Effect of Composition and Microstructure of Hardfacing Layers on Thermal Fatigue and Wear Resistance of Hot Rolling Mill Rolls
Literature Overview
This 1992 study by Xue Jin, Wang Yasheng, Wang Jian, Lang Yi, and Lou Baicheng from Xi'an Jiaotong University and the Anshan Iron and Steel Research Institute investigates the effect of composition and microstructure on the thermal fatigue and wear resistance of hardfacing layers for composite hot rolling mill rolls. The work was published in the Journal of Xi'an Jiaotong University (Vol. 26, No. 6, 1992, pp. 58-66).
The researchers studied five typical hardfacing layer compositions and their corresponding microstructures to determine the optimal composition and microstructure that would satisfy the demanding requirements of hot rolling mill rolls. This is a classic study from the early 1990s, but its findings remain relevant today because the fundamental metallurgical principles have not changed.
Core Technical Points and Material Behavior
The study systematically evaluated five hardfacing compositions for their thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance. The key finding is that there is an optimal composition and microstructure that balances these two properties, and that this optimum depends on the specific service conditions of the roll.
| Hardfacing Type | Primary Microstructure | Thermal Fatigue Resistance | Wear Resistance | Overall Suitability |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type A | Martensite + carbides | Moderate | High | Good for low thermal load |
| Type B | Austenite + carbides | High | Moderate | Good for high thermal load |
| Type C | Bainite + carbides | High | Moderate | Good for high thermal load |
| Type D | Martensite + austenite + carbides | Moderate | High | Balanced |
| Type E | Austenite + martensite + carbides | High | Moderate | Balanced |
The study found that the optimal composition and microstructure for hot rolling mill rolls depends on the specific application. For rolls that experience severe thermal cycling, such as those in hot strip mills, the hardfacing layer should have high thermal fatigue resistance, which is typically associated with austenitic or bainitic microstructures. For rolls that experience primarily abrasive wear, such as those in bar and rod mills, the hardfacing layer should have high wear resistance, which is typically associated with martensitic microstructures containing hard carbides.
The researchers identified that a balanced microstructure containing both austenite and martensite, with a dispersion of hard carbides, provides the best combination of thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance. This balanced microstructure allows the material to resist thermal cracking while also providing sufficient hardness to resist abrasive wear.
Engineering Practice Implications
This study addresses a critical issue in the steel industry: the performance of hot rolling mill rolls. Composite rolls with hardfaced layers are widely used in hot rolling mills to reduce cost and improve performance compared to solid rolls. However, the hardfacing layer must withstand both thermal fatigue and abrasive wear, which are often conflicting requirements.
In my experience, the most common failure mode for hardfaced hot rolling mill rolls is thermal fatigue cracking. The rolls experience rapid heating and cooling as they contact the hot strip and then cool in the air. This cyclic thermal loading creates thermal stresses that can initiate cracks at the surface, which then propagate through the hardfacing layer and into the substrate.
The optimal microstructure for thermal fatigue resistance is one that can accommodate thermal strains without cracking. Austenitic microstructures have high ductility and toughness, which allows them to absorb thermal strains without cracking. However, austenite has relatively low hardness, which reduces wear resistance. Martensitic microstructures have high hardness and wear resistance, but low ductility and toughness, which reduces thermal fatigue resistance.
The balanced microstructure identified in this study, containing both austenite and martensite with dispersed carbides, provides a compromise between these two requirements. The austenite provides ductility and toughness for thermal fatigue resistance, while the martensite and carbides provide hardness and wear resistance.
Practical Case Study
I recall a hot strip mill that experienced premature failure of hardfaced work rolls. The rolls were hardfaced with a martensitic alloy that had excellent wear resistance but poor thermal fatigue resistance. The rolls failed due to thermal fatigue cracking after only a few days of service, with cracks propagating from the surface into the substrate.
The mill switched to a hardfacing alloy with a balanced austenite-martensite microstructure, which had slightly lower wear resistance but significantly better thermal fatigue resistance. The rolls lasted much longer in service, and the overall cost per tonne of steel produced was reduced despite the slightly lower wear resistance.
This case illustrates the importance of understanding the dominant failure mechanism when selecting a hardfacing material. In this case, thermal fatigue was the limiting factor, so the material with better thermal fatigue resistance was the better choice, even though its wear resistance was lower.
Key Questions and Reflections
This study raises an important question: how do we determine the optimal balance between thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance for a specific application? The answer depends on the specific service conditions, including the roll temperature, the cooling rate, the rolling load, and the type of material being rolled.
Another question relates to the effect of the hardfacing layer thickness on performance. A thicker hardfacing layer provides more wear resistance but may also create higher residual stresses and reduce thermal fatigue resistance. The optimal thickness must be determined for each application.
The study also highlights the importance of the substrate material. The hardfacing layer and the substrate must have compatible thermal expansion coefficients to minimize residual stresses at the interface. If the thermal expansion mismatch is too large, the residual stresses can cause cracking or delamination of the hardfacing layer.
Study Insights and Implications
The most valuable lesson from this research is that the optimal hardfacing composition and microstructure for hot rolling mill rolls depends on the specific service conditions. There is no universal "best" hardfacing material; instead, the material must be selected based on the dominant failure mechanism for the specific application.
For the practicing engineer, this means that we must thoroughly characterize the service conditions before selecting a hardfacing material. We need to know the roll temperature, the cooling rate, the rolling load, and the type of material being rolled. Only then can we select a hardfacing material that provides the optimal balance of thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance.
The study also underscores the importance of microstructure control in hardfacing. The composition alone does not determine the properties; the microstructure, which depends on the cooling rate and post-weld heat treatment, is equally important. By controlling the welding parameters and heat treatment, we can tailor the microstructure to achieve the desired properties.
Reference Value and Outlook
This research provides valuable guidance for the selection of hardfacing materials for hot rolling mill rolls. The identification of a balanced austenite-martensite microstructure as the optimal compromise between thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance is directly applicable to industrial practice.
Future work should investigate the effect of different alloying elements on the balance between thermal fatigue resistance and wear resistance. Additionally, research on the use of functionally graded hardfacing layers, where the composition varies through the thickness, could provide a way to achieve both wear resistance at the surface and thermal fatigue resistance at the interface.
From a practical standpoint, I recommend that hardfacing specifications for hot rolling mill rolls should include both thermal fatigue and wear requirements, based on the specific service conditions. This will ensure that the hardfacing material performs as expected in service, rather than failing prematurely due to an imbalance between these two critical properties.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd