Effect of Heat Treatment on Microstructure and Mechanical Properties of Q345B Steel-Based Hardfacing Composite Plate
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Chen Youming and colleagues from Hunan University of Science and Technology and Baotou Steel examines the effect of three heat treatment processes (quenching, normalizing, and spray quenching + tempering) on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Q345B steel-based composite plates hardfaced with YD212 welding wire using CO2 gas shielded welding.
The results show that all three heat treatments alter the microstructure of both the fusion zone and the hardfacing layer, and also change the pearlite content in the base metal layer. The spray quenching + tempering treatment produces the best combination of properties: higher pearlite content in the base metal, significantly improved hardness and toughness, improved fusion zone toughness, and excellent hardfacing layer hardness. The impact absorption energy of the spray quenched + tempered composite plate is 1.57 times that of the untreated composite plate.
Technical Points and Metallurgical Interpretation
The heat treatment of hardfacing composite plates is a complex metallurgical problem because the plate consists of three distinct zones: the base metal (Q345B), the fusion zone, and the hardfacing layer (YD212). Each zone responds differently to heat treatment, and the optimal treatment must balance the requirements of all three.
| Heat Treatment | Base Metal Pearlite | Fusion Zone Toughness | Hardfacing Hardness | Overall Performance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| None (as-welded) | Low | Poor | Moderate | Baseline |
| Quenching | Medium | Moderate | High | Good hardness, moderate toughness |
| Normalizing | Low | Moderate | Moderate | Minimal improvement |
| Spray quenching + tempering | High | Good | Excellent | Best overall performance |
The spray quenching + tempering treatment is particularly effective because it achieves a balance between the base metal and the hardfacing layer. The spray quenching rapidly cools the surface, producing a fine-grained structure in the hardfacing layer and a martensitic structure in the base metal near the fusion zone. The subsequent tempering reduces the brittleness of the martensite while maintaining the hardness of the hardfacing layer.
The 1.57 times improvement in impact absorption energy is significant. This indicates that the fusion zone, which is typically the weakest link in composite plates, is substantially toughened by the spray quenching + tempering treatment. This is critical for applications where the composite plate is subjected to impact loading.
Engineering Practice and Field Application
This work has direct relevance to our industry in the production of composite plates for wear-resistant applications:
- Wear plates for pipe conveying systems: Composite plates are used as liners in chutes, hoppers, and pipe conveying systems. The improved toughness from spray quenching + tempering reduces the risk of cracking and spalling under impact.
- Hardfaced pipe mill components: The YD212 welding wire is a common hardfacing consumable for pipe mill rolls and guides. The heat treatment described in this paper can be applied to improve the performance of these components.
- Structural applications: In some cases, hardfaced composite plates are used in structural applications where both wear resistance and load-bearing capacity are required. The improved toughness of the fusion zone is critical for these applications.
From my experience with composite plates, the most common failure mode is delamination at the fusion zone. The fusion zone is typically the weakest link because it has a mixed microstructure with poor toughness. The spray quenching + tempering treatment addresses this directly by improving the fusion zone toughness.
One practical consideration is the size of the composite plate. Spray quenching is a surface treatment that is most effective on relatively thin plates. For thick plates, the cooling rate at the center may be insufficient to achieve the desired microstructure. The authors used a specific plate thickness, and the results may not be directly applicable to thicker plates.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper does not address the effect of heat treatment on the residual stress in the composite plate. Hardfacing typically introduces significant residual stresses due to the thermal cycle and the difference in thermal expansion between the hardfacing layer and the base metal. Heat treatment can redistribute these stresses, but the paper does not measure or discuss this.
I would also question the choice of YD212 welding wire. This is a common hardfacing wire, but it is not specifically designed for composite plate applications. The interaction between the YD212 deposit and the Q345B base metal during heat treatment may not be representative of other hardfacing wires.
Another practical issue is the cost and complexity of the heat treatment. Spray quenching + tempering requires specialized equipment and careful process control. For many applications, the improvement in properties may not justify the additional cost, and a simpler treatment such as stress relief may be sufficient.
Study Insights and Practical Implications
This work provides valuable guidance on heat treatment of hardfaced composite plates, which is a topic that is often overlooked in practice. The spray quenching + tempering treatment offers a significant improvement in toughness without sacrificing hardness, which is a difficult combination to achieve.
For our industry, the practical implications are:
- Heat treatment specification: When hardfaced composite plates are used in demanding applications, spray quenching + tempering should be considered as a post-weld treatment to improve toughness and reduce the risk of fusion zone failure.
- Process window: The specific parameters for spray quenching and tempering should be optimized for the plate thickness and the hardfacing alloy. The 1.57 times improvement in impact energy provides a target for process development.
- Quality control: Impact testing should be performed on the fusion zone to verify that the heat treatment has achieved the desired improvement. The 1.57 times improvement provides a clear acceptance criterion.
- Application selection: This treatment is most beneficial for applications involving impact loading, such as chute liners and hopper walls. For pure abrasion applications, the additional toughness may not be necessary.
The bottom line is that heat treatment of hardfaced composite plates is a critical step that is often ignored. The spray quenching + tempering treatment provides a significant improvement in toughness, which directly addresses the most common failure mode in composite plates. This treatment should be specified for applications where impact loading is expected, and the 1.57 times improvement in impact energy provides a clear target for process qualification.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd