these components.
From a practical standpoint, the PTA process is well-suited for this application. It produces a thick, dense coating with a strong metallurgical bond to the substrate. The coating can be applied to localized areas that are subject to wear, such as the ice belt of a hull or the leading edges of rudders and propellers.
However, there are some practical considerations. The PTA process requires careful control of the welding parameters to ensure a sound deposit with minimal dilution. Excessive dilution can reduce the WC content and degrade the wear resistance. The coating also needs to be applied in multiple passes to achieve the desired thickness, and the interpass temperature must be controlled to avoid cracking.
The low-temperature performance is also important. At -20°C, the steel is more brittle, and the coating must be able to withstand the impact and abrasion without cracking or spalling. The paper shows that the coatings perform well at -20°C, which is a positive indicator for their use in polar applications.
Summary
This paper is a strong contribution to the field of surface engineering for low-temperature applications. The authors have demonstrated that PTA-surfaced spherical WC-reinforced Co-based coatings can significantly improve the wear resistance of E32 steel at -20°C. The coatings are dense, hard, and resistant to wear, and the wear resistance increases with WC content.
The practical lesson is that the selection of a surfacing material for polar applications requires careful consideration of the service environment, the wear mechanism, and the coating properties. The PTA process is a viable method for applying these coatings, but it requires skilled operators and careful process control. The paper provides valuable data on the performance of these coatings at low temperatures, and it is a useful reference for anyone involved in the repair and life extension of polar ship components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd