ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Properties of TiC Particle Reinforced Composite Coating by Submerged Arc Surfacing

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Liu Junhai and colleagues from Beijing University of Science and Technology and other institutions investigates the in-situ synthesis of TiC particle reinforced Fe-based composite coatings using alloy powder submerged arc surfacing on Q235 steel. The raw materials are TiFe powder, Cr powder, Ni powder, Fe powder, and colloidal graphite. The results show that TiC particles with a size below 2 μm are synthesized in-situ and dispersed uniformly in the coating. The coating microstructure consists of TiC particles, martensite, and austenite. The average microhardness is 601 HV0.2, about three times that of the carbon steel substrate. The wear mass loss of the coating is about one-tenth that of the substrate. The double-layer coating has better wear resistance than the single-layer coating, with less martensite and more austenite and TiC.

Metallurgical Analysis and Practical Implications

The in-situ synthesis of TiC particles is a clever approach to creating a metal matrix composite. The TiC particles are formed by the reaction between TiFe and graphite during the surfacing process. The particles are fine (below 2 μm) and uniformly distributed, which is ideal for wear resistance. The coating consists of TiC particles in a martensitic-austenitic matrix. The martensite provides hardness, while the austenite provides toughness. The combination of TiC and martensite gives excellent wear resistance, as evidenced by the wear mass loss being one-tenth that of the substrate. The table below summarizes the key properties.

Property Single-Layer Coating Double-Layer Coating Substrate (Q235)
Microhardness (HV0.2) ~601 Similar or higher ~200
Wear Mass Loss ~1/10 of substrate Lower than single-layer Baseline
TiC Content Moderate Higher N/A
Martensite Content Higher Lower N/A
Austenite Content Lower Higher N/A

The double-layer coating has better wear resistance because it has more TiC and austenite. This is counterintuitive at first, because martensite is harder than austenite. However, in a composite coating, the TiC particles are the primary wear-resistant phase. The austenite matrix provides toughness and holds the TiC particles in place. The martensite is harder but more brittle, and it can crack under high-stress abrasion. The double-layer coating also has a more uniform distribution of TiC, because the first layer provides a base for the second layer to nucleate and grow TiC particles.

Shop Floor Application and Delivery Considerations

For the shop floor, this coating is a strong candidate for applications requiring high wear resistance, such as chutes, hoppers, and conveyor components. The submerged arc process is well-suited for large, flat surfaces, and the alloy powder feed system can be integrated into the existing equipment. However, the process is more complex than conventional submerged arc welding, because you need to feed the alloy powder in addition to the wire. The powder feed rate must be carefully controlled to maintain the correct TiC content. In my experience, the in-situ synthesis of TiC is sensitive to the heat input. If the heat input is too low, the reaction may not go to completion, leaving unreacted TiFe and graphite. If the heat input is too high, the TiC particles may coarsen or dissolve. The authors used a double-layer coating, which is a good practice for thick deposits, but it doubles the processing time and cost.

Key Questions and Reflections

The authors report that the wear mass loss of the coating is about one-tenth that of the substrate. This is a significant improvement, but I would like to see the wear test conditions. The authors used a "room temperature dry sliding wear test," which is a simple test. In practice, many wear applications involve abrasive particles, impact, or corrosion. The coating may perform differently under three-body abrasion or impact. The authors also do not report on the adhesion between the coating and the substrate. In my experience, the interface is the weak link in composite coatings. If the TiC particles are not well-bonded to the matrix, they can be pulled out during wear, accelerating the wear rate. The authors do not discuss the effect of the substrate on the coating. Q235 is a low-carbon steel, which is a good substrate for surfacing. However, if the substrate is a high-carbon steel or a cast iron, the HAZ may become martensitic and crack.

Study Insights and Implications

This study is a valuable contribution to the practical design of wear-resistant composite coatings. The key insight is that in-situ synthesis of TiC particles is a viable route to creating a metal matrix composite with excellent wear resistance. The double-layer coating approach is particularly interesting, because it allows you to build up a thick deposit with a high TiC content and a tough austenitic matrix. For my own operations, I would consider this coating for applications such as chute liners, hopper walls, and conveyor components in mining and cement plants. However, I would conduct a thorough qualification program before committing to large-scale production. This would include chemical composition analysis, microhardness mapping, metallographic examination, wear testing under actual service conditions, and field trials. The cost of a failed coating is high, but the cost of a qualification program is low by comparison. I would also recommend that the coating be applied by a qualified operator with experience in alloy powder submerged arc surfacing, because the process is sensitive to parameter variations.