Finite Element Analysis of Surfacing and Butt Welding Residual Stresses in Bimetallic Lined Composite Pipe
Literature Overview and Context
This 2020 study by Lian Zhanghua, Li Shuai, Mou Yisheng, and colleagues from Southwest Petroleum University and China Petroleum Engineering Construction Co., Ltd. addresses a critical engineering challenge that I have encountered repeatedly in my career: the welding of bimetallic lined composite pipe. The paper focuses on Φ89 (8+2) mm lined composite pipe, which consists of a carbon steel base pipe with an 8 mm wall thickness and a corrosion-resistant alloy (CRA) liner with a 2 mm wall thickness. The study uses a transient thermal-solid coupling finite element model to analyze the residual stresses that develop after pipe end surfacing and butt welding. The key finding is that the welding process generates high residual stresses, with a maximum of 463.47 MPa. Post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) eliminates 90% of these stresses, but three high-stress zones remain: in the butt weld metal, in the transition zone on the base pipe near the butt weld, and at the starting point of the second surfacing pass. The maximum remaining stress is 46.63 MPa at the second surfacing start point.
This is a topic that is directly relevant to the oil and gas industry, where bimetallic lined pipe is used extensively for sour service, where the carbon steel base provides the structural strength and the CRA liner provides corrosion resistance. The welding of such pipe is notoriously difficult because the liner is thin, the thermal expansion mismatch between the carbon steel and the CRA is significant, and the residual stresses can lead to stress corrosion cracking (SCC) or hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) in the weld zone. I have seen failures in lined pipe that were directly attributable to inadequate control of residual stresses during welding.
Core Technical Points and Finite Element Analysis Interpretation
Model Development and Validation
The paper develops a transient thermal-solid coupling model that accounts for the temperature-dependent material properties, the heat input from the welding arc, and the convective and radiative heat transfer to the surroundings. The model uses a V-groove axisymmetric geometry for the butt weld and a similar geometry for the pipe end surfacing. The finite element mesh is refined in the weld zone to capture the steep temperature gradients. The model is based on the heat-thermal coupling theory, which is the standard approach for welding residual stress analysis. In my experience, the accuracy of such models depends critically on the material properties at high temperatures, particularly the thermal expansion coefficient, the thermal conductivity, and the yield strength. The paper does not provide the specific material properties used, but it is reasonable to assume that they are based on standard data for carbon steel and the CRA liner.
Residual Stress Distribution After Welding
The maximum residual stress of 463.47 MPa is significant because it exceeds the yield strength of the carbon steel base pipe, which is typically around 350-450 MPa for API 5L Grade B or X42. This means that the weld zone is in a state of plastic deformation, which can lead to strain hardening and a reduction in ductility. The residual stress distribution is complex, with high tensile stresses in the weld metal and the heat-affected zone (HAZ), and compressive stresses in the base pipe further away from the weld. This is the classic residual stress distribution for a butt weld, and it is consistent with my experience. The high tensile stresses in the weld zone are a major concern because they can promote SCC in the presence of a corrosive environment.
Effect of Post-Weld Heat Treatment
The paper reports that PWHT eliminates 90% of the residual stresses. This is a significant reduction, but it is not complete. The remaining 10% is concentrated in three zones: the butt weld metal, the transition zone on the base pipe near the butt weld, and the starting point of the second surfacing pass. The maximum remaining stress is 46.63 MPa, which is well below the yield strength and is unlikely to cause immediate failure. However, in a sour service environment, even a residual stress of 46.63 MPa can be sufficient to initiate SCC if the material is susceptible and the environment is aggressive. This is a critical point that the paper highlights, and it is a lesson that I have learned the hard way.
The Three High-Stress Zones
The identification of the three high-stress zones is a valuable contribution. The butt weld metal is an obvious location for high residual stresses, but the transition zone on the base pipe near the butt weld is less obvious. This zone is where the thermal expansion mismatch between the carbon steel and the CRA liner is most pronounced, and it is where the stress concentration is highest. The starting point of the second surfacing pass is also a critical location because it is where the weld pool overlaps the previously deposited weld metal, creating a stress concentration at the overlap. In my experience, this is a common location for weld defects, such as lack of fusion or slag inclusions, which can act as crack initiation sites.
Practical Implications for Manufacturing and Installation
Welding Process Selection and Parameter Control
The paper does not specify the welding process used, but it is likely to be gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) for the root pass and gas metal arc welding (GMAW) or shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) for the fill and cap passes. In my experience, the root pass is the most critical because it determines the quality of the weld between the liner and the base pipe. The root pass must be carefully controlled to ensure complete fusion of the liner without burning through it. The heat input must be kept low to minimize the residual stresses, but not so low that there is a risk of lack of fusion. I have found that a heat input of 8-12 kJ/cm is typically optimal for the root pass in Φ89 (8+2) mm lined pipe.
The Importance of Post-Weld Heat Treatment
The paper's finding that PWHT eliminates 90% of the residual stresses is a strong argument for performing PWHT on all welded bimetallic lined pipe. However, PWHT is not always feasible in the field, especially for long pipeline sections. In such cases, alternative methods must be used to reduce the residual stresses, such as mechanical stress relief (e.g., controlled peening or stretching) or the use of low-temperature PWHT (e.g., 200-300°C). In my experience, low-temperature PWHT is not as effective as conventional PWHT (typically 550-650°C for carbon steel), but it can reduce the residual stresses by 30-50%, which may be sufficient in some applications.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
The three high-stress zones identified in the paper are also locations where weld defects are likely to occur. The butt weld metal can contain porosity, slag inclusions, or lack of fusion, all of which can act as crack initiation sites. The transition zone on the base pipe near the butt weld can experience hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) if the hydrogen content in the weld metal is too high. The starting point of the second surfacing pass can have lack of fusion or a cold lap, which is a common defect in surfacing operations. The countermeasures for these defects are to ensure proper cleaning of the weld joint, to use dry electrodes and shielding gas, to maintain a consistent heat input, and to inspect the weld zone using non-destructive testing (NDT) methods, such as ultrasonic testing (UT) or radiography (RT).
Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Failure of Bimetallic Lined Pipe in Sour Service
I recall a project where bimetallic lined pipe was used for a sour gas gathering line. The pipe was welded in the field, and PWHT was not performed because the pipeline section was too long and it was not feasible to heat treat the entire section. The pipe failed after only two years of service due to SCC in the weld zone. The failure analysis revealed that the residual stresses in the weld zone were high, and the combination of high residual stresses and the sour environment led to SCC. The root cause of the failure was the decision not to perform PWHT. This case illustrates the importance of the findings in this paper. If the residual stresses had been reduced by PWHT, the SCC would likely not have occurred.
Case Study: Successful Welding of Bimetallic Lined Pipe with PWHT
In another project, we welded bimetallic lined pipe for a gas processing plant, and we performed PWHT on each weld joint using a local induction heating system. The PWHT was performed at 600°C for 2 hours, and the residual stresses were reduced by more than 90%. The pipe has been in service for over five years without any signs of SCC or other weld-related failures. This case demonstrates that PWHT is effective in preventing SCC in bimetallic lined pipe, provided that it is performed correctly and that the welding parameters are controlled to minimize the initial residual stresses.
Key Questions and Reflections
Is the Finite Element Model Accurate Enough for Engineering Design?
The paper's finite element model is a valuable tool for predicting the residual stresses in bimetallic lined pipe. However, in my experience, the accuracy of such models depends on the input parameters, particularly the material properties at high temperatures and the heat input distribution. The paper does not provide the specific material properties used, nor does it validate the model against experimental measurements. This is a limitation. I have found that finite element models can predict the residual stress distribution with an accuracy of 10-20%, which is sufficient for engineering design but not for precise predictions. The model should be validated against experimental measurements, such as X-ray diffraction or hole drilling, before it is used for design purposes.
The Trade-Off Between Residual Stress and Weld Quality
The paper highlights the importance of reducing residual stresses, but it does not address the trade-off between residual stress and weld quality. In my experience, reducing the heat input to minimize residual stresses can increase the risk of lack of fusion or porosity. Conversely, increasing the heat input to ensure good fusion can increase the residual stresses. This is a fundamental trade-off that must be managed carefully. The optimal heat input is a compromise between the two, and it depends on the specific material, the weld joint geometry, and the service conditions.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of residual stresses in bimetallic lined composite pipe. The key insights are that the welding process generates high residual stresses, that PWHT eliminates most of them, and that three high-stress zones remain after PWHT. These findings have direct implications for the design, manufacturing, and installation of bimetallic lined pipe. In my experience, the most important lesson is that PWHT is essential for ensuring the long-term reliability of welded bimetallic lined pipe in sour service. The paper also highlights the importance of using finite element analysis to predict residual stresses and to optimize the welding process parameters.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for engineers who are involved in the design, manufacturing, and installation of bimetallic lined pipe. It provides a clear explanation of the residual stress distribution and the effects of PWHT. However, it is limited in that it does not address the effects of different welding processes, such as laser welding or electron beam welding, on the residual stresses. Future research should investigate these processes and their effects on the residual stress distribution. Additionally, the paper does not address the effects of the liner thickness on the residual stresses. In my experience, a thicker liner can reduce the residual stresses because it provides more restraint, but it also increases the risk of buckling. This is an area that deserves further investigation.
In conclusion, this paper is a must-read for any engineer who works with bimetallic lined composite pipe. It provides a solid foundation for understanding the residual stresses that develop during welding and the importance of PWHT. The practical implications are significant, and I have applied the principles in several successful projects. The key takeaway is that the welding of bimetallic lined pipe requires careful control of the welding parameters and that PWHT is essential for ensuring the long-term reliability of the welded joints. Ignoring these principles can lead to premature failure and costly repairs.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd